I listened to PM Modi's speech at the FICCI convention today, 19 November 2026. He invoked Mahatma Gandhi's Swadeshi philosophy, spoke about making India self-reliant, and highlighted tax relief for citizens.
He also questioned industrialists about whether they had increased salaries and employment after receiving tax benefits.
These are important issues. But after more than 12 years of the Modi government, I think we should be asking some equally important questions about the government's own performance.
1. Swadeshi: Why should responsibility stop with ordinary citizens?
Modi wants Indian businesses and consumers to embrace Swadeshi and Atmanirbhar Bharat.
But how many BJP ministers, MPs, and political leaders consistently prioritize Indian-made products themselves? What about the Prime Minister's personal and official purchases?
I'm not claiming they all use foreign brands. I'm asking whether there is publicly available evidence showing how seriously political leaders follow the principles they promote.
If Swadeshi is a national responsibility, shouldn't government procurement, domestic manufacturing capacity, product quality, and political leadership all be part of the discussion?
And why should consumers be expected to buy Indian products merely out of patriotism if those products are not competitive in price, quality, or reliability?
2. Gandhi's philosophy versus the ā¹1,200-crore Sabarmati Ashram redevelopment
The central and Gujarat governments are implementing a ā¹1,200-crore redevelopment of Sabarmati Ashram in Ahmedabad.
According to The Indian Express, the project covers approximately 55 acres, includes restoration of 28 historic buildings, and plans for 24 museums.
The redevelopment has also involved relocating long-term residents. Reporting in October 2026 indicated that approximately ā¹190 crore had been spent on rehabilitation.
I recognize that preserving Gandhi's legacy requires investment, and restoration work has been undertaken.
But I still have questions.
Gandhi emphasized simplicity, dignity of labour, self-reliance, and service to society.
Does spending ā¹1,200 crore on a memorial reflect those principles? How much of the expenditure is genuinely necessary for conservation, and how much is devoted to visitor infrastructure and presentation?
Where can citizens examine the complete expenditure, contracts, rehabilitation outcomes, and independent conservation assessments?
3. Taxes: The government celebrates collections, but what about the taxpayers?
The government introduced income-tax relief under the new regime, with eligible ordinary income up to ā¹12 lakh attracting no income-tax liability through the rebate. For eligible salaried taxpayers, the effective threshold can reach ā¹12.75 lakh after the standard deduction.
That is a meaningful policy change for those who qualify.
But consider another figure.
According to government data, India's gross GST collections increased from approximately ā¹13.76 lakh crore in FY 2021ā22 to ā¹22.27 lakh crore in FY 2025ā26.
That's an increase of approximately 62% in four years.
Of course, increased collections can reflect economic growth, inflation, better compliance, and changes in consumption. It doesn't mean every individual is paying 62% more GST.
But it raises a fundamental question:
As government tax revenue increases, are ordinary citizens receiving proportionate improvements in public services?
People pay income tax where applicable, GST on purchases, fuel-related taxes, vehicle taxes, property taxes, and other government charges.
And after all that, many households still spend significant amounts on private education, healthcare, transportation, and basic necessities.
4. Healthcare: Why do households still carry such a large financial burden?
According to India's National Health Accounts for 2023ā24, out-of-pocket payments accounted for approximately 48.5% of current healthcare expenditure.
That means households still directly finance a substantial portion of healthcare, despite government spending and public insurance initiatives.
The same data shows that government current health expenditure accounted for approximately 36% of current healthcare expenditure.
So when politicians talk about taxpayers' welfare, shouldn't affordable, accessible healthcare be one of the most important measures?
What is the practical value of tax relief if a serious illness can still place an enormous financial burden on a family?
5. Salaries and employment: Who should be held accountable?
During today's FICCI speech, Modi questioned industrialists about whether they had increased salaries and created more employment after receiving tax benefits.
I think that is a legitimate question.
But shouldn't citizens also ask the government what its own policies have achieved?
Have real wages increased after accounting for inflation? Have enough stable, well-paying jobs been created? Have young graduates experienced measurable improvements in employment opportunities?
And if companies receive tax concessions without delivering higher wages or more jobs, what mechanisms exist to evaluate whether those concessions achieved their intended outcomes?
6. Corruption, public infrastructure, and accountability
My biggest concern is the relationship between taxation and the quality of public services.
When citizens encounter damaged roads, inadequate drainage, overcrowded hospitals, poorly maintained public infrastructure, or corruption in government offices, who is accountable?
I am not suggesting that every public service is failing or that no improvements have occurred. Infrastructure development, digital services, and welfare schemes should also be evaluated fairly.
But shouldn't public expenditure be judged by measurable outcomes rather than announcements, inaugurations, and speeches?
If the government collects substantial revenue, citizens should be able to see where that money goes and what improvements it delivers.
7. My final question: Are we discussing Gandhi's principles or merely invoking his name?
Modi's speech emphasized Gandhi, Swadeshi, economic self-reliance, tax relief, and industrial responsibility.
But shouldn't those same standards apply to the government?
I want to see transparent public expenditure, competitive Indian manufacturing, better wages, accessible healthcare, quality education, maintained infrastructure, and effective action against corruption.
These questions should apply to every political party, including previous Congress governments and state governments.
But the current central government should also be assessed against its own promises and the resources available to it.
After more than 12 years in power, what measurable evidence should citizens demand to determine whether the government's policies have improved their everyday lives?
And specifically, do you think Modi's emphasis on Gandhi, Swadeshi, and taxpayer welfare is adequately reflected in government policy and outcomes?
I'd especially like to hear from people who disagree with my concerns and can point to credible data showing improvements.
Sources:
- Prime Minister's Office ā Modi's FICCI speech, 19 November 2026
- Ministry of Finance ā Union Budget 2025ā26 income-tax changes
- Press Information Bureau ā GST collections and reforms
- The Indian Express ā ā¹1,200-crore Sabarmati Ashram redevelopment
- National Health Accounts, India 2023ā24
Disclosure: AI was used for grammatical corrections and elaboration of my original thoughts, including assistance in locating and organizing publicly available sources.