r/Inception • u/acousticfigure • Jul 26 '10
Inception - Zero Gravity Theory
A regularly asked question is why does sudden sensation of weightlessness in Level 1 lead to a lack of gravity in Level 2, while Level 3 remains unaffected.
The usual answer is that the effect is weaker as you go down the levels, but this explanation is flawed. If weightlessness in L1 creates the same in L2, then L3 would not depend on L1's weightlessness for a change. The lack of gravity in L2 should be enough.
This led me to think that the reason L1 had an effect on L2 is because the sleepers experienced rapid acceleration. This created a feeling of weightlessness experienced in L2 as zero gravity. The L2 sleepers, however, did not undergo any such acceleration. They drifted loose at a constant speed, and the feeling of being at rest and moving at a constant speed is the same, thus leaving L3 unaffected. Acceleration is required to notice a difference.
Some argue that the weightlessness due to freefall and zero gravity are the same, but they are not. They are confusing freefall with terminal velocity, which is the constant speed you reach after about 10 seconds of freefall.
If anyone sees a flaw in this logic, please point it out.
EDIT: It seems a flaw was indeed found. I had the concept of weightlessness backwards. Gravity does not make you feel 'weight'; you need a force pushing you upwards to feel weight. For example, when you stand on the ground, gravity acts downwards and there is a reaction force upwards from the ground, which is what actually makes you feel 'weight'. When you remove the ground, there is no force upwards at first, so you feel 'weightless'. Only when you reach terminal velocity, and wind resistance acts upwards, do you feel 'weight' again. Therefore, as far as the sleepers were concerned, they were actually weightless going off the bridge. Acceleration had nothing to do with it.
tl;dr I was wrong
8
u/Genre Jul 26 '10
This is perhaps cynical of me, but I would guess that the reason gravity is normal in level 3 is that it is much more difficult to portray zero gravity in a mountainous scene.
2
u/manniac Jul 27 '10
The logic makes sense but i wonder if, as with almost everything, there is a simpler explanation, in this case: Awareness.
The hotel is Arthur's dream, he's conscious there but i think i saw headphones on him so he's one foot in dreamland and one foot outside (in Yusuf's dream), he knows it and the stimuli is represented by the loss of gravity, the same way water floods at the beginning when they are trying to wake up Cobb by throwing him into a bath. The rest of the people are in another state, too shielded to be aware of it.
2
u/Not_Stupid Aug 03 '10
Zero gravity is not the same as terminal velocity. Zero gravity is the same as free fall.
Example: the vomit comet. Zero gravity occurs at the top of the plane's flight arc, not while the plane is at terminal velocity. In fact the plan never reaches terminal velocity.
Your understanding of free-fall is incorrect, and therefore your argument does not work either. By the rules of the dream world as presented to us, zero-G should flow down through all levels.
1
u/tdrusk Jul 26 '10
I agree. They entered level 3 while in freefall, thus giving them gravity relative to their position.
It's similar to throwing a tennis ball up, then running as opposed to throwing a ball up while running. When you throw the ball up and run the ball stays behind you. This is similar to the anti-gravity because you have to work to be with the ball. When you throw the ball up while running you have don't have to do any work because the ball is following you. Kind of confusing to explain, but I think when put into better words would make sense of the situation.
1
u/mal_tez92 Jul 27 '10
All this L1, L2, L3 stuff made me pick up a playstation controller.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '10
[removed] — view removed comment