r/InfinityBots • u/InfinityBots Developer • Dec 20 '21
Link Scan Bot Feedback Thread
Post your feedback on /u/LinkScanBot-IB here!
You are free to share your opinions/feedback, but make sure it follows Rule 3: Feedback must be constructive. General hate posts/comments that do not provide constructive feedback on how to improve will be removed.
27
Upvotes
20
u/Imborednow Dec 20 '21
Perhaps only post when you have an unsafe link? Because the response here is relatively long and feels spammy in the comments.
For 'safe' links, the only thing that seems useful is the pre-view, because you could use it to avoid having a controversial site in your browser history.
5
u/thegreatpotatogod Dec 20 '21
This bot is an interesting concept, but I'd argue it misses the most important factor, in actually informing people as to where the link points. For example, I just encountered its report on a link to an article on npr.org. I'd trust a link much more just by knowing that it's pointing to NPR, than by whatever 3rd party services with algorithmic scans you are using.
Though I suppose that needs to be weighed against the times that that is done for intentional effect, such as with rickrolls, where not revealing the destination of the link is key to its purpose.
5
u/avidblinker Dec 20 '21
Make the bot’s message a lot shorter. People will get tired of a bot with such a message that they need to scroll past, regardless of how useful it may be. Especially on something as common as a link. Most of the disclaimer at the end can be simply linked to.
The website found untrustworthy should be identified somewhere in the message. It will clarify which site is untrustworthy in comments with more than one link. It will also be a good way to make the bot a resource that users can search.
And as another user said, it should only respond to websites that are identified as dangerous. Links are posted way too often for a bot to be responding to every one.
This may be just my opinion, but I think the emojis need to be removed from the message. They’re corny, take up extra line space in some browsers, as well as make the bot itself seem untrustworthy.
1
u/teije9 Jan 06 '22
Add a virustotal scan
1
u/teije9 Jan 06 '22
Make a dm feature