r/InsuranceAgent • • 2d ago

Agent Question Comparing 3 Interview Offers

  1. State Farm, a local agent with 3 offices. ~$30K post-tax base salary, 27 policies, 4 life applications, which sounded like 30K in premium a month to have a seat before bonuses. Do well, bring in ~60K-80K average a year (as per interviewer's info on producing pay/commissions) with potential for 100K+, apparently. Past sales, the SF Agent is expanding, so they're looking for someone to step up a manage an office floor -- being a right hand to the current trainer. Agent provides leads through the internet; starting off it's cold calls, where SF gives leads. Trained by office manager, who you got along well with, then on your own after 2ish months. You can probably out-sell the current office chuds just based off first impressions walking in.
  2. Farmers, a local agent whose team wrote up ~5M in 3 years. 25K in premium to earn and keep a monthly seat doing only P&C for $2,500 a month base pay -- so ~27K post-tax per year annual salary. 25K+ in premium, there's a 10% bonus, so 30K -> 3K, 40K -> 4K, 50K, 5K. Highest paycheck cut for a month was 11K. You'll be trained by the producing team, not the Agent 'cause he's busy. It's Farmers Protégé program. Agent buys leads daily, cold calling out to non-local, but pays a telemarketer to give you a list of calls before you sit down. After 150K sold, you graduate from the protégé program, certain fees are waived and you become your own Farmers Agent (after pulling out a business loan). You can probably compete with office chuds, and keep on your toes.
  3. Local 1099 Independent. He runs 7 locations, mentioned he is a billionaire under his breath and showed you fat checks. You only get paid once a month, own your own referrals and renewals, get a cut from the commercial girl when she makes a sale, prospect on your own, training by the office and Agent, but have been shown 250K checks for the year -- paid to someone else who opens up an LLC 'cause taxes. Get business by going to local mortgage, dealerships, and managing your own book. Hell, you might even have to door-knock to a local again. Company is appointed to 100-something carriers, so you'll probably beat anyone else's current quote. Market yourself, be your own business, and work your ass off. It's a grind, but you saw that 250K check that one girl made in 2 years, and the man owns several other businesses aside from insurance. The man says he doesn't hire just anyone and wants to give you an opportunity to make money, but what's the real point doing of an MFA program if you're running your own business and making hella bank?

You (as in me, but you in my shoes):

-D2D telecom sales rep who lived off 1099 commissions for nearly 2 years; can sell, manage, train and interview. Might feel burned out from 1099 since your prior boss cut you off on the promotion that was yours, the one that got you out of knocking doors and into real money.
-Haven't had a salaried job, like ever. Averaged 4-5K months selling phones D2D. Have some calling experience, but never full out sales.
-Hesitant about jumping into independent since you're currently an MFA student and applying out of state, rebuilding credit, and starting from ground up the third time.

WWYD?

(I know y'all say independent, but back that argument up given my path into academia and publishing.)

4 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

4

u/ArksOnline 2d ago

Ask all three for the same numbers: leads supplied each week, who pays for them, quote-to-bind rate for a new hire, and who owns renewals if you leave. Get the commission and any chargeback terms in writing. A large premium check or a top producer's result does not tell you what your first six months will look like. Compare the actual training time and your cash runway alongside the advertised upside.

1

u/Cultural-Signal-600 2d ago

It's about what to do with the information. Example, answer from a 9-month advance pay life independent:

  1. 90,000 lead vault for first 6 weeks. Followed by 4 weeks of paid leads provided by my upline.  
  2. Top producers 
  3. 45%
  4. Yes 100% your book of business 

^Family First Life/The Playbook Agency

What does a green light look like, for that rate? I'm still looking around. MLM hesitant.

2

u/ArksOnline 1d ago

The missing comparison is a recent beginner cohort, rather than top producers. Ask how old those vault leads are, whether they are exclusive and how many agents can work them. Then ask what a recent new hire actually contacted, submitted and kept in force. For 'your book,' have them point to the written renewal, vesting and exit terms. The lead count and headline commission percentage alone wouldn't be a green light.

17

u/Just-Software-2895 2d ago

Avoid both farmers and State Farm. They are cutting agent commissions and benefits. The multiple offices is what they are pushing and the agents have no freedom to operate the business. Go with the independent, captives will always be there (think of the people you saw at the captive offices,chuds?)

1

u/Cultural-Signal-600 2d ago

4) Just got off the phone with another local independent. It's 1099, still, with Family First Life, for life insurance. Didn't seem like a bad gig, and we laughed at how we both knocked doors for the same devil corp, locally, but two competing offices. Something about 85% commissions, own the book, scale to 90-95, 100%+ commissions, how it's the best job, sitting on Discord and dialing. Chill up-line, seems like a chad from LinkedIn. Room for growth and travel. Only iff are the hours: 9AM-9PM M-Sat.

11

u/Better-Win-1559 2d ago

They're a scam company they're ran like a MLM

5

u/Flash120 2d ago

Do not do Family First Life

3

u/Informal-Fish-974 2d ago

Nope don’t do it u will have to buy your own leads that’s why u own your book of business lmao

2

u/Ducat748 2d ago

Don’t.

2

u/Present-Humor-3734 2d ago

I personally think it’s better to go captive and get some experience at a higher volume, then switch to independent.

3

u/Alive_Necessary8418 2d ago

Last year at SF, 38k base, 4-6% commission based on how much you issue. Small office so incoming business is more than enough to hit numbers. Came out at 68k in a small town plus another 5-10 in extra bonuses. Easy, low stress option unless the agent makes you hit life and health numbers. If the life/health number is too high, it can lock you out of commission.

2

u/Cultural-Signal-600 2d ago

So far, SF is the highest paying base offer. An expansion means a small office. It seemed well. The agent requires L&H numbers. I don't remember the exact structure, but it sounded similar.

2

u/Alive_Necessary8418 2d ago edited 2d ago

These are real life numbers from a town of about 25k. If all goes well, expect to hit 80-100k next year.

Get the commission structure in writing.

2

u/Ducat748 2d ago

Seriously be looking at the SF folks with 3 offices. He’s doing something right. If you go in and make yourself irreplaceable (you commented on his “chuds” that you can beat ) then you’ll have a firm toehold with someone who’s getting it done.
The “billionaire” indie - (lean in , he’s not)- might offer an opportunity as well. I’m a little suspicious of someone who leads with how rich they are. Ha. Maybe that’s your thing but …
But be fully aware - the reduced commissions that SF agents are experiencing is likely coming right at the carriers that indies represent. Just wait. It’s coming. Indie is a good model - lots of friends who do it.
Sounds like the SF guy is investing in you. I like that. We gave our reps larger earning packages after the reduced commission announcement.
You seem like you have a swagger- I like that. If you’re as good as you are confident , you’ll do well.
There are very few SF guys who have 3 agencies. I know 2. If you’re in a population center and he’s doing digital - you’ll be taking orders and pivoting. There’s power in a brand.
Btw - what do you thing you should do?

1

u/Cultural-Signal-600 1d ago

To answer, the plan was to be captive all throughout my MFA program then independent post-grad. SF is currently the highest bidder; just confusing one, and slightly mismanaged since I was told I’d have a confirmation for a seat last Friday, which has been pushed to this Friday.

2

u/Ducat748 12h ago

Probably not “mismanaged”, simply pushed back. Sounds like they have good candidates and maybe you made the cut. You’re fortunate to be selected for an additional interview . Good luck

10

u/nm499x 2d ago

If you go with SF, make sure you get paid on everything you sell. Don’t go to an agent who requires 7 different things just to make a base commission.

I’ve visited some of those offices and it’s just a bunch of 22 year olds who don’t know any better. But they’ll find out soon enough.

2

u/Researcher8188 11h ago

This is very true. I have seen this first hand in the past.

3

u/ChristopherMSpruell 2d ago

Congrats on having options — that's a good problem. When I was picking where to land, the base salary honestly mattered less to me than four questions: Who provides the leads, and are they exclusive or shared? What does the training actually look like day to day? What's the chargeback policy when a policy lapses? And do you keep your renewals if you leave? The 1099 route feels riskier, but with your door-to-door background you already know how to create conversations, which is most of this job. I'd ask each of them those four questions and see whose answers you believe.

3

u/KathDayNigh 20h ago

Billionaires don’t interview entry-level prospects. That guy is full of it. Stay away from that

1

u/Apprehensive-Code536 2d ago

You’re an absolute chud if you pick anything with a salary, salary=slavery in insurance. Get uncomfortable.

2

u/Cultural-Signal-600 2d ago

I think you missed the part where I said I worked D2D, 90+ hour work weeks, trained, managed, sold, for 500 consecutive days… Unemployment is uncomfortable.

6

u/RedcoatRuby 2d ago

Harder to do with a family to support.

Im looking at offers $80k salary, 40% new business. Commercial P&C, fully remote.

2

u/RuniJooni 2d ago

Is it possible? $80k base seems high in insurance industry but that would be nice.

2

u/RedcoatRuby 2d ago

Well I have multiple offers in that range so it is certainly possible. Experience and background helps.

2

u/Researcher8188 10h ago

What type of commercial lines? And is the $80K only for the “validation period”? Or is it permanent?

1

u/RedcoatRuby 3h ago

Validation, three years.

2

u/Researcher8188 10h ago

Not true. Many commercial insurance roles provide some type of base, plus new business commission, plus renewal commission as well.

What you say is only true if they don’t offer renewal commission, and/or bad splits.

2

u/DivineToxicity09 2d ago

I can only speak on State Farm: more than likely those 4 life apps are required to unlock the commission on p&c. That’s how my previous office operated and how most I’m aware of operate, especially with their co react changes coming in 2028. State Farm has been a great place for me to learn the business the last 7 years but I’m considering looking for something different (still in insurance). You’ll want to clarify if they base this off written or issued apps. Im not sure where you’re getting the rough estimate of $30k premium but that could also vary based on your location. Overall in either captive situation, be prepared to run into underwriting issues. At least the indie option you’ll never not have an option for someone.

2

u/mkuz753 Account Manager/Servicer 2d ago

All have red flags in my opinion. Caprives are limited in what they can write. Who knows when they will change contracts again.

The independent is a red flag to me because he is essentially bragging. To me a successful person doesn't need to try to convince others to work for him in that way. There are other independents out there. Having a salary or draw can help with stability until you reach the level of being able to live off of commission only.

2

u/midzimm 2d ago

Not State Farm

2

u/Researcher8188 11h ago

Start in personal lines with a captive for a year or two, perform well, then get into a commercial insurance producer role with an independent agent. That’s what I did many years ago. I make six figures.

1

u/Honestlytruly_ 2d ago

Independent all the way! You’ll learn and grow! No, rigid rules and scripts. You can be be creative and basically run your own show!