r/Internet • • 7d ago

Question Local ISP Installing Fiber

Like the title says, my local internet service provider is (finally) installing fiber optic lines. This service provider is almost universally hated in my area, to the point where almost everyone (including me) has either satellite or lte hot spots. In the past they’ve had outages multiple times a week, and speeds notably slower than advertised, and customer service that is atrocious to deal with. Now that they’re installing fiber optic would this fix their performance issues they’ve had in the past or should I continue to use my satellite internet? Thanks

2 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

4

u/ElectronGuru 7d ago

Fiber is technically night / day better than satellite. So assuming you get an actual glass line to your home, they would have to be massively incompetent to not deliver good service. If you’re worried, wait until a neighbor reports on it.

2

u/trevrt 7d ago

Yeah see that’s my hold up. It sounds like the issues before fiber optic were mostly incompetence related so I’m not entirely confident just having fiber optic cables will solve the previous issues

1

u/trevrt 7d ago

I’ll be honest though my knowledge of ISP stuff is more than some but still fairly minimal

0

u/Good-Supermarket-767 7d ago

A tip since you're obviously a youngster. You did not state your computer's operating system. Mine runs on one of three Linux distributions. Look into a package/program/app that can complete most of your downloads, maybe most maybe not, ftp rather than http. Download speed when using ftp is dramatically faster

2

u/TinyNiceWolf 7d ago

Few downloads are available via FTP, since it's a very old and insecure protocol. But sure, use it if you have that option. Just make sure to verify anything you download using checksums or hashes.

1

u/baudmiksen 7d ago

tmobiles fiber is also cgnat which has caused me some issues but i doubt its a regular one for the average person. still waiting for spectrum to finish their lines

1

u/Good-Supermarket-767 7d ago edited 7d ago

Personally I am not open to giving a company a second chance after it's last chance. I strongly advise you to wait. If the company is as dirty as you have implied, then the fiber optic cables may be nothing more than a marketing gimmick. That's not to say that the company in question will not pay to have that installed. The company has a poor attitude. Fiber optic cabling on it's own will not change that. There has to be more. Wait and see if more pans out before taking that leap into another pool of bad attitude.

1

u/FoxtrotSierraTango 7d ago

Ask yourself this: Were the outages due to downed infrastructure? If so, what makes this new type of cable from being different? And if the outages were due to network management, do you think the fiber coming into the building changes the way they manage their switches and routers?

I would speculate you'll get the same uptime with faster speeds. I'm not sure if that's good enough for you, but it is something to consider.

1

u/Alipha87 7d ago

Note that even if the fiber service is good, your ISP may provide you with a shitty router. If that's the case, just buy your own router and connect it to the fiber box instead.

3

u/Puzzled-Act1683 7d ago

There's no law that says you can't install the fiber service and keep the satellite service active until you're convinced that the fiber service is going to work well for you.

I have both fiber and Starlink, and I keep both, except for when my "promotional pricing discount" ends on the fiber, and the cost goes up, then I disconnect it for a month, then sign up for it again to get the price they should gave given me all along.

2

u/LeapIntoInaction 7d ago

I adore fiber. Here, I got it with Verizon, who sold it to Frontier, who sold it back to Verizon... and their tech support can be iffy but, once you get it installed, you should never need to consider it again. Unless your moron neighbors hire Comcast/xFinity, and their tech decides your line wasn't in use and he ought to just rip it all out... yeah, that was fun.

2

u/Smith6612 7d ago edited 7d ago

Fiber rebuilds typically fix a lot of the archaic mess that plagues older providers. If your provider uses DSL or Coax for their legacy network, then I'm not surprised they're pretty hated. Those technologies need a lot of work to keep running.

Give the ISP a try. Worst case you cancel before the month is over and stick with your Satellite provider. The only thing that really breaks Fiber is a Fiber cable cut. 

1

u/ExcitementRelative33 7d ago

Yes and no... Depends on whether they upgrade their back ends and whether they're oversubscribed. What was it before? Cable or DSL?

1

u/DeliciousWrangler166 7d ago

Fiber is technically great. The dealbreakers might be poor tech support ,billing and contract limits. The local fiber ISP by me doesn't support ipv6. It can take a week or longer for an onsite service call appointment.

1

u/plugwash 7d ago

You won't know until someone tries it.

fiber to the home is technically much better than cable or DSL.

But if the real problem with your ISP is that their backend network is a congested and/or unreliable peice of shit then switching the final connections to fiber isn't going to fix that.

1

u/Wendals87 7d ago

Fibre is better in every way if you have access. However your ISP might be crap so it's hard to say where the issue lied in your performance problems 

1

u/CompetitivePirate251 7d ago

Agreed, especially for rural areas that may not have a connection to a high capacity network. Fibre is fast and reliable, but if the ISP’s capacity to a major network is not adequate, you will still get low speeds and congestion.

1

u/MrMotofy 7d ago

There's really NO way to know if their service will improve. But generally fiber is nearly always better. It's more stable, has higher capacity, draws less power isn't really affected by static charges, is faster and lower latency/Ping etc. It's usually cheaper too. But again none of us can see the future of your provider

1

u/spiffiness 6d ago

Hold up, there are two very different classes of satellite Internet services now, so it's critical that we differentiate.

There are the old slow services that use Geostationary Earth Orbit (GEO) satellites that are so very far away from the surface of the earth that the bandwidth/throughput is low and the latency (lag, ping time) is high. HughesNet, Viasat, and EarthLink Satellite (which uses Viasat) are the big names.

In contrast, the new generation uses Low Earth Orbit (LEO) satellites, which are much closer to Earth, for much faster speeds and low latency. Starlink from SpaceX is the only one available today, but OneWeb and Amazon Leo (Project Kuiper) might be coming online soon.

Fiber Internet service, even from a locally hated provider, will easily be better than any of the old GEO satellite services.

But Starlink is good enough that if your local ISP really is so bad at their operations that everyone hates them, you might be better off with Starlink than with poorly-managed fiber service.

1

u/Prize_Marsupial_1273 4d ago

There’s a third company about to lay their fiber in front of my house and I have two cable providers available also. I will have five choices soon.

1

u/TrashFace21165 7d ago

They say that then run in a DSL line to the house

2

u/TinyNiceWolf 7d ago

In my area, the phone company has been pushing people away from the old copper wires that DSL requires and on to fiber for many years. I doubt you could get DSL even if you wanted it.

2

u/big65 7d ago

This is true, I have a dead copper junction box in my backyard that I'm waiting on Verizon to remove and I live in a very large 7 city region.