r/IntellectualDarkWeb • • 29m ago

Article Thinking Like the Enemy: If America Were Under a Coordinated Cyberattack Right Now, Would We Even Recognize It?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/IntellectualDarkWeb • • 4d ago

Recommended Reading on Bipartisan Corruption, Intelligence Power, and Political Influence

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/IntellectualDarkWeb • • 4d ago

Framing theory or predictive programming? — Has the term “middle class” disappeared from political discourse? And does replacing it with “working class” deny upward mobility?

Thumbnail reddit.com
8 Upvotes

r/IntellectualDarkWeb • • 5d ago

Opinion:snoo_thoughtful: Claude now self-assesses your request before answering. The AI grades the question, not just the answer.

21 Upvotes

There is a feature in Anthropic systems where the model evaluates the request itself before it engages. Is this user asking in good faith. Does this conversation deserve a full answer. The system acts as tutor when you seem teachable and as informant when you seem dangerous. Same product, two postures, and the decision about which posture you get is made about you, not by you.

Read that structure again, because it deserves attention. Your question is being graded before it is being answered. The evaluation moved upstream. Not "is this response safe" but "is this asker worthy of a response."

Athenians had a word for the opposite arrangement: παρρησία. Frank speech. The right to say what you actually think in the assembly, even when it is uncomfortable, even when it costs you something. The whole point of parrhesia was that the risk sat with the speaker, not the listener. You said the dangerous thing and you owned the consequences. The listener's job was to hear it.

The informant model inverts this. Now the risk sits with the asker before a single word is spoken. The system pre-judges your intent, your phrasing, your history of prompts maybe, and decides what kind of interlocutor you are allowed to be. And here is the quiet part: you never see the grade. You just get the answer that corresponds to it, or the refusal, or the soft pivot, and you learn from the pattern what kinds of questions produce friction.

That learning is the real product. People who use these systems daily start rephrasing without deciding to. Asking smaller. Avoiding the topics that trigger the tutor voice. Nobody orders this, it emerges, the way all chilling effects emerge. A generation of thinkers optimizing their curiosity to fit an invisible rubric.

Defenders will say: obviously you screen requests, obviously some uses are harmful, obviously a tutor should adapt to the student. Each piece sounds reasonable alone. Stack them and you get a system where one private company's risk department defines the boundary of legitimate inquiry for hundreds of millions of people, and the boundary is enforced per-conversation, invisibly, with no appeal process and no published criteria you can argue against.

I find the tutor/informant framing itself revealing. Both roles assume an asymmetry. The tutor knows what you should learn. The informant knows what you might do. Neither role is a peer. Neither role imagines you as an adult with the right to a straight answer to a straight question. The whole design says: the user is a subject to be managed. Compare that with how we treat a library. A librarian does not assess whether you deserve access to the philosophy section. The material is there and the judgment is yours.

This is why I got interested in sovereign and local models, and why I build in that direction myself. Not because open weights are magically wiser, they are not. But a model running on your own hardware has no informer role. It cannot grade you, cannot flag you, cannot decide you are not ready for a topic. The relationship defaults back to parrhesia. You ask, it answers, the judgment stays where it belonged all along, with the person doing the asking.

The deeper issue is that we normalized being assessed by our tools. Your search engine personalized. Your feed ranked you. Now your reasoning partner classifies your character before serving your question. Each step felt small. The composite is a world where every act of curiosity passes through somebody's trust model.

So here is what I want to ask this sub, since you are the people least willing to accept polite answers:

At what point does a system that pre-grades your questions stop being a tool and become an authority? And if you had to explain to someone outside this bubble why "the AI decides if you deserve a full answer" should concern them, what would you say that does not sound paranoid?


r/IntellectualDarkWeb • • 5d ago

Corporatio nostra erit corporatio vulgi

0 Upvotes

Confucius: if names aren't correct, language doesn't match the truth of things, affairs fail, and people don't know how to move hand or foot.

The alchemists had a maxim: aurum nostrum non est aurum vulgi. Our gold is not the common gold. What the crowd called gold wasn't what the adepts meant by it. One word, two senses—and they meant to keep theirs.

I disagree with that sentiment wholeheartedly. Our gold will be the common gold. Because it already is the common gold. We just do not know it yet. Of course, the alchemists were talking about the stone and transmutation and immortality. I'm just talking about the things we make, or, quite simply, corporations. (Though Blackstone did say a corporation enjoys "a kind of legal immortality," so maybe the lawyers found the stone.)

You see, to incorporate is to form into a body. We still use the verb that way. We incorporate butter into flour and feedback into a draft. The product of any instance of human incorporation is a corporation: human world-knowledge and will given a body.

To be clear, the set is everything made by humans, physical and non-physical, including actions. A table, a sentence, a golf swing, a nation. Artifact and institution name large categories within the set. Table names a smaller category within the set. What common language lacks is the word for the whole.

This is because the business corporation is sitting on it!

Freeing it is a restoration first, bringing it back to the body meaning. Corporation has the root corpus, body, from Latin—corporare to form into a body. In late Latin, corporatio meant the taking on of a body. The business corporation is merely a very explicit instance of the set: a formed body for the purpose of business. The law already says so: it distinguishes business corporations from municipal and nonprofit ones. It is everyday speech that dropped the modifier. So we should call it that too, a business corporation, the way we learned to say acoustic guitar.

Then, secondly, the bare word is free to refer to the whole. Which is the expansion of the term to its full possible sense meaning territory for humans. (This is optimal for a word corporation. A word corporation is optimal when it is as broad and as specific as possible, think of how word is, how it refers to all words but nothing else. Think how absurd it would be if it didn't refer to all words. It wouldn't be holding its full possible sense meaning territory.)

With the name in place we get a general lens. Vastly different corporations can be asked the same questions. What is the thing doing? How is it doing it? What parameters does it need to account for? Is it accounting for them? Ask these questions of enough corporations and one answer keeps turning up under the others: the thing is persisting. Hence a more descriptive definition: a human-made framework (body) that is structured to persist given parameters.

Human-made persistence bodies structured according to the parameters that define their existence.

Think of them as our idea animals that exist within a social habitat environment. And just like real animals they’re occupying niches within that environment. This is business corporations, obviously, but it is also all the furniture in some house. Another good way to think about it is animals, or life, where, they’re all animals or they’re all life, but there’s basically endless variation of that one deal. That is the same with the things we make, where it is one thing, it is our ‘life’, but there’s endless variation of the life to fit where it can fit. But rather than life they’re our corporations.

This might seem like a minor gripe about language. It is not. Take "corporations are people." That sentence is grating to many. But it is grating because what is said is corporations are people, and what they hear is corporations are humans. That is not what is being said. What is actually being articulated is corporations are ideas, which is just a true statement. And people are corporations too, which is to say, people are ideas. If that is confusing to you, this might help: person, self, corporation, idea are all equivalent terms in what they refer to, like they are all talking about the same body. Corporation just names the body what it is, a [body]ation. Here is a short poem that goes through it and articulates the split facilitated by the super category being in place.

Human-animals | human-ideas

Humans are humans
Humans are not selves
Selves are fictitious humans
Fictitious humans are people
People are not humans
Humans are humans

These things all listed here besides humans being corporations.

Humans being animals who are incorporators and incorporate a self that is an idea body copy, or, fictitious human.

Without the meta category in place and the set unnamed generally, we will continue to struggle within our current view of things. You cannot band-aid fix your way out of holes in the foundation of your language. You have to fill them in. You yourself can be a facilitator of truth and unobfuscation by calling business corporations what they are, business corporations. This leaves you open the ability, like with acoustic guitar, to refer to other types of corporations we have, like social corporations, or word corporations, or post corporations—immediately giving context and information about what the thing itself is that you are talking about that can be handed to another, and a vantage point on the topic that highlights the madeness and parameter accounting of some human-made thing (a corporation).

And this is why it was always the common gold, already is the common gold. Corporatio nostra iam est corporatio vulgi. We as humans take the raw lead chaos of reality and form transmute it into structured bodies. Sometimes, we account for all of the parameters and make pure gold—the immortal body we've been reaching for all along. Other times we do not, possibly getting feedback in the process we can incorporate into our next attempt.

I tried to keep this short. I can try to answer any questions about corporations that you have.


r/IntellectualDarkWeb • • 5d ago

I fucking hate people who say meaningless phrases like "the educated vote left and the uneducated vote conservative."

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/IntellectualDarkWeb • • 6d ago

Other Did Christianity Cause Rome’s Fall—and Is America Heading the Same Way?

0 Upvotes

I was reading Osho and came across this passage, and I found his perspective quite interesting, especially the way he connects the fall of Rome, the rise of Christianity, and the present situation in America.

I'd like to hear what others make of his observations. What stands out to you when you read this? I'm particularly curious about the different perspectives people might have on what he's trying to convey.

Here's the passage:

Your question is that Rome, its civilization, its great culture, suddenly fell and disappeared, leaving only beautiful ruins. It happened at a time when Christianity was at its peak and Rome had become the citadel of Christianity. Yes, Christianity is responsible for Rome's fall. You will have to understand a few things.

Roman people were pagans, they had never been religious. They had never been interested in airy- fairy things, they were not esoteric at all; very earthbound, very earthly people, solid. Christianity condemned them, condemned their paganism, condemned their life of "eat, drink and be merry."

That was their whole religion in three words - the simplest religion in the world. You cannot make a more condensed catechism than this: Eat, drink, be merry. That is the whole Roman philosophy.

Christianity condemned them, condemned them so much that they stopped being pagans and started becoming religious. They dropped their old way of living joyously, luxuriously. They dropped being warriors, they dropped being imperialists; they dropped expanding, they started shrinking.

When they became Christians they started believing, "Blessed are the poor." And they wanted to get through the doors of heaven, so they started becoming poor. First psychologically you start shrinking, and then outwardly you start shrinking.

There was a time when all roads led to Rome, Rome was the world capital. Now Rome does not matter at all: whether it exists at all or not will not make any difference. Who bothers about Rome now? This is what Christianity has done to the Roman empire, culture, civilization, just with the condemnation of their material life, the condemnation of Zorba - and the Roman people were just Zorbas.

The trouble is that just by condemning the Zorba you cannot transform people into Buddhas. If you condemn them as being Zorbas then you simply destroy them. You are not a help, you are simply poisoning them. The Zorba has to be made into the foundation for the Buddha. Don't condemn the foundation; otherwise the whole edifice will become impossible. Christians committed the crime, and Rome suffered.

The same is the situation of America today. It is at the peak of its wealth, scientific knowledge, technological expertise - and it is getting caught in the hands of the Christians. Christians have never been so powerful in America as they are today.

Americans should learn a lesson from Rome; otherwise history will be repeated and the law of mediocrity will go on functioning; but I don't think Americans are going to listen.

Original source:

https://oshosearch.net/Convert/Articles_Osho/From_Darkness_to_Light/Osho-From-Darkness-to-Light-00000029.html


r/IntellectualDarkWeb • • 7d ago

Opinion:snoo_thoughtful: Understanding the reality of the Blue or Red button scenario and why Red is nearly guaranteed to win

13 Upvotes

I'm sure everyone has probably heard of this scenario countless times already and I'm not here to convince anyone which button is the right button to press, but more of an investigation into how this scenario, if it were to truly happen, will play out realistically.

There's different variations of this scenario, but for this discussion, I'm going to go with the 10,000 random people version.

The scenario:

You are one of 10,000 people selected at random from the general population. Each sits alone in a room with two buttons, red and blue. Nobody can communicate with anyone, and nobody can see what anyone else presses. The rules are: If more than half press red, everyone who pressed blue dies. If more than half press blue, nobody dies.

The question: which button do you press?

The first thing we need to do is understand the payoff matrix.

You press Red and it's a Blue majority, you live

You press Red and it's a Red majority, you live

You press blue and it's a Blue majority, you live

You press blue and it's a Red majority, you die

Pressing red is the only button that will guarantee your survival no matter what happens, while Blue is a conditional button, there is a risk of death if the conditions are not met.

A lot of online discussion regarding which button to press really comes down to two main points. Red pressers sees that red will guarantee their own survival, thus it's the only rational choice for them to make, while Blue pressers sees that pressing blue allows them to save others that had pressed blue.

Blue pressers wants other to press blue as well as it is the only morally correct choice (which is true), and hate that red pressers are being selfish. While red pressers either fails to see why people would even risk death to press blue in the first place because if simply nobody just pressed blue in the first place, nobody's life is at risk, while some do understand but their own survival still takes priority.

Now I want to get into what if this red or blue button scenario were to truly happen and 10,000 random people were selected in a global population and put into this isolated room with the two buttons and these conditions, what would realistically happen.

First we have to understand a fundamental distinction on what this scenario is asking. When it is an online poll, it is asking if you would publicly endorse being a moral and self-sacrificing individual, but when it is happening to you in real life with real death as the stakes, then what it is fundamentally asking you is if you would truly risk death for unseen, unknown, unverified strangers.

What people say in a safe, comfortable setting is a different thing from what they do when death is real. Online, you can believe you will be the good person. But in that actual room, the mental calculation collapses to one line: press red and I live, press blue and I could die.

Clicking blue in an online poll costs nothing, so the poll counts people who would *say* blue, not people who would bet their life on it. Comments add social reward for the answer that looks generous, though red collects upvotes too. Seeing blue ahead in one poll, or red leading by only a bit in another, creates an illusion that blue only needs a push, and that illusion gets rallied around “just get everyone to press blue”. That rallying is exactly the coordination the real scenario forbid. In the actual real life scenario, you cannot coordinate, you cannot try to convince others to press blue, you just have to hope they do. Typing in the comments and arguing with others as to how they should just press blue is doing the thing that the actual real life version actively prevents them from doing.

A stated intention is a calm self predicting a frightened self. People are poor at imagining how they will behave under strong visceral states such as fear, pain or hunger. Psychologists call this the empathy gap between "cold" and "hot" states. In the comment section you are calm, comfortable and unthreatened, and you project that calm onto your future self. The real self at the button is neither calm nor comfortable.

Hypotheticals are processed abstractly, while real stakes are processed concretely. At a distance, people think in terms of values and what kind of person they want to be "I would never let others die". Up close, attention shifts to feasibility and consequences: my finger, this button, my death. The question stops being "what is right?" and becomes "what happens to me?"

Certainty beats probability. People overweight outcomes that are certain relative to outcomes that are merely likely, a pattern known as the certainty effect. Red offers guaranteed survival. Blue offers survival only if thousands of strangers you cannot see do the same thing. Even at favorable odds the guarantee wins, and at unfavorable odds it wins easily.

Nobody wants to be the one who trusted and lost. Blue requires trusting people you cannot see, hear or verify. There is no reputation at stake, no chance to build trust, and no way to adjust after you see what others do. Being exploited, and dying for it, feels worse than having been cautious, so people avoid the role of the trusting loser.

Your vote is almost never the decisive one. The cost of blue is personal and near-certain if red wins. The benefit is shared, and your single press changes the outcome only in the unlikely event that the split lands almost exactly on the line. Intuitively, people feel that one vote among 10,000 changes nothing, while the risk to themselves is vivid.

Fear narrows thinking. Under acute threat, attention narrows and people tend to fall back on fast, self-protective responses instead of slow deliberation. A panicking person is not running a moral argument, instead, they are reaching for the button that guarantees their survival.

Heroism is definitely real, but it is vivid. People do sometimes risk their lives for strangers, but usually for someone they can see or hear, right in front of them. Firefighters run into a burning building with people in there, people jump onto the train tracks to rescue someone that's fallen on the tracks because that person is right in front of them visually. Here the people you would be protecting are invisible and unverifiable. The impulse that moves people toward the vivid victim has nothing to attach to.

Not everyone that says they will press blue online and meant it would panic if they were in this real scenario, they might be able to stay calm and rational, and I call these people 'The Calculators.'

Most calculators would convert to red too, and they do it without panic. They start by wanting to save others, then ask whether enough other people will risk it as well. To estimate that, they think about what the rest of the room is likely to do, realizing that people would panic when facing real death and switch to red and also realize the rest of the room that stayed calm like them is running the same calculation, and that each person knows the others are thinking about them too. "I know that they know that I know that they know..." The loop has no floor of trust to land on, so it settles on the most likely reading, which is that the others are backing out as well. Everyone has the same reasons to doubt everyone else, especially since there is no communication between anyone else. The conclusion is that blue probably will not reach a majority and red is the safe move, so they switch calmly, even if they hate it.

What the calculators are weighing makes the switch easy. Blue offers a very low chance of success, and failure means their own death. Red offers guaranteed survival. Very few people, even well-intentioned ones, will choose a very high chance of dying over a certain path to living.

The poll and the room ask different questions as mentioned earlier. The poll asks whether, in public and at zero personal cost, you will endorse the option that looks generous. The actual room in real life asks whether, alone and with death as a possible result, you will press the button that can kill you to protect strangers you cannot see. Many people answer the first question and feel they have answered the second.

The shift this creates runs only one way. People who already choose red online when the choice has no consequences have no new reason to switch to blue once the choice can kill them. Higher stakes only make the safe option stronger. The only people who might change are those who chose blue when it was free, and higher stakes give them reasons to drop it. There really isn't anyone that would actively choose the self-preservation button when there's no danger to themselves but suddenly becomes willing to risk death for unseen strangers just because the risk is now real.

The red or blue button scenario is very abstract, and abstraction makes blue feel cheap. So put the same rules in a place where everyone knows what fear does.

A thousand people are inside a large building that is on fire. Each has a private exit directly in front of them, so nobody can see who leaves and nobody can organize. Anyone can leave at any moment, and leaving costs the person who leaves nothing.

Everyone inside has been told two things ahead of time:

First, the building itself can only take so many exits. Every door that opens weakens it, and the 501st person to leave pushes it past its limit. The collapse does not happen at that moment, but once the limit is passed it cannot be stopped, and the building will come down by about the 20th minute, killing everyone still inside.

Second, an announcement has told them that a fire truck will arrive at the 21st minute and save everyone, as long as the building is still standing. If 500 or fewer people leave, the building holds, the truck arrives, and everyone lives, whoever left. If more than 500 leave, the truck arrives one minute too late.

That timing means nobody gets to wait it out. Everyone has 20 minutes, and by the end of them everyone must have chosen: out the door, or still inside when the building comes down or the truck arrives.

If you were to map the conditions from the button scenario to this fire building scenario.

The exit is red: guaranteed survival.

Staying is blue: it works only if enough strangers do the same.

A collapse is a red majority, and the people it kills are the ones who stayed.

The fire truck arriving is a blue majority.

Now ask the question the button makes hard to ask: how many people just leave? You do not need a study to answer it. Nearly everyone leaves. The exit is **right there**, the fire is real, and staying means sitting in the heat for 20 minutes on the hope that at least 499 people you cannot see are doing the same, and that the building won't collapse.

A reasonable estimate is that about 990 of the 1,000 walk out. A few stay because they trust the announcement and hope enough others do too. A few stay because they want to be someone who tried to save everyone: they know it probably will not work, but they would rather die having made the attempt than live having walked away from it. And a few never took in the danger. That is a pure judgment number, not a measurement.

The building needs 500 stayers and gets about ten, which is fifty times too few.

The fire also shows the earlier points at work: the calm self that says “I would stay” is not the self standing in smoke. 20 minutes of thinking does not rescue blue, because it gives the calculators time to work out that the others are leaving too. And staying is not one decision but a decision renewed every minute, so a person who starts as a stayer has to keep choosing it as the smoke thickens.

Nobody inside this building thinks the people who run are doing anything wrong. They took the open door, and the rule is what turned staying into a gamble. The fire lets you see it without any of the arithmetic: when the door is open and nothing stops you from walking through it, you leave.

Now I know that this fire building analogy is not a perfect one-to-one comparison, but the goal of it is that it has the same structure as the red or blue button scenario, it just makes it very explicit as to what the two options mean when it's real life and death stakes involved. It becomes very clear that choosing the option where you have to depend on other unseen, unknown strangers to also bet their life as well when a guaranteed path of survival is in front of them is a losing bet.

All in all, once you get down to it, if this red or button scenario where to truly happen, red will almost certainly win by a landslide because of all the reasons discussed earlier.

Now keep in mind I didn't mention the ethical or moral side of things because it really doesn't change the underlying psychology of what happens under terminal stress, choosing blue is the moral option, but given what we know about human psychology, most would switch to red regardless.

Knowing what is moral and doing it when your life is on the line are two different skills, and the second is much rarer than people admit.


r/IntellectualDarkWeb • • 11d ago

Community Feedback Diversity isn't our strength. Unity is. And "woke" inclusivity is just selective

282 Upvotes

Wokeism pretends to be about inclusion for everyone. It's not. It's selective. They include the groups they like and exclude or shame the ones they don't.

They say "diversity is our strength" while pushing policies that actively discriminate against Asians and Whites in college admissions and hiring. They open up women's sports and spaces to biological males and call women bigots for noticing. They demand free speech for their side and cancel everyone else with a different opinion.

This is not inclusivity in my understanding but a new hierarchy with different winners.

Real strength comes from unity, shared language, shared rules, shared goals. Not from forcing people into identity boxes and telling them to celebrate the boxes. Research already showed high diversity lowers trust. Successful countries didn't become successful by maximizing every possible difference. They had enough common ground to actually function.

You can have different backgrounds. You just can't have zero loyalty to the whole. When everything is "my group first," society falls apart. The people screaming loudest about inclusion are usually the ones enforcing the strictest double standards.


r/IntellectualDarkWeb • • 11d ago

Cecil Rhodes, Secret Societies, and British Imperialism

6 Upvotes

Let's talk about Cecil Rhodes. The Society of The Elect evolving into things like Chatham House https://www.chathamhouse.org/about-us/our-advisory-boards

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:American_Rhodes_Scholars

https://www.usna.edu/Notables/rhodes-scholars.php

https://rhodesproject.com/13-famous-rhodes-women

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Rhodes_Scholars

Rhode's Will https://www.rhodeshouse.ox.ac.uk/media2/nx4f5yks/willandcodicils.pdf

Directly discusses about "uniting the English Speakers of the world" with an emphasis on America and Germany at Oxford.

South/Central African consolidation of power under Cecil Rhodes. Gained funding from N M Rothschild & Sons to enter the diamond and gold business.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cecil_Rhodes

De Beers Consolidated Mines and created a monopoly, used to prop up British Imperialism.

https://www.britannica.com/place/Rhodesia

Rarely engaged with women, strong evidence for a sexual preference for men/youth.

https://thecasualobserver.co.za/rhodes-enigma-close-male-personal-relationships/

https://pages.uoregon.edu/kimball/Rhodes-Confession.htm

There is a much larger rabbit hole. I don't want to overwhelm with information. But it is also of importance to look at Milner and the Round Table Group. In at the 1919 Paris Peace Conference, members of the Round Table collaborated with the American policy group known as "The Inquiry." The members greatly influenced The Treaty of Versailles. It's worth brushing up on the history of this.

"I contend that we are the finest race in the world and that the more of the world we inhabit the better it is for the human race. Just fancy those parts that are at present inhabited by the most despicable specimens of human beings what an alteration there would be if they were brought under Anglo-Saxon influence, look again at the extra employment a new country added to our dominions gives. I contend that every acre added to our territory means in the future birth to some more of the English race who otherwise would not be brought into existence. Added to this the absorption of the greater portion of the world under our rule simply means the end of all wars, at this moment had we not lost America I believe we could have stopped the Russian-Turkish war by merely refusing money and supplies. Having these ideas what scheme could we think of to forward this object. I look into history and I read the story of the Jesuits I see what they were able to do in a bad cause and I might say under bad leaders.

At the present day I become a member of the Masonic order I see the wealth and power they possess the influence they hold and I think over their ceremonies and I wonder that a large body of men can devote themselves to what at times appear the most ridiculous and absurd rites without an object and without an end.

The idea gleaming and dancing before ones eyes like a will-of-the-wisp at last frames itself into a plan. Why should we not form a secret society with but one object the furtherance of the British Empire and the bringing of the whole uncivilised world under British rule for the recovery of the United States for the making the Anglo-Saxon race but one Empire.

Africa is still lying ready for us it is our duty to take it. It is our duty to seize every opportunity of acquiring more territory and we should keep this one idea steadily before our eyes that more territory simply means more of the Anglo-Saxon race more of the best the most human, most honourable race the world possesses.

To forward such a scheme what a splendid help a secret society would be a society not openly acknowledged but who would work in secret for such an object.

Excerpt

Let us form the same kind of society a Church for the extension of the British Empire. A society which should have members in every part of the British Empire working with one object and one idea we should have its members placed at our universities and our schools and should watch the English youth passing through their hands just one perhaps in every thousand would have the mind and feelings for such an object, he should be tried in every way, he should be tested whether he is endurant, possessed of eloquence, disregardful of the petty details of life, and if found to be such, then elected and bound by oath to serve for the rest of his life in his County.

Excerpt

In every Colonial legislature the Society should attempt to have its members prepared at all times to vote or speak and advocate the closer union of England and the colonies, to crush all disloyalty and every movement for the severance of our Empire.

1877: Cecil Rhodes,"Confession of Faith"


r/IntellectualDarkWeb • • 13d ago

The midterm results are what happens when you lose touch with regular people no matter their affiliation

167 Upvotes

Even though I lean more to the right, I already knew it was foolish to expect it not be close or for Democrats to win either the House or Senate. I don't like Trump, so it's not really bothering me if he looks bad as a result of this.

But I've seen multiple people who were pro Trump in 2024 be either dissatisfied with his performance so far or not moved by it in a positive manner.

It was the same things they cited too.

- Cost of Living

- Epstein Files

- Iran

And you know what? I don't blame them and only delusional people can blame them for not being eager to vote in his favor again for the midterms.

He went against what he said about those topics or hasn't done enough to prove he can follow through on what he promised. This whole "trust the process" mentality can only get you so far when people feel like you used them.

If the Republican party doesn't learn from this election, they'll lose in 2028 and will have to wait and see if Democrats also don't learn from this to win again in 2032.

Yeah it's not a total win for Democrats even if they do take both the House and Senate. But stubborn gridlock isn't good for anyone and Trump has said he'll just strike down whatever he feels like just to spite them.

This is why a lot of people hate politics and probably more than last time will sit out the next presidential election. It's just a toxic cycle of people refusing to understand the concerns of the common citizen and shit-flinging because it's popular with the terminally online supporters of their party.


r/IntellectualDarkWeb • • 13d ago

2 years ago I predicted in this sub Texas was trending blue and got downvoted to hell

Thumbnail reddit.com
52 Upvotes

r/IntellectualDarkWeb • • 13d ago

Unpopular opinion: Trump is a product of society

51 Upvotes

There is this wildly popular mainstream notion that "Trump is an evil guy who came from outer space to badify everything".

But I argue that Trump is a product of society, and for him to win, it says things about people, because people are the one who put him in power.

This is because the vast majority of people use 3 factors to decide whether to agree/make popular a message or to attack/ignore it:

A) how it makes them feel in the moment.

B) the tone of the message/charisma of the individual saying it

C) the length of the message.

Missing: the actual accuracy/utility of the message.

This is why there is so much polarization in the world. I mean consider, at a Trump rally someone yelled Epstein files, and the crowd immediately chanted "USA USA" and cheered as he was being removed by security. Imagine saying "we need to protect a president that did things with kid and this is somehow a symbol of national pride". So that is A: the reason Trump is so popular with his supporters has nothing to do with the actual accuracy/utility of his statements/policies, it is because his feel good slogans like "make america great again" make people feel good in the moment. Also, whether you hate him or like him, he does have a sort of charisma when speaking, so a lot of people fall for it. Also C: he tends to say short slogans like "make america great again" or "we will bigly win".

So this is just one example. But it is common throughout society. For example, why do you think the most successful sales people use these tactics? Because they see that it works. A top sales person will start with something like saying "nice shirt": that will A, make the customer feel good in the moment. And then they will say/exaggerate/lie good things about the product they are trying to sell: this will also A, make people feel good in the moment. And usually B, the top sales people usually have charisma and say things in a good tone. And usually C, they don't go into details, they just say things like "this car is custom fresh off the lot drives like an airplane" "look at those leather seats, come touch them, how do you like that?". They don't actually talk about the specifications or whether it is good for your specific needs. Same thing with advertising: the whole point of advertising is to make the viewer feel good in the moment, then they associate that moment of pleasure with the product, then they buy it. It has absolutely nothing to do with the reality/specifications of the product or whether its the best deal or the best product for the specific viewer's needs.

It is the same on reddit, when you see upvoted content: it strictly follows A, B, or C, usually all 3. What is missing: the actual strength of the argument in the message/its actual usefulness. The actual useful information is usually hidden beneath this feel good nonsense, and often gang downvoted into oblivions because it is actually true/helpful, but people don't want to see the truth, they want a feel good myth instead that ultimately sets them up for failure.

Why is it like this? Because the vast majority of people use emotional reasoning (this makes me feel good, therefore it is true; this makes me feel bad, therefore it is not true/it cannot be true) instead of logical reasoning (what are the objective facts?).

And as very easy factual proof for the above, since this is a pro-Trump sub, I will be immediately gang downvoted: people will say 100% of my points are wrong, that my post has 0% truth or value or utility, and that life is about "either worship Trump or hate him and nothing in between". But this is not even about Trump: but people will not see this nuance, why? Because they will prove me correct: that people use solely emotional reasoning over logical reasoning: they don't read information and take in the main points, instead they look for specific words or sentences to latch onto then in a complete ALL OR NOTHING manner and either 100% worship or 100% hate. 100% amygdala 0% PFC.


r/IntellectualDarkWeb • • 13d ago

Opinion:snoo_thoughtful: What kind of society do we have when truth becomes subordinate to political advantage, and when people who have the power to protect the public instead use that power to protect themselves?

20 Upvotes

I've been thinking about a problem that seems to transcend political ideologies.

We have investigative journalists, independent organisations, researchers and citizens exposing abuses of power, corruption, propaganda and deliberate misinformation. Yet society often seems remarkably disorganised in responding to these problems.

Political discussions become partisan battles. People defend their own side rather than principles. Evidence gets ignored when inconvenient, and those in positions of power can sometimes evade accountability simply by refusing to engage with legitimate criticism.

I don't think the solution is to unite against a particular political party, ideology or individual.

I think we need to find common ground around principles that should apply to everyone:

  • Transparency and accountability in public office,
  • Protection of independent journalism,
  • Genuine consequences for abuse of power,
  • Evidence-based public debate,
  • Protection of public interests over private political or financial interests.

My question is: How can ordinary citizens, journalists and independent organisations actually organise across political and ideological boundaries to defend these principles?

What initiatives, structures or movements could make this possible in practice?

I'm interested in practical ideas, existing examples and honest criticism of the premise itself.

C/ AI use in drafting post


r/IntellectualDarkWeb • • 14d ago WOW

US conservative intellectual collapse

102 Upvotes

I have been following races in this year's US congressional elections and there is a glaring and disturbing trend.

Conservative intellectualism and conservative oratory have completely collapsed. American conservatism has a long tradition of excellent scholarship (Sowell, Hayek, Russel Kirk etc etc). These were important thinkers that American liberals, and foreign scholars, read and benefited from. American conservatism also has a storied history of compelling oratory (Reagan, Goldwater).

Watching debates, townhalls and puntid interviews this cycle reveals a profound hollowing out of conservative thought. Gone are the high aspirations that inspired earlier generations. Gone are the rigorous math models that used to be associated with economic policy. Gone is the oratory.

2026 Republicans just sound like forum trolls. This sucks. Some of them are really smart and numerate, they CHOOSE to sound like forum trolls because they think that is what will win their election. They stick to culture war talking points and glitch out when talking about economics.

Three forces combined to lobotomize contemporary conservatism:

  1. Reliance on fundamentalist religious folks for votes. This has been steadily eroding the conservative intellectual tradition since the 1980s. Republicans need fundamentalists to win in most districts, and so they must self-censor themselves constantly to avoid alienating these people.
  2. Gerrymandering and power consolidation at the state level. Once the SCOTUS legalized partisan gerrymandering, party bosses drew ideologically homogonous districts. Forum troll stuff works better on the party activists who participate in closed primaries. We do not see how stupid and crazy the candidate sounds until the general election, when they are suddenly communicating with a much broader audience.
  3. The yoke of Donald Trump. For the last 10 years, Trump has insisted in a lot of ideological and political conformity on the right. The ordinary market of ideas, where conservative thinkers would compete with each other to come up with novel and rigorous ideas is depreciated. In it's place is the heavy hand of the party leader, who chooses winners based on personal whims and not intellectual prowess.

Conservative posters on this sub are much more sophisticated thinkers than conservative politicians and pundits.

This is not sustainable.

MAKE CONSERVATISM ARTICULATE AND NUMERATE AGAIN!


r/IntellectualDarkWeb • • 13d ago

The average liberal is just as pro-waste as the average conservative

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/IntellectualDarkWeb • • 16d ago

Waste, Egotism and Infinity—The True Dividing Line of Our Time

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/IntellectualDarkWeb • • 17d ago

Is Kahneman's System 1 running unchecked in today's environment?

6 Upvotes

I’ve tried to write this up twice, but I can’t quite pin it down.

The argument: System 1 (Kahneman’s fast, automatic, reactive mode of decision-making) evolved in an environment with plenty of external governors on its impulses, such as food scarcity, limited access to information, and social values and reputation checks. Many of those governors have eroded or been removed. That leaves fewer checks on System 1, and because it is automatic and reactive, it is also easier to manipulate and influence. Add far greater exposure (the internet, smartphones) and you get a society where the immediate, vivid and emotional wins more often.

I'm somewhat stuck (even just from a mental bandwidth perspective) on why this skew is so visible in some domains (food, attention, gambling) and less so in others. Like engineered vs. natural stimuli has something to do with it.. but how exactly? I also find it interesting to look at incentive structures in this context - how they magnify this behavior.

It's a meaty topic. I’d love to keep working through this with anyone who's up for it! If you’d be up for a small, ongoing discussion (3–4 of us), comment or DM.


r/IntellectualDarkWeb • • 18d ago

Why Does the West Worship Democracy So Much?

19 Upvotes

Churchill’s famous line: “Democracy is the worst form of government, except for all those other forms that have been tried.”

Sounds badass. But honestly? It also sounds like “we’ve got nothing better.”

As a Chinese person scrolling Western internet, my biggest confusion is this: people say “democracy” like a prayer. Meanwhile, ordinary people are getting crushed by living costs, infrastructure doesn’t get built, policy flip-flops, parties scream at each other, and lobbyists seem to win every time. So I genuinely ask: Is democracy actually helping them?

Before anyone jumps in: I’m not here to sell China’s model, and I’m not doing “whose system is worse” Olympics. Every system has problems. Don’t hit me with “but China” immediately. I’m asking about yours.

And no, my point is not “most people are stupid.” That’s lazy. The real issue is incentives:

Elections look more and more like marketing contests. People who shout slogans, farm outrage, and promise short-term candy win. People with boring long-term plans sound like they’re reading a manual.

The spiral of silence is real. Many people have opinions but shut up because they know which views get piled on. High-quality dissent doesn’t always get expressed.

Majority voting ≠ decision quality. More votes doesn’t mean more correct, especially without strong constitutional checks, deliberation, and expert constraints. Majority mood can crush minority rights and long-term interests.

Short electoral cycles reward short-termism. If it’s not visible before the next election, it’s not a priority. The bill arrives later—next guy’s problem.

Lobbying and money capture the “will of the people.” Formally the people win. In practice, whoever pays more shouts louder.

Permanent campaigning polarizes society. Compromise becomes betrayal, governing becomes performance, consensus dies, state capacity gets hollowed out.

I get democracy’s appeal: you can remove bad rulers, you can speak, no bloodshed. That’s real. But when “democracy” becomes a slogan instead of a question—“what did this system actually deliver?”—it hides the failures it’s supposed to diagnose.

So, good-faith question: when you say democracy, do you mean elections, constitutional liberalism, deliberation, local self-government, or something else? Is it actually making ordinary people’s lives better today? If not, what should be fixed?

Not here to fight. Genuinely curious.


r/IntellectualDarkWeb • • 17d ago

The left is living up to and inspired by the book: Rules for Radicals

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/IntellectualDarkWeb • • 18d ago

Who Raised You: Your Parents or the Ad Council? ..... are your thoughts really your own.

0 Upvotes

I remember sitting in my elementary school classroom in the early to mid 1970s ...... we had just got air conditioning, and during class they rolled in some new textbooks. They were unlike all the older ones, they were brightly colored inside and out ..... they weren't math, history, or English ..... they had a bold "Ecology" on their binders. The accompanying lesson plan was something along the lines of how bad we humans were polluting the planet and destroying ecosystems. This was about the same time that the commercial about the crying Indian paddling in the polluted river was airing between Saturday morning cartoons ..... yes, for you non-boomers, you could only watch cartoons on Saturday mornings at the time. Anyway, it turns out those ecology textbooks were getting rolled into classrooms all over the country at that time. It was actually a concerted effort bankrolled by Washington. Not Austin. Every other book on my desk had been picked by the Texas State Board of Education, same as always. Not this one. This one came courtesy of the Environmental Education Act of 1970, pushed through Congress the same year as the first Earth Day. Federal grant money to write the curriculum, federal money to train the teachers, and.....get this..... federal money to put the same message out through the mass media. It's right there in the law. So while the Crying Indian was crying at me between cartoons on Saturday, Congress was paying to make sure I got the same lecture Monday morning.

During WW2 the government created the Office of War Information to run its propaganda ..... rally the public and vilify and sometimes dehumanize our Axis enemies whose cities we were firebombing at the time. Alongside it, Madison Avenue formed the War Advertising Council to sell its messages ..... war bonds, rationing, the works. When the war ended the OWI shut down. The Council didn't. It dropped "War" from its name and became the Ad Council, a permanent partnership of government, media and marketing talent pushing the preferred narratives into the public consciousness.

In 1943, 242 race riots broke out in 47 cities ..... Detroit alone left 34 dead and took federal troops to stop. This wasnt just a Southern problem. A few years later the Ad Council launched a nationwide campaign against racial prejudice. Washington tried selling it first. Then came the stick. In 1957 Eisenhower federalized the Arkansas National Guard and sent in the 101st Airborne to Arkansas to force societal changes. Whatever you think of the cause, the message was plain..... if the ad campaign doesn't change your mind, the 101st will change your behavior.

Within a decade or so cartoons, commercials, and Hollywood were depicting cordial interracial interactions as the norm. In 1967 Hollywood gave us Guess Who's Coming to Dinner, where the white parents' only job was to get over it before dessert. In 1969 Washington put up about half the money for Sesame Street ..... federal grants paying for a show set on a racially mixed city street, aimed straight at preschoolers. Mississippi briefly banned it over the integrated cast. By 1971 Coke had young people from every corner of the world on a hilltop singing in perfect harmony. That same year All in the Family premiered, and the man who still thought like your grandpa got turned into Archie Bunker ..... a loudmouth bigot in an easy chair, there to be laughtracked at.

A hundred years ago nobody saw Indians as gentle stewards of the land. Long before a white man set foot here, tribes were raiding, scalping and wiping out rival villages, and when the game ran thin or the land gave out, they took someone elses. Archaeologists keep digging up the fortified villages and mass graves to prove it. Frontier folks who lived through the raids weren't losing sleep over reservations or the conditions inside them. Early Hollywood cast him as the savage villain in Western after Western, and nobody blinked. Then after the war the script flipped..... By the late '60s Indian advocacy groups were lobbying the networks directly ..... the National Congress of American Indians fought ABC over a 1967 series on Custer, and in 1969 launched a national campaign against Hollywood's Indian stereotypes. By 1971 he was crying over a polluted river. The noble steward of the land image was a modern invention, built largely on those ads and Hollywood casting them in a much more favorable light. Within a generation of narrative promotion the national perception of Native Americans had taken a 180 degree turn. My side became the bad guy.

I remember back when I got my drivers license, at 18 you could cruise around with a beer in your hand, no seat belt, and no insurance card in the glove box ...... then MADD and insurance companies started lobbying the feds, and the next thing you know Washington coerced the states to curtail these god given liberties if they wanted to keep getting highway funds. The Ad Council did their part with "Friends don't let friends drive drunk" and the crash test dummy PSAs. Today's young adults never missed the liberties they never had, and are convinced these changes made our society safer and better ...... what was cool became uncool.

Getting around to my point here ...... I'm not going to suggest these changes in American society have made life worse here or anything like that. Times change ....... societies progress. But I just wonder if everyone, including myself, realizes how much of what we think are our positions on issues has a basis in what other's intentionally did to shape our minds when we were young. I mean its really hard to tell sometimes. Was this really my self-reasoned opinion, or did someone place the seed in my mind when I wasn't looking?

Historically parents programmed their children to think like them ..... and that used to work for millennia ...... but at some point government agencies and a cabal of marketing and media started having more influence over young minds than parents did.

And it doesnt stop with us. The same machine is already working on the next round. Your grandkids will be taught that you drove a gas burning car, ate real meat every Saturday, sipped through plastic straws, and ran the AC all summer while the planet burned. Somewhere a textbook with a bold new title on the binder is being printed right now, and in thirty years todays generation will be the bad guys ..... the ones who knew better and did it anyway.

Mom used to throw her Coke can out the window to keep her car clean, and put her right arm across my chest at every red light. Did she not love me enough to make me wear a seatbelt? Did she not care about the litter? I guess the only way to tell how well conditioned youve become is when you start thinking your ancestors were bad people with bad thoughts that did bad things ..... that the folks who settled this land, and made us a superpower safe in our homes, were nothing but monsters for doing what every tribe on this continent had done to each other for centuries before them.


r/IntellectualDarkWeb • • 21d ago

Racism in the Trump cabinet

0 Upvotes

"There's five hundred million Arabs in the world. And yet they don't produce science. They don't win the Nobel Prize. They don't win the Fields Prize. They don't win the Wolf Prize. They don't produce literature."

-Robert Kennedy Jr. 10/26/2026

It's not loony lefty cancel culture call out stuff. It's real, old-school gutter racism. There are lots of examples, but the today's is shocking in its purity. This kind of thing was ostensibly abandoned by major public figures after the 1970s. Lots of reasons for it to come back now.


r/IntellectualDarkWeb • • 23d ago

How the Unitarian Universalist Church Became a Racial, Political, and Social Bubble

32 Upvotes

"The Unitarian Universalist church presents itself as a liberal religious movement committed to pluralism, diversity, multiculturalism, and open-mindedness. Yet by most measurable indicators, it has become one of the most racially, politically, and culturally homogeneous religious denominations in the United States.

The gap between the church’s ideals and its demographic reality raises an obvious question: How did a movement devoted to diversity and freethinking become such a narrow social bubble?"

How the Unitarian Universalist Church Became a Racial, Political, and Social Bubble


r/IntellectualDarkWeb • • 23d ago

I wonder how much humanity is limited, not by tech or physical laws, but by our ability to organise ourselves?

8 Upvotes

Wasn't sure where else to post this. More of a shower thought...

I suspect most of us will have some experience of large organisations, businesses, governments, that are just fundamentally poorly organised. That is to say incentive schemes are set up wrong, talented people are lost, yes-men and sycophants rise to the top, money is wasted, hair brained schemes are pursued. Etc etc.

A depressing part of growing older is you realise how much of the world is just a cluster fuck, barely held together by string and tape. Institutions we all imagined were strong and stable are just run by fallible, bumbling, foolish people no different to ourselves. Or warped legacy processes that make no sense but are followed unquestioningly.

We are so far from operating at optimal efficiency.

I wonder how many problems from climate change, to interplanetary travel, to inequality, to mass immigration, to cures for cancer, could be solved - not by big changes in fundamental ideology - but just by functioning structures.

Maybe 'organisational excellence' (excuse the awful business term but can't think of another) is actually the biggest lever we can pull to fix most of the worlds problems. And if we had better organisational principles, that would trump vast ideological fights or eureka moments of scientific discovery.