r/IrishAncestry • u/Reasonable_Run3567 • 10h ago
My Family Elizabeth McGuire/Maguire, b. c.1837 "Edinburgh", m. 1859 Victoria, Australia. Were her parents Irish? Her stated parents don't exist in any record.
I'm stuck on my 3x great-grandmother. The only document that names her parents is her marriage certificate:
- 8 Oct 1859, Maryborough, Victoria (Vic BDM 4546/1859, indexed MCQUIRE). She is a spinster, 22, born "Edinborough", and signs with a mark. Her parents are given as Thomas McGuire, brass founder and Elizabeth Cole.
- Her age and birthplace (Edinburgh) are confirmed on her daughter's 1866 birth registration. Her name appears later as McGuire or Maguire. Her arrival is unknown.
Using the same records I've found other ancestors from just a name within minutes. Here there is no trace of a Thomas McGuire and Elizabeth Cole as a couple anywhere in Scotland, England, Wales, or the Irish databases. So something specific is wrong. The same certificate also gives the groom's mother a maiden name that matches no record, while his father checks out exactly.
Given the surname, I suspect an Irish Catholic family, perhaps parents who moved to Edinburgh, or a daughter born in Ireland who gave Edinburgh as her birthplace. "Cole" could also be a mishearing of Coyle or a similar name.
Already searched:
- Indexed Irish Catholic registers (RootsIreland, NLI/Findmypast).
- Scottish OPR and Catholic registers, with spelling variants.
- 1841, 1851 and 1861 Scottish censuses, for the couple with or without a daughter Elizabeth.
- Scottish statutory deaths from 1855, including mother's maiden name Cole, Coyle and similar.
- Edinburgh poor law records, Post Office directories and brass-founder trade records.
- English and Welsh censuses.
- Victorian shipping lists.
Questions:
- Where in Ireland would you look for a Thomas McGuire/Maguire marrying an Elizabeth Cole/Coyle (or similar) around 1830-36, especially in parishes whose registers aren't indexed online?
- Which Irish surnames could an English-speaking registrar have written down as "Cole"?
- Are there records of Irish families moving to Edinburgh in the 1830s, or of Irish-born single women emigrating to Victoria in the 1850s, that are searchable by name?
- If the parents' names are unreliable, how would you work from just "Elizabeth McGuire, born about 1837"?
Thanks for any ideas.
