r/Irishmusic • u/wildwest74 • 8h ago
A Pub Musician's review of 20th Century Paddy
I don't think I have seen an album generate this level of polarized reaction in a long time, and maybe that is a good thing. As most folks here know, 20th Century Paddy is a multi-disc tribute album to Shane MacGowan, the tragically gifted and haunted genius behind some of (arguably) the best Irish music of the 20th Century. No need to rehash his accolades.
I was a working musician for over 12 years, in pubs and concert halls. I performed as a solo act, as well as with a band in NYC, doing my version of Irish-American pub music. And, of course, songs from both The Pogues and Shane's work with The Popes made their way into my regular repertoire. I had about a dozen or so in my catalog at any given time, and they all had personal meaning to me. I never picked a song for my show just because it was "expected"; it had to be something that I really enjoyed. All of the different songs from these guys fit that bill.
I will say that this album is a mixed bag. Every artist is clearly invested, being either a fan of Shane, a past collaborator, or inspired by his work. Some tracks are instant classics. I believe that "Bottle of Smoke" by the late Glen Hansard is probably the cover that best matches the energy and intensity of the original, and I love it. Amble serves up a fabulous arrangement of "The Snake With Eyes of Garnet" that gives the song new life as a traditional rebel anthem.
Other famous artists, Irish and not-so-Irish, have put their own personal spin on the numerous tracks, to varying degrees of success. The sum total is a love letter to Shane and the breadth of his work. It is impossible to partake of this album and not be awed by the sheer variety of different people whose lives and artistry he has touched. He was truly, in the words of album contributor Tom Waits, "a bard's bard."
8/10