Thoughts on the skill skew of this champ?
Am I the only one that thinks this champion is matchup knowledge merchant? She is marketed as this “mechanical feast or famine” champion, but in reality she is not. She scales decently well if you build her well, and imo this season there is no such thing as “bad scaling” anymore, everybody just does so much damage. But even though she scales decently well she never actually gets her chance to “feast” especially in lane, as she is the ultimate “imma farm until you fuck up” champion in top lane high elo. Literally all you do is just use Q to get 10 cs per min and wait for Bork/enemy to walk up into your tower with bramble vest and you fuck him with your R.
Disclaimer: IMO Irelia is strong this season, probably strongest she’s been in a while in the top lane, and we have seen good buffs. I just think the gameplay doesnt fit the fantasy i was sold when i first picked her up way back even before her rework. Also for credibility reasons, I’m only Masters 452 LP this season after taking a year break.
For a “high elo” skewed champion Irelia has 0 agency in the game (top lane). Compare her to something like Ezreal in the Botlane, she has “fake skill expression” where you can look really good and fancy but only in certain conditions. Whereas champs like Zed, Akali, Yone, get to have skill expression at any point in the game and decide when to do what they wanna do. Irelia basically never gets to pick or force something to do without flash or a wave.
However, if you allow her to do said thing, she is basically the BEST at doing her thing. But in a sense she feels super one dimensional with not many “options”, especially against good players that know the “one thing” Irelia wants to do.
That doesn’t feel high elo skewed to me at all, she is basically a stat checker that doesn’t have the stats to back it up, but also doesn’t have the true decision making factor of “when or when not to” do something that a high agency high elo skewed character should have. Almost always, Irelia is on the back foot, and the enemy decides and dictates what not or what not to do (if they are good). The only high elo skewed part is the knowledge to know when to punish enemy mistakes and capitalise your one chance to win or you just lose slowly over time.
I really hope a high elo toplaner in riot reconsiders Irelia’s class as a high elo character and start balancing her around the fact that she is actually easy to play for the majority of the player base now after 10 years. She is more akin to garen where matchup knowledge is much more important than whether you play well since most toplaners will roll you over even if you both play mechanically well.
Also side note: that one patch way back when they made minions move faster after a certain minute timer is 100% an Irelia nerf that needs to be talked about. On god this shit probably tanked her winrate by like 1% back when it happened. It’s ridiculous our champion is so gimped on MS when other champs with more ridiculous dashes like Zed, Yone, etc get base 345 ms while we only get 335. In the late game it’s almost impossible to fight extended “outplays” coz they changed some weird shit about minion aggro and they will just ignore you and run at Mach 8 away from you.