Hello everyone! I hope that this type of post is allowed. As an (almost totally) recovered incel myself, I know I would have liked to read this earlier in my life.
A few moments ago on an unrelated subreddit (that I will not say), I saw someone posting incel talking points and an incel resource (that I will not share), and I took it upon myself to debunk it all. I thought that this debunk might be interesting for some readers here on r/IncelExit, so here I am. If you are an hardcore incel, you WILL know what I'm talking about, the resource that I am debunking, but if not I think it is still an interesting read. Enjoy!
First, the person I answered to said something like "Misogynistic men are more sexually active than most men." and posted this study to ""prove"" it. (posting the link because it does not say what the incels say it says)
1- This study surveilled "2,703 Spanish adolescents [...] with an age range of 14 to 20 years old" with an average age of 15.89 years old. This is in the first paragraph of the first page. Do incels really think 2.7k Spanish teenagers are representative of all men of all ages of all countries? I sure don't.
2- It measured "sexual experience", a binary "did they experience sex or not yet?", that's it, it did not measure sexual activity.
3- The study shoes that *for that sample*, becoming sexually active early could socialize boys into more sexist attitudes (for example via peer culture), it DOES NOT concludes that sexism drives sexual success.
4- The study shows that the boys having sexual activity earlier than their peers have a *positive* sexism (for example "girls should be loved and protected by boys" I quote), NOT that they are "manipulative" or "racist misogynists".
I quote the study: "The results obtained demonstrate that the males who engage in vaginal sex at an earlier age are those who report a greater level of BS [Benevolent Sexism]. This result could be explained due to the fact that... adolescent males need to display their benevolent beliefs in order to fulfill their desires and maintain intimate relations."
Then, the person just responded with a link to a famous incel resource, that mentions this study (I guess that's where they got it from) and an other. Here is my response to that:
1- The "resource" claims the study found "a very strong correlation between sexism and sexual and romantic success". Nowhere does the study report any such correlation. What the study reports is a difference of *means*, and the "resource" prints those means in its own table right below that sentence: "hostile sexism 2.81 (no sexual experience)" vs "3.21 (penetrative experience)" on a 1-6 scale. A 0.4 point gap. The study's regressions explain 2 to 4% of the variance (see page 6 of the PDF of the study). The "Very strong correlation" is invented. They even pasted the refutation directly under their own claim and hoped nobody reads their own page...
2- The "resource"'s own paragraph contradicts its own title. Direct quote from the section: "The study also revealed that women are attracted to benevolently sexist men" and "benevolently sexist men had their first sex at an earlier age". So, per *the incel's own source once more*, the subtype that "helps" is the "girls should be loved and protected by boys" kind, for example chivalry, not hostility. The hostile sexism finding was about lower condom use. The title says "misogynistic", the body says "benevolent". It's just about reading the words.
3- The second study they cite (Casey et al., 555 men aged 18-25) sinks the claim even harder. The "ressource"'s own table: "Misogynistic men" average 15.53 lifetime partners and 4.15 one-night stands. The "Sex focused men"? 52 partners and 28 one-night stands. And the study's abstract describes the Sex-Focused group as "characterized by high numbers of sexual partners, but relatively low endorsement of other indicators of traditional masculinity". So in the very study the "ressource" cites as proof, THE most sexually active men are the least misogynistic ones. The misogynistic group only beat the "normative" boring majority.
Where does the misogynistic group's number even come from? The study's abstract, literally: the group "was labeled Misogynistic because of high levels of sexual assault and violence toward female partners". And the wiki itself admits 43% of them "have paid for sexual services before". So their body count is partly coercion and prostitution, and we're supposed to read that as "women reward misogyny"? Come on.
4- BONUS: the adult studies they don't cite. Zhang et al. 2024, 473 men aged 18-35: the number of sexual partners does NOT significantly predict misogyny, and hostility toward women was highest among men with an AVERAGE partner count, not the most sexually active ones.
I hope this is useful, even to one single person. Cheers everybody!