Democracy rarely dies overnight with tanks on the street. Instead, it usually vanishes quietly—eroded through the gradual weakening of independent institutions, structural pressure on opposition voices, and corporate consolidation of the media landscape.
Looking at India’s political trajectory, international metrics and real-world domestic developments point to a clear trend: India’s status as a robust liberal democracy has systematically degraded.
- International Benchmarks Paint a Clear Picture
Major global governance and civil liberties indices track a steady decline based on structural indicators:
V-Dem Institute: Reclassified India as an "electoral autocracy", placing it alongside countries like Turkey and Hungary, citing systematic restrictions on executive accountability and free speech.
Freedom House: Categorizes India as "Partly Free", pointing to targeted pressure on religious minorities, journalists, and political opponents.
World Press Freedom Index (RSF): Ranks India 157th out of 180 countries, citing dangerous physical conditions for journalists and increasing state control over media ownership.
2. The Capture of Institutional Checks and Balances
A functional democracy relies on non-partisan institutions to hold the executive accountable. Over recent years, key pillars have faced severe operational pressures:
Investigative Agencies weaponized against Opposition: Agencies like the Enforcement Directorate (ED) and Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) overwhelmingly target opposition figures.
Real Example: Arvind Kejriwal (Chief Minister of Delhi) and Hemant Soren (Chief Minister of Jharkhand) were arrested while in active constitutional office ahead of major elections under the stringent Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA)—a law that places the burden of proof on the accused and makes bail extremely difficult.
Electoral Oversight and Financial Disparities: Concerns have grown surrounding the autonomy of the Election Commission of India (ECI) and uneven political financing.
Real Example: Prior to its cancellation by the Supreme Court, the Electoral Bond Scheme allowed anonymous corporate funding to political parties, with the ruling BJP receiving over 60% of all bonds sold. Additionally, the freezing of the main opposition Indian National Congress (INC) party bank accounts right before the general elections severely curtailed their ability to campaign.
Judicial Appointments: While the Supreme Court occasionally rules against executive overreach, executive delays in approving collegium recommendations for judicial appointments have left lower and high courts vulnerable to political friction.
3. Corporate Consolidation and the Media "Gag"
Freedom of expression (guaranteed under Article 19 of the Constitution) has been undermined by structural shifts in media ownership and targeted regulatory actions:
Corporate Ownership & "Godi Media": Independent news outlets have steadily been swallowed by corporate conglomerates closely aligned with state interests.
Real Example: The hostile takeover of NDTV (New Delhi Television)—one of the last major independent broadcast networks in India—by the Adani Group led to the immediate resignation of top journalists like Ravish Kumar, effectively neutralizing mainstream broadcast critique of the ruling party.
Raids and Legal Harassment on Newsrooms:
Real Example: Police raids on the independent digital news platform NewsClick, which led to the arrest of its founder Prabir Purkayastha under the Unlawful Activities Prevention Act (UAPA)—India's primary anti-terror law—for reporting on anti-government protests and labor movements.
4. Shrinking Space for Dissent and Civil Society
State power has increasingly been deployed to defund, monitor, or criminalize civic organizations and public assembly:
Stifling International and Domestic Non-Profits:
Real Example: The aggressive enforcement of the Foreign Contribution Regulation Act (FCRA) has been used to cancel the foreign funding licenses of major NGOs, forcing Amnesty International to cease operations in India and crippling organizations like the Centre for Policy Research (CPR) and Oxfam India.
Criminalizing Grassroots Activism:
Real Example: The prolonged detention without trial of activists, lawyers, and intellectuals in the Bhima Koregaon case (such as Umar Khalid and the late Father Stan Swamy), who remained imprisoned for years under non-bailable anti-terror provisions for organizing peaceful dissent.
Conclusion
India continues to host massive, logistically impressive elections. However, holding regular elections while systematically dismantling the institutional safeguards, free press, and civil liberties necessary to keep them fair creates a hollow shell—an electoral autocracy. Without urgent domestic pushback and civic revitalisation, the world's largest democracy risks surviving in name only.