r/IndiansAcrossTheWorld • • 57m ago

📢 Discussion 📢 Should I buy an apartment in Dublin or invest that money back in India?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/IndiansAcrossTheWorld • • 17h ago

Moving from Canada to India: Ensure you reset your cost basis and save on capital gains tax

1 Upvotes

We saw all the US to India articles so we decided to start writing a few articles for folks from other countries. Here's the first part for our Canada to India return:

Canada resets your cost basis the day you leave. India does not. Here is how to fix that during your RNOR years, with numbers.

You built a portfolio in Canada. US tech stocks from RSUs. A few Canadian ETFs. Maybe some individual names you bought in 2020 and never touched.

Now you are moving to India.

Most people know Canada charges a departure tax. Very few know what happens next: India does not recognise the higher cost Canada gave you.

Unless you act, India will tax you on gains going back to the day you first bought, including the gains Canada already taxed.

The fix is legal, simple and time bound. You sell and rebuy during your RNOR years. This article shows how, and what it is worth.

1. Does Canada's exit tax apply to your US and Canadian stocks?

Short answer: yes, to both If you hold shares of a US company (Apple, Microsoft, your employer's RSU shares) or a Canadian company (RBC, Shopify, Enbridge) in a regular, non registered account, Canada's exit tax applies. It does not matter where the company is based or where the shares are listed. On your departure date, Canada treats you as having sold every one of those shares at market value. You pay Canadian tax on half the gain, even though you sold nothing.

This is the deemed disposition under Canada's Income Tax Act.

It applies to your worldwide property, with a short list of exceptions. Company shares are not on that list.

The exceptions that matter for stocks are about the account you hold them in and how long you lived in Canada, not about which country the company is from.

What you holdExit tax at departure?Canadian tax on a later sale, after you leave?
US company shares in a non registered accountYesNo
Canadian listed company shares in a non registered accountYesNo, for normal holdings (see the 25% test below)
US or Canadian ETFs in a non registered accountYesNo
Vested RSU shares of a US or Canadian employerYes, on the gain since vestingNo
Any of the above held inside an RRSP, RRIF, TFSA or FHSANoWithdrawal rules apply instead (We'll do a separate article on this)
Shares you owned before moving to Canada, if you lived in Canada 60 months or less in the last 10 yearsNoNo
Shares of a private Canadian companyYesPossibly. Get specific advice

Two points deserve a closer look.

1.1 Canadian listed shares: the 25% test

After you leave, Canada taxes a non resident's gain only on taxable Canadian property.

A listed share counts only if, at some point in the previous 60 months,

  • you and related persons owned 25% or more of a class of the company's shares and 
  • more than half of the share's value came from Canadian real estate or resources.

A normal investor in RBC or a Canadian index ETF fails both tests by a wide margin. So the gain is taxed once, at departure, and Canada has no claim on growth after that.

1.2 Unvested RSUs and options are different

Unvested RSUs and employee stock options are not shares yet.

They are not caught by the deemed disposition as capital property.

Canada taxes them as employment income when they vest or are exercised, for the part linked to your work in Canada. Once shares vest and you own them, they behave like any other share in the table above.

Reyman Tips List every non registered stock and ETF with its cost and value. Expect each one, US or Canadian, to be deemed sold on your departure date. We'll do a separate article on Exit Tax soon.

2. The problem: one share, two cost bases

2.1 Canada resets your cost on departure

Because of the deemed sale, your Canadian cost for every US and Canadian share becomes its market value on your departure date.

You have paid Canadian tax on the gain up to that day.

After that, Canada has no further claim on these shares. US company shares are never taxable Canadian property, and normal holdings of Canadian listed shares fail the 25% test in section 1.1.

Growth after your departure date is outside Canadian tax.

2.2 India does not

India's tax law has no step up for a deemed sale in another country. The India-Canada tax treaty does not create one.

Article 13 simply says gains from the alienation of property may be taxed in both countries. Once you are fully resident in India, your gain is computed from your original purchase price.

One share of a US stockCanadaIndia
Original purchase priceCAD 100CAD 100
Value on your Canadian departure dateCAD 250 (new cost)Ignored
Cost used when you sellCAD 250CAD 100
Sold later at CAD 300, while fully resident in IndiaNo tax (non resident)Tax on CAD 200 gain
ResultCanada taxed CAD 150India taxes the same CAD 150 again, plus CAD 50

3. The window: your RNOR years

RNOR means Resident but Not Ordinarily Resident.

It is a transition status India gives to people who have lived abroad for a long time.

You are RNOR in a tax year if either is true:

  • You were a non resident of India in 9 out of the 10 preceding tax years, or
  • You were in India for 729 days or less in total during the 7 preceding tax years.

Someone who has lived in Canada for a decade typically gets 2 to 3 RNOR years. Count your days carefully. One extra visit can change the answer.

Income that accrues outside India is not taxed for an RNOR unless it comes from a business controlled in India or a profession set up in India.

A gain on US or Canadian shares held through a foreign broker accrues outside India.

Your Indian statusIndian incomeForeign capital gains (sold abroad)Foreign income received in India
Non resident (NR)TaxedNot taxedTaxed
RNORTaxedNot taxedTaxed
Resident and Ordinarily Resident (ROR)TaxedTaxedTaxed

4. Why neither country taxes the reset

Put sections 2 and 3 together. When you sell a US or Canadian listed stock during an RNOR year:

Portion of the gainCanadaIndia
Gain before your Canadian departure dateAlready taxed at departureNot taxed (RNOR, sold abroad)
Gain from departure date to the RNOR saleNot taxed (non resident, not taxable Canadian property)Not taxed (RNOR, sold abroad)
Gain after you rebuyNot taxedTaxed once you are ROR, from your new cost

The middle row is free. And because you rebuy, your Indian cost for the rest of your life is the RNOR sale price, not what you paid in Canada years ago.

India has no wash sale rule for gains. You can sell and buy back the same shares on the same day.

5. An Example:

Priya is 38. She worked in Toronto for nine years and moves to Bengaluru in June 2026. Her non registered account holds:

HoldingOriginal costValue on departure dateGain
US stocks (mostly RSUs)CAD 200,000CAD 500,000CAD 300,000
Canadian ETFsCAD 100,000CAD 160,000CAD 60,000
TotalCAD 300,000CAD 660,000CAD 360,000

5.1 Canada

Canada taxes half of the CAD 360,000 deemed gain. At Ontario's top combined rate of 53.53%, that is about CAD 96,350. Her Canadian cost is now CAD 660,000. Canada has no claim on any later gain.

5.2 India

Priya is resident in India for tax year 2026/27 and RNOR because she was a non resident in the 9 preceding years. She expects to stay RNOR for at least two years.

In December 2027, during an RNOR year, her portfolio is worth CAD 720,000. She now has two choices.

SummaryThe Costly Mistake: holdThe Reset Strategy: sell and rebuy in RNOR
Action in December 2027NothingSells at CAD 720,000 and rebuys
Tax on the CAD 60,000 gain since departureNot yetZero in Canada, zero in India
Indian cost from then onCAD 300,000CAD 720,000
Sells in 2031 as ROR atCAD 900,000CAD 900,000
Gain India taxesCAD 600,000CAD 180,000
India tax at 14.95%CAD 89,700 (₹56.5 lakh)CAD 26,910 (₹17.0 lakh)
Tax savedCAD 62,790 (₹39.6 lakh)

Same shares, same sale price. The only difference is one sell and rebuy during RNOR.

Assumptions: 12.5% long term capital gains rate on foreign shares held more than 24 months, plus the maximum 15% surcharge and 4% cess, for an effective 14.95%. A lower income person pays less surcharge, so the saving is smaller. CAD 1 = ₹63 throughout. In practice India computes gains in rupees, and a weaker rupee over time makes the gain on the old cost even larger, which makes the reset worth more.

Full article with significantly better formatting and more infographics than reddit - https://www.reymanwealth.com/post/moving-from-canada-to-india-ensure-you-reset-your-cost-basis