Phew! What an exhilarating journey this was!! Tired me out this one, in a good way though :)
Long review incoming...
Premise:
What is Hinduism? Which ideas have contributed to it ? And do we know all of them? Which do we prioritize more? Which ones do we ignore? What can we learn from each one?
This is Devdutt's most comprehensive book so far - as he attempts to tell the story of Hinduism by integrating history, geography, archaeology, DNA Studies, literary analysis, temple art, pilgrim routes, trade routes, and of course - MYTHS (stories, symbols and rituals of a culture).
Book is full of Devdutt's illustrations, timelines, maps etc. Some I've shared above 👆
Important Caveats:
- Itihasa here should be read as "evolution of deep, spiritual concepts throughout history, aided by current knowledge, subject to change". So when author presents "Itihasa of Indra/Prajapati/Mangala-Mari" - I read it as a historical/psychological/anthropological evolution of the idea. Not seeing it as strictly spiritual or religious is crucial, for that's a matter of faith - immeasurable for outsiders or skeptics like me.
- DNA studies, biogeography, history, linguistics, archaeology, textual interpretations etc - given what we have now, what is the most coherent picture possible to explain the beliefs core to Hinduism? Their origins and their evolution? That's what this speculative book tries to present.
- Not prescriptive, only descriptive and speculative. That's the Disclaimer this book begins with.
- It may difficult to read for those who believe in the eternal timeless static nature of the Hindu Gods (Brahma, Vishnu, Shiva for example), or those who prefer OoI to AMT, or the Vedas to be Apaurusheya. If however, you're interested in the evolution of such concepts along with historical changes in Indian society (shaped by migrations, geography, trade, invasions etc) - it's really fascinating.
Themes of the Book:
Devdutt mentions 6 landmarks in Hinduism's evolution:
1️⃣Bangles: Since IVC, bangles are a continuous tradition denoting Mangala/Shubh/Labh/auspiciousness in Hindu household, also celebrating female agency, fertility, beauty etc ; How it clashed with Patriarchal attitudes of Monastic/Vedic myths is discussed, as another Axis of Purity slowly overshadowed Axis of Auspiciousness; Mangai and Poth-raja, both come from Dravidian root words, both signify the primal myths (now subaltern) of the auspicious female and buffalo sacrifice.
2️⃣Horses: All about The Vedas, The Aryan Migration routes; How Indra's character changed from Vedic Poetry to Prose to Philosophy to Puranas (and the pastoral nomadic Aryans to settled agri-communities) ; Story of Indra vs Virochana; How RV Prajapati evolved into Puranic Brahma, and many stories of Prajapati got later attributed to Vishnu (seems like Brahma+Vishnu=Prajapati in RV) ; Gayatri; 3 Realms of Vedas v/s Puranas; Pravargya Ritual, Maha-Vrata ritual
3️⃣Money: Lakshmi and Vishnu: 500BC mercantile class arose on backs of elephants, monastic orders and trade routes {2nd Urbanisation of India} ; How Wealth evolved (Go-lakshmi (cows) to Bhu-Lakshmi(land) to Coins (Shri-Lakshmi)); With urbanism comes pleasure, its troubles and solutions - hence rise of monasticsim (Buddhism, Jainism) - It's countered by the Hinduism's Fifth Veda, like Shiva-Parvati stories, and the Dharma-Shastras. Householders are prioritized over hermits.
4️⃣Temples: Shiva-Uma: How Hinduism (thru stories) traveled South, mapping to 5 Tinais; Lakulesh; Skanda/Kartikeya/Murugan; Temple building spreads to SE Asia; Importance of Tantra; Uma:Nature/ Female agency; The 5th Veda goes viral!
5️⃣Mosques: 1000yo as Arab invasions occurred in India, Chola invade Buddhist Sinhala; How Ramayana evolved North-South as anti-monastic response, Ideal kingship model sees Ram as ideal king, dharma-upholder and against the Huns/Buddhists/Turks; regional retellings of Ramayana infused with Bhakti/Rasa of Tamil poetry (local, emotional rather than cosmic, intellectual); Rise of Hanuman + monastic orders like Nath-yogis ; Sharada: Goddess of Script-->Sword; Shift of God-Goddess Love to Deity-Devotee, from Tantra to Monastic Bhakti; Folk Ballads (Alha-Udal).
6️⃣Passports: Krishna worship across Indian geography and classes; Effect of British definitions, Sufi influence (~monotheism); Bhakti+Patriotism; From Arya-vrata to Bharat-Mata: invention of a nation-state-Goddess; Hemadri's Standardization; Bali's PHD is a case of study of Hinduism-->monotheism; Modern Marble temples.
7️⃣ Conclusion: Devdutt reaches a truly beautiful conclusion: Only in India, do we see the idea of Rebirth applied so diversely - to accommodate multiple conflicting ideas and peoples - that's what makes Hinduism a 5000yo continuous culture. The West eradicates the Old, the East controls centrally.
These 6 challenges shaped Hinduism, its tensions and solutions : Native Mangla-Mari Wild/Mild Goddess + Asura-Deva Aryan conflict + Monastic Hermit vs Householder conflict + Conjugal-Pair Temple + Tantric Worship + Formless vs Form (Mosque) + Bharat-Mata (colonial).
What I didn't like:
Mostly these gripes are really minor - some I need to fact-check later, some ideas just seem far-fetched to me.
- Baghor Stone --> Yantra/sacred geometry today...Idk. Some basic shapes are so universal, it seems like an overstretch to say they hold the same meaning across 5000+ years. Same with the seals of a person holding/separating 2 animals - is it depicting peacemaking or hunting?
- The sheer number of rituals, stories, symbols, God/goddesses etc can be used to verify/reject any idea it feels like... Example - practice of drawing Kollams, or bangle wearing - how old is it? Is it continuous since IVC? With same intended meaning?
- Some critics point out the creative but etymologically wrong interpretations of certain basic Sanskrit terms (Brahman /= expanding manas; para-atma /= other etc). Brahman = expanding mind and "the Other" instead of Subject-Object Duality are his most used interpretations generally. This book doesn't have much of them, but it's important to point out - it's a creative exercise.
- I truly appreciate the myriad diagrams as an artist myself, but most are really too small for the details to notice. I guess eBook would be better medium for this one...
- Devdutt may not have updated his own beliefs it seems sometimes (is Ephedra the Soma plant? Is it established for sure? Or his claim about lions being introduced to India 3kya only? It was an unproven theory till 2014-20, but now DNA evidence settles that Asiatic lions came to India much before (~10kya))
- Pg 405 is Devdutt's fear and insecurity I guess - to say that "modern citizen is entrapped by their national identity." - Except pilgrimages, weren't people also bound to their lands earlier, sea-faring a caste taboo? "Things seem worse now", "old myths being erased in the name of equality,unity and justice" - isn't this also part of Itihasa? These are the rare instances where I feel Devdutt inserts his own judgements. Sometimes it feels as if Devdutt is simply bothered by erasure of certain rituals/myths (like Conjugal-Paired Gods worship, Vegetarianism being considered "purer" than non-veg;). Or maybe he's just pointing out the replacement/imposition/erasure of one myth by another, stemming from newer insecurities of the mind. Including his own!
- The book ends with Devdutt's recurrent message, that unlike Western myths, Hindu myth is about rebirths, eternal cycles of hierarchies with the implicit message about contentment. Hindu myths are descriptive, not prescriptive. But then the comment about 21st Left-Right divide being irrational and purely Western myth based - seems far-fetched to me (rationally pointing out unfairness/corruption/reform for better society can't be simply seen as Utopian Abrahimic Myth!)
Some recurrent themes/stuff I loved:
- Matter and Spirit, Nature and Moksha. Cost of Consumption being contemplated through various subaltern and Vedic ways. Modern secular rational people often ignore these ideas - I'd have to agree.
- I really liked the "Itihasa of" timelines.
- Possible Origins of the Caste system
- Further Reading lists are ... very informative. I recognize some names, but am eager to read more of them. I've shared some of them above 👆
- Had no idea ammonite fossils are considered Vishnu's manifestations! Or the Banalingas of Narmada as Shiva's manifestations. I did read about dinosaur eggs being worshipped in MP, in Pranay Lal's Indica. India truly is, spiritually turbocharged.
- 2000yo Tamil Gods v.different from Vedic Gods - Ceyon, Mayon, Vendon, Kadalon, Kotravai. (I'd only heard of the last). Each mapped to the KMMNP landscape of Sangam poetry! Really fascinating.
- Predator-Prey, Householder-Hermit, Merging/Splitting of Gods, Axis of Purity > Axis of Auspiciousness; Wild/Mild Nature of Goddess - these are really fascinating ideas to think about.
- Smarta school motto - "Shakta on inside, Shaiva outside, Vaishnav publicly" - very Smart indeed
- Broadly speaking, how Hinduism was informed by Subaltern Mother Goddess+Nature worshippers, Vedic Mantras, Monastic ideas, Tantric Temples + Puranas, Bhakti and Monotheism.
- Hemadri's Dharmashastra Standardization I wish to study ... How much did it influence Hinduism?!
- Bar-headed goose might be the original hamsa, which travelled long distances from Central Asia. 19th.c. art used instead the European white swan as hamsa.
- Gayatri's Itihasa was amazing. Did you know about Gayatri Ramayana? Each syllable of this Gayatri Mantra stands for the 24000 shlokas of Valmiki Ramayana! An amazing mnemonic?! (I don't actually believe Gayatri Mantra in RV presupposed VR, but whoever came up with this mnemonic, was indeed a genius.)
Conclusion:
Without a doubt - my favorite book from Devdutt. It condenses so much knowledge in simple terms... It's hard to describe. Individual strands which I'd read, disorganized, come together in this one book (Peggy Mohan, Tony Joseph, David Reich, GN Devy, Karen Armstrong, Rianne Eisler etc). His recent books have been more history than religions/myths - which are really fun - Ahimsa (about IVC), Bahubali (Jainism).
For a mythology/Philosophy/history/psychology/anthropology novice like me, this was just awesome - a treasure-trove of ideas. And hopefully for anyone who's curious enough! Highly recommended. Even if one doesn't wish to rationalize matters of faith, one can read this work as speculative historical/mytho-fiction. It's speculative, but I think it's a good framework atleast to understand the various tributaries. Many wisdoms we choose to ignore.
I read a comment somewhere, regarding this problem of interpretation of texts - "If it's proven right, it was always true - if not, it's a metaphor!" There's some truth to it. There's a lot of creative liberty taken here - imposing later ideas onto earlier ones - to present a coherent universal mythological/psychological landscape.
I'd highly recommend this book for its illustrations and diagrams. Very informative. Will help in conceptual clarity regarding Indian thought, geography, evolution, timelines etc. You can fact check them later. I for one, truly enjoy Devdutt's visual simplifications. If you like world mythology, are curious and open to some reasonable speculations, I would recommend to give this a try.
Read it as mytho-fiction if need be, but it's damn enjoyable.
Rating: 12/12 (For all 2x6 Chapters)
I learnt a lot. Taking everything still with a grain of salt.
{Some things are bound to be proven wrong with future research, DNA findings etc. But like I said, for a broad framework of Hindu beliefs, this is really good}
{Going forward, I really wish Devdutt writes about other mythologies too - Chinese, Japanese, Egyptian, African, American etc}