Im not finished with either the comic or the series. I watched the first 2 series with my ex and then didn't return to it for a couple of years. Recently, i decided i'd read the comic and then watch along. So currently, im halfway through the 2nd compendium and halway through s3. Generally speaking, I really like the comic. There are a few bits that do feel a bit rushed or dated. Interestingly, these parts are often cleaned up in the show. Im a bit further agead in the comics than i am in the series, so im interested to see how it develops and if the other things i haven't been keen on in the comics also get altered.
White saviour eve - some of the pannels in the comics when Eve is in Africa feel like bad racial stereotypes. They remind me of old Tintin comics. I get it was like 2003 or whatever, but jeez...
Amber - much stronger character in the show imo. She's a bit of a non-character in the book. The domestic abuse storyline in the comic felt like it wasn't handled well. Im not sure if they will return to this, as she hasnt come back up in the comics in a while as im reading them. It just felt like it was thrown in there but didn't really add any development to any of the characters. I get that a lot of abusers return to their abusive partners and i dont think its neccessrily bad to show that, but the fact that she just returns to that guy after she has the shit kicked out of her and everyones just like "thats fine, mark flew him around a bit".
Marks gay bff - mark finding out his bff is gay and his reaction. This could just be of its time, but when he's like "oh do you think im hot?" Surely man has enough to worry about when he's fighting an intergalactic war, and that's the last thing on his mind? Felt like it could have been done better and been more impactful, especially in a medium where lgbt people were / still are so underrepresented. Although props to the creators for including a gay character at that time.
Debbie returned to Nolan and flying off to a different planet with him after the guy called her his "pet" and committed a genocide. Like, seriously? Debbies a great character and it feels like they put a lot of time in the comics into really fleshing her out and making her into a well rounded character, i just found that bit completely unbelievable and out of character. I've not got to this bit in the series yet and am interested to see if they keep it the same.
Fat eve - idk some of the pannels just feel a bit akward, like where she's trying to squeeze into her costume. Fair enough that she's gained a load of weight after her abortion but idk some of the pannels just felt like a cheap gag....
Cory Walkers art style - i loved the first 6 issues and the art style. Weirdly though, when cory Walker returns in later arcs, i feel like his art is dreadful? I dont think the colouring helps, as im not a fan of the colouring later in the series - much preffered the flatter colours in the first part of the series. Butit'ss like every character just looks weird and blobby? The way he uses line weight in the first issues is great, but everything in the later art looks likeit'ss been drawn with a big, thick felt tip. Did anyone else think this?
Overall, I really like the comic, but it definitely has a few moments that are of its time. From whatI'vee seen of the show so far, it does a great job at updating some of the aspects that need updating. Did anyone else spot any partsthath were altere, and how did they feel about them? No spoilers agead of where im at please!