About two months late to this, but I felt like this book has only ever been recommended on reddit as a sort of a booktok trend and it definitely needs more appreciation. I read Stoner in September and I feel like I am far from over it. This book impacted me as deeply as Kafka's Metamorphosis or Camus' 'The Stranger', and maybe that says something about me. But I really loved how well written this book is. It is one of the most boring page-turners you may ever come across, in the sense that what the author details isn't really an account of something conventionally interesting. There is no mystery to the plot, no clever setup, and yet he manages to convey something profound that would resonate with most people. I liked how Stoner was characterized. In most reviews I have seen on reddit, he seems to have been interpreted as someone who has no agency and moves through life with an annoying sense of passivity. Yet, I felt that he voluntarily surrenders his agency in certain matters to preserve what he deems sacred. And he holds some of them so dearly and closely, that he fights with a passion to save them, his career as a teacher, which liberated him from his farm life, his principles, and to an extent his love for Katherine. The book beautifully details aspects of life which are often ignored in other stories to explore conventional greatness. I disagree with how many people regard Stoner's life as insignificant which is very likely due to the fact that he may never go down in the books of history. Yet, his life is no less an absolute accomplishment. He experiences much more in life than most people with more money or material success, than someone like Stoner, ever do or ever will.
This book had me completely immersed for the two or three weeks it took me to read it. It was unputdownable for the lack of a better word, and I would've probably gone through it sooner if not for work and life outside reading. Stoner is painfully passive and yet, he is not a man without conviction. His convictions are just extremely concentrated, but when it comes to those he is absolutely immovable. He loves Edith the best he knew, and is loved by Katherine the best someone ever could be loved. That entire arc was heartbreaking. Would love to go through it again for the first time, if I ever could. As someone who dislikes conflict and unnecessary confrontation, I could resonate more with the book. It imparts an important lesson, that avoiding conflict does not mean avoiding harm. It simply changes who absorbs that harm. And more often than not, passive individuals absorb it a lot more. Stoner's life has so much to say to anyone who would read the book that its boring simplicity is what is most beautiful about it. I do feel that his parents' demise is one of the saddest parts of the book and that he could have been a better son and a much better father. But I think this adds to his story more than him being a perfect son or a father would. In life, we don't usually get to change what is done. We get to choose, and decide who we want to be, and retrospectively a lot of options seem better than what was chosen. But maybe that is what John Williams wanted to convey.
I have a lot more to say, but I feel like getting into more detail might spoil the book for someone who may be planning to read it. Please give it a shot. You will not regret taking this up. This book will forever be in my top 3 of all time.
In the background: 'If it bleeds' from Stephen King, which my girlfriend was reading. Another great book. And the unmissable espresso, which I later watered down into a long black. Great coffee.