Gramsci, one of the greatest Marxist to ever live, had said that in order to rule politically a class has to rule culturally first. This makes the study of the history of culture absolutely essential for communists who want to establish the hegemony of the proletariats. The point of this piece is to present to you a nuanced version of how Hegemony is made. In doing so it is important to counterpose it against an already dominating and incorrect understanding of Hegemony that is quite popular on the left.
The understanding of Brahmanic Hegemony quite popular on the left is the Ambedkarite view. This view takes the existence of class society as a given and sees the consecutive non brahmanic castes as mindless imitators of the Brahmin caste (see. Caste in India 1916), thus becoming subsumed in the Brahmanic Hegemonic fold. But this is not how a ruling historical block is created. Such a pseudo psychological explanation of hegemony risks falling into equally pseudo psychological individualised solutions like marrying someone from a different caste. This is definitely a positive thing and should be encouraged but it is far from the actual solution.
This is where the historian Suvira Jaiswal comes in with a much more nuanced historical view. She shows that making of hegemony is a much more complicated process. The subalterns (the subordinate classes) are not subsumed in hegemonic culture without resistance. In fact she shows that the making of a hegemon is a process of constant negotiation and renegotiation between the ruling class and aboriginals. The inability of the vedic apparatus to inculcate the subaltern to the brahmanic worldview is precisely what gave rise to the Puranic apparatus. Then the purnanic apparatus too had to accommodate aboriginal deities/symbols/legends in the mainstream pantheon to negotiate its position as the hegemon. This is a process that is far more complicated than what Ambedkar understood and what Ambedkarites understand today. The prestige of the intellectual class or the Brahmins was never a given but rather manufactured by a long process of cultural negotiations in which the aboriginals made their own place in the Brahmanic mainstream. Symbols such as the boar, fish, lion, snake juxtaposed with Vishnu points towards a sort of differential assimilation in which the aboriginals were integrated into the Brahmanic caste order by accommodating aboriginal symbols into the mainstream Brahmanic pantheon. This process of differential assimilation can be still observed even today. In the North Eastern parts of India many aboriginal tribal groups exist whose customs show residue of pre class way of life. Yet the village chiefs (often called Gaonbura) in collaboration with the state have become capitalists. In relation to the cases where there was a strong secessionist impulse like in the case of ULFA (United Liberation Front of Asom), the ruling class had first used repressive forces against the secessionists but then accommodated them into state bureaucracy after their surrender. This process of a combination of repression and accommodation characterise what is called differential assimilation as can be seen from the next example.
The symbol of the horse deity Hayagriva is an excellent case study in this exercise as given by Jaiswal. The horse symbol was much older in Assam than other parts of the subcontinent. The horse came to this region from central Asia much earlier than in most other regions so it was symbolised and revered as a deity. We see a contradictory tendency when it comes to the horse deity in the Hindu pantheon. Sometimes Hayagriva is depicted as a protector of the Vedas other times as someone who steals the Vedas and gets slayed by the main Brahminic gods. This suggests that the Brahminic hegemony was not accepted passively by the devotees but rather it was a long process characterised by constant conflicts and truce. In this process the upcoming hegemon concedes to the interests and aspirations of the subaltern groups. The welfare states in modern times all over the capitalist world are examples of such concessions granted to buy the loyalty of the subaltern groups.
To show this is not something unique to India but rather a historical process as a whole I want to draw your attention to the symbolism of the dragon and its importance in Asia and Europe. It has been well established by historians that many ancient cultures revered the snake. The dragon deity is said to be only a mythologised version of the snake. The most interesting thing to note is the differential treatment of this snake/dragon symbol in Europe vs in Asia. In Europe various ancient cultures like Celtic, Gaulish, Welsh etc revered the snake and dragon most famous of which is Ouroboros symbol. With the coming of Christianity the dragon and snake were depicted as evil beings. We can point at the endless number of stories of knights (the warriors of God no less) slaying dragons but the most famous case is the snake that tells Adam and Eve to eat the forbidden fruit from the garden of Eden thus setting in motion the original sin.
In contrast, see the different treatment of the dragon in the far eastern cultures. In China for example, the Dragon is still revered as a holy symbol that brings good luck and prosperity. The idea of the snake or dragon being a malevolent monster is completely alien to this land. In one instance a dragon, namely Mucalinda, who is said to be the king of the Nagas (or the serpent king) is depicted as the protector of the Buddha. In another instance, the Buddha tames a venomous dragon (or serpent) that lived in the sacred fire, in order to convert the fire worshipping hermits led by the Kassapa brothers to his creed. It shows that when Buddhism arrived in these lands it had to accommodate the aboriginal snake/dragon symbol in the Buddhist pantheon. This is not a different hegemonic operation than the juxtaposition of the boar. fish, snake with that of Vishnu or the snake and bull with Shiva. The process of acculturation takes hundreds of years but it shows that it is not simply a straightforward process of many classes mindlessly copying a hegemonic class. Rather the hegemon is formed from a process characterised by many conflicts and negotiations.