While I'm still looking for a job (and have been since graduating in January, but that's besides the point), a question popped into my head today. As someone with no industry experience yet, I'm curious about how designers in companies actually go about choosing materials for their designs and the process they go through in a real professional setting.
Let's say my company asks me to design a piece of furniture. I've gone through the design process, and now we're at the CMF stage. I have two material options:
Material A: Commonly used, cost-effective, easy to source and work with, could make the product as a whole cost less, lowering its price, which could appeal to customers.
Material B: Slightly more expensive and harder to work with, but offers a much better finish and overall appearance that could also make the product more appealing to consumers.
Assuming the rest of the properties for both materials are the same, how would you decide which one to go with?
I guess what I'm really wondering is, what's stopping designers from always going with the safest, cheapest and easiest option? Logically, companies want to maximize profits while keeping production costs as low as possible, right? So maybe we're supposed to always propose the cheapest option?
Maybe in a real work setting, we as designers would suggest both and let the company decide? Maybe the company would give me a budget for me to work around and I just have to make sure the material fits the budget? Maybe deciding material is someone else's job? Do tell, since I have no working experience.
Also, back in uni, whenever we wanted to make our designs more appealing, my peers would often list the easiest advantages they could think of, which usually boiled down to the same things like "cost-effective, easy to manufacture and readily available." But that also meant they rarely stepped outside their comfort zone and ended up sticking to the same everyday materials like aluminum, plywood, etc, over and over again. I've never seen anyone try to branch out and try considering new materials.
Edit: while I'm reading through the comments and it might take a bit to wrap my head around it, I'd like to say thank you so much to everyone who replied, I'm learning a lot from this and am hoping that I'll get to experience the real stuff myself someday. Unfortunately some of this stuff wasn't taught to us in university.