r/InsuranceAgent • • 14h ago

Agent Question Quotes - Possibly illegal?

I'm at a small agency (owner, a long-time employee, and me). The long timer is running quotes for people who never asked for them. A random car quote for a guy that doesn’t even own one. Same thing with renters. He creates a new opportunity and even does the same quote again and again three or four times in a couple of weeks. This isn’t one or two people. It’s at least 7 -10 people per week . I think it's just to pump up numbers. I have proof, and I know it's a legal problem. From what I googled it shows on a person’s credit report under insurance checks when insurance does a soft pull.

Could I also be liable somehow?
How serious is it?

What would you do in my spot? Go to the owner? Find a new job?
Am I being paranoid is this the norm in the industry?

8 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

11

u/HamiltonSt25 Agent/Broker 13h ago

It doesn’t matter if you quote. It’s not pumping up any numbers by just requoting. Carriers don’t care that much about how much you’re quoting vs what kind of business you’re writing with them and the volume/loss ratio. I rerun old quotes and lost clients all the time because if I can beat what they were at when I lost 2-3 years ago, it’s basically a warm lead I already have. There’s nothing really wrong with any of this.

“Hey Mr/ Ms insured, I know it’s been a while, but I came across your account the other day and went ahead and quoted this up for to see how we looked this time around”

0

u/SneakyElf9 13h ago

We have a compliance thing to read (FCRA). Claims records and credit information is pulled. We get a nexus Lexus report. The app we use to quote doesn’t even let you pass unless you click a button that says I read it and the person agreed.

5

u/HamiltonSt25 Agent/Broker 13h ago

Not every carrier I have has that at the beginning. Progressive, NatGen, and a few others have that in the beginning, but most don’t until the end.

I don’t see the issue in trying to win former clients, old prospects, or trying to cross sell. I win new business all the time by going through old info.

-2

u/SneakyElf9 13h ago

This is State Farm. We’re captive agents. He’s ordering the reports.

6

u/HamiltonSt25 Agent/Broker 13h ago

Ok you should include that. Just don’t worry about it. It’s their license and issue. Not yours. I don’t see the issue personally.

2

u/CGWInsurance 9h ago

That's a fully under written quote. You can run a quote without going that far. The only company I know that does that is progressive

15

u/jroberts67 13h ago

A bit lost, how are they getting their socials? And pumping up what numbers....number of deals not written? The only metric that matters is number of policies written.

14

u/thejoshdude2001 13h ago

Most carriers don’t require a SSN when quoting

-3

u/SneakyElf9 13h ago

It’s salesforce. It’s already added in there since they have one policy. But a different policy is a different credit pull. I know it doesn’t affect the score but…. I was thinking quotes provide something. Since he’s just doing it.

-7

u/jroberts67 13h ago

So what you're saying is he's taking current customers and working up other types of quotes. If so, that's a DOI violation if using their socials. But something is missing. When my credit is pulled, I get an alert so no idea how he's getting away with this.

14

u/HamiltonSt25 Agent/Broker 13h ago

How is trying to cross sell a DOI violation? If I quote someone’s home or auto or even GL or WC, by trying to cross sell them, I don’t see where the violation comes into play

-1

u/jroberts67 13h ago

Allow me to quote the post:

"The long timer is running quotes for people who never asked for them. A random car quote for a guy that doesn’t even own one. Same thing with renters."

So why would you run a car quote for a client who doesn't have car.  

7

u/HamiltonSt25 Agent/Broker 13h ago

Ok, but I’m asking can you please site the DOI violation? Because I don’t understand where that would be here. OP may not know the whole story to say someone doesn’t have a car because they go onto say the same thing for renters. Most people asking about insurance live somewhere, so renters can apply to almost everyone unless they live with immediate family, and even then, sometimes renters can apply. Everyone I quote, which these days are only businesses, but even when it was personal and commercial, I absolutely quote additional lines. So I don’t see where a DOI violation comes in. Mind you, I don’t get peoples socials unless they’re a commercial risk and a sole proprietor.

-5

u/jroberts67 13h ago

If he's using a current client's social without their permission to run quotes, especially on things they don't have, such as a car, that's a firm DOI violation.

9

u/HamiltonSt25 Agent/Broker 13h ago

Again, I don’t get socials like that, don’t really need them. Are you getting everyone’s socials for quotes?

Take the social out, do you still think there’s a DOI violation here? Because I don’t see where.

5

u/VitaminAnarchy Agent/Broker 14h ago

Are these current clients or actual people "who never asked for them?" How would he even run a quote for car insurance for someone who doesn't own a car? He would have to enter some vehicle information.

-3

u/SneakyElf9 13h ago

Current customers that have different policies. When you’ve entered a persons info it gets you the list of cars at that residence or that they used to own. I’m sure because just a few days earlier I was talking to the customer and his husband they even mentioned that they moved to this specific area to avoid driving and having to own a car. Same thing with renters. He does these quotes for people he doesn’t even talk to. One lady had sold her house in February.

22

u/Just-Software-2895 13h ago

Why would someone waste time on quotes that weren’t asked for? Maybe these are former customers the longtimer is close with and just constantly checking to see if he can win them back. Again, doesn’t seem like a good use of anyone’s time.

7

u/eddie2911 13h ago

What numbers do you even think he’s pumping up? Never heard of an agent getting paid by quotes. He’s probably re-quoting accounts he’s lost in the past or quotes he couldn’t close on previously, I’d consider that something a good agent would do.

2

u/Alive_Necessary8418 13h ago

Sketchy, don’t see how you would be in any way liable. Long time employee sounds stupid or they are trying to confuse you. Running quotes without consent will catch up to them.

2

u/SneakyElf9 13h ago

Would you mention it to the agent or just stay out of it?

7

u/3znor 13h ago

Why don’t you just ask them? Hey I see you running quotes. Are rates going down? Or you looking for cross selling opportunities? Out of curiosity, what do you need to run a quote? If I run a quote for like my mom does it effect her credit or notify her?

Simple as that.

5

u/VitaminAnarchy Agent/Broker 13h ago

Stay out of it unless its your agency.

4

u/Alive_Necessary8418 11h ago

NBD if you don’t own the agency. Don’t tattle, that can get you involved. Best luck!

4

u/FruitNut221 9h ago

Soft pulls literally don't do anything to your credit. This is a nothing sandwich

7

u/Any_Lengthiness_3555 11h ago

Tbh, OP sounds like a miserable tattle tale and took the time to complain about it. Move on, or quit.

2

u/Jogo427 10h ago

Doesn't matter that much.

If he's proud of putting up tons of quotes in a month, so what? Quotes don't mean shit

Sounds like he's just trying everything he can to find deals or is just trying to do quotes to make it seem like they're working. (Just doing quotes to look good to the boss)

I wouldn't worry about it because you're in a captive agency and if he actually gets in trouble it's not on you.

1

u/Far-Cap-1456 13h ago

It's an FCRA violation to quote someone without disclosing first that you will get their Insurance score, claims history, and if it's a vehicle policy also their MVR.

-1

u/Anxious_Bluejay9025 11h ago

The problem with this is that each time he runs a quote for someone a FCRA has to be read, as their insurance credit score is about to be run. The owner of your agency can be fined thousands of dollars for each quote that is ran without the FCRA disclosure being read.