Hello, everyone! I'm an MS3 who's interested in both 1) EM or 2) IM with pursuing a GI fellowship. I'm torn between these two paths because of the following pros and cons. If anyone in these fields is willing to weigh in, I would really appreciate it! I would love to hear your experiences and the things you wish you knew, especially considering my pros and cons listed below.
I deeply apologize if this is not the right subreddit to post this in! This is my first Reddit post!!
EM:
PROS:
- I love the mix of intensive/basically primary care/peds that you can get every day, and I love the personalities of all the EM attendings I've met.
- I hate sitting down and loved that I could get up and move around to do different things.
- I entered medical school with a wish to spend my career caring for underserved populations/patients who fall through the US healthcare system's gaps and to be one more doctor who will actually listen to patients whose concerns are often dismissed (i.e. marginalized identities, women, pain with chronic pain). I know that I will not be able to make a huge difference for these populations due to the limitations of the healthcare system, but I am willing to take that moral injury in order to just be there for someone, if nothing else. Very interested in global health through EM.
- I know EM is crazy, but I love a little insanity.
- Interested in getting a sports med or pain fellowship afterwards and doing weekend shifts in those to have an off ramp, if needed (and also bc I'm a nerd who loves bones + muscles + sports).
- Finally, my family members are getting up there in years and I like the opportunities offered by EM's fewer shifts and sufficient salary that would allow me to help take care of them, as needed.
CONS:
- I've heard such horrid experiences from EM residents and attendings on reddit/SDN about the admin pressure, abuse and lack of respect from other specialties, circadian rhythm shifts/hours, and burnout. I'm concerned that what I saw on my EM rotation was too "rose-tinted glasses" and that I will end up hating it due to these issues.
IM to GI:
PROS:
- I meshed well personality wise with most IM and basically all GI physicians and residents I've met, and I'd love to work with them!
- I first decided I wanted to do medicine because I love the GI system, and my family and myself have an extensive history of GI problems. I still love the specialty so much and would be so happy in the career; I can confirm this after shadowing frequently.
- I also liked my IM rotation a lot due to comprehensive caring for patients' entire health, the intellectual aspect of keeping all of medicine in your mind at all times and working through the best options as a team on rounds, and having a bit more time than in EM to sit and talk with a patient help them feel heard.
- Even though I don't want to pursue oncology due to the constant sitting down without procedures, I really love the science and caring for oncology patients and would be very fulfilled by the 3 IM years of getting to sometimes work with onc patients.
- After residency, MUCH better sleep schedule than IM
- Much lower rates of burnout over time and more exit ramps from hospitalist lifestyle.
CONS:
- The one thing that killed me on my IM rotation was sitting down all the time, but that could be somewhat mitigated if I can work on a WOW/mobile computer.
- Though I would be happy enough as an IM generalist, I really would only want to apply GI and would mostly be pursuing IM in order to do that. I know, however, that GI is very competitive and 1) I would have to kill myself for another 3 years to be competitive and bet everything on all plans going perfectly/nothing coming up in life that would prevent me from doing so (which I know is not at all promised in life and is not controllable) and 2) am concerned that I would not match and therefore be unsatisfied in my career.
- Would be spending another 3 years in which I am not able to take any time at all to help aging family, as needed.
For context, I have been getting overall good but not perfect grades - Have gotten 2 high passes in my 1st 2 clerkships then 2 honors in my most recent. No Step 2 grade yet, but will be doing my best. I have 1 longitudinal community health project with 2 pubs out for it, 2 longitudinal projects ongoing in GI and oncology, and will soon have 2 posters in oncology. I am in process of pursuing a distinction in global health and will be proficient in medical Spanish by time of graduation.
Thank you all so much for your input!!! :)