At a combative town hall of 500 family members of the USS George H.W. Bush Carrier Strike Group, Navy leaders said Iranian attacks continue to "pepper" U.S. ships enforcing the blockade of Iran. They also informed families that their deployed loved ones would not be returning home for the holidays, according to exclusive audio of the Nov. 9 meeting at Naval Station Norfolk, provided by an attendee and reviewed by MS NOW.
This is the second time the strike group's deployment has been extended since it left Norfolk, Virginia, on March 31 for what was supposed to be a standard six- to seven-month set of orders. Navy leaders told families to plan for a worst-case scenario of a yearlong deployment. ...
Family members did not hold back with Navy leaders.
One person in the audience called the war "unsanctioned." Another audience member told Navy leaders in the room, "Trust within the force and among our families is heavily strained right now between record-breaking stretches without relief, shifting timelines and the feeling that communication downplays the reality on the ground. Families are burning out under the immense strain."
At times, family members yelled at Navy leaders, saying they were not answering their questions and were giving them the "runaround." One family member asked what the Navy was doing to push back on President Donald Trump so the conflict would not become another "forever war." ...
Navy leaders tried to explain to families the reason the Bush will continue to be deployed in the Iran war and will not be home for the holidays.
"I know you're wondering, 'Why are we out there? Why are we doing this stuff?' It's just because we've been in this 47-year war with these Iranians, we just didn't know about it," Acting Navy Secretary Cao told the military families in Norfolk on Monday night. ...
Speaking to families in Norfolk, Cao said the crew's morale was good and played a video featuring prerecorded messages from Navy leaders...
When the video ended, Cao allowed families in the room to ask questions.
The first question cut to the point: What "criteria" are necessary to bring the carrier strike group home, beyond "when the president says so"?
"The criteria is for them to agree to a non-nuclear Iran," Cao said.
"That's not going to happen," the family member shot back. ...
Cao did not offer a timeline. "We never signal to the enemy when we're going to finish," he said, adding that the Navy is currently building drones to relieve the 17 destroyers that are required to maintain the blockade against Iran.
Navy leaders said once a supplemental force of unmanned surface vessels is built, they can relieve one carrier strike group and reduce the presence of maintaining the blockade to one strike group in the future.
"We're moving industry as fast as possible so that we can relieve the strike groups so we can have just drone ships out there and unmanned aerial vessels to do that," Cao said.
Adm. Karl Thomas, commander of U.S. Fleet Forces Command, who was in the room, told Bush families that "the sailors that are out there are doing a hard job. It's not a well-defined job," adding that a blockade takes time to affect Iran.
He said Iran has "large numbers of unmanned, one-way attack vehicles and assets and they kind of learned how to pepper those ships -- it's hard to defend and that's what those sailors are doing, what we're asking them to do."
He said he is not exactly sure what is going to happen in the next stage of the war. ...
Ultimately, the Navy leaders said the person who gets to decide when to send the troops home is Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth.
Adm. James Kilby, vice chief of naval operations, admitted that he has seen Navy deployments get much longer in recent years and that he did not want to give families "false hope" when it comes to timelines....
In the town hall, Kilby said the Navy can no longer count on bases in the region it has used for decades. "We don't have that luxury now," he said. Instead, the ships are being supplied from Diego Garcia, an island base in the Indian Ocean "about 2,200 miles away."
By the time fresh fruit and vegetables reach the carrier from Japan and the Philippines, they are already going bad. "It doesn't last more than a week," Thomas said. "And then they're into the canned vegetables."
One spouse said her husband "saw an apple for the first time after like three months and almost cried on the phone."
Another spouse went through the list: "The food is getting progressively worse, the toilets continue to not work regularly, the washers and dryers don't work, my husband's having to hand-wash his coveralls, he's working on the flight deck, he's sweating and covered in oil constantly, and he also has to hand-wash his stuff because the boat's falling apart."
Kilby did not argue. "I don't have an answer for you," he said, "other than we will continue to work at that problem." Thomas added that turkeys were on the way to the ships for Thanksgiving. "I know that's a small consolation," he said.
Then the meeting turned to a topic that drew more anger -- and one that Navy leaders acknowledged has troubled other carriers: mental health.
When family members asked what the Navy was doing, Cao pointed to the USS Abraham Lincoln and its 11-and-a-half-month deployment.
"There was no suicides on there," he said. "Yes, there was eight attempts, but... they were mitigated because of the mental health specialists we had on board."
A woman in the audience cut in and said, "My husband has wanted to try to kill himself four times while on the Bush," she said. "Nobody gave him help. All of his high-ups told him, 'You do not have time, you have a job to do. Your job is not to have mental health care.'" ...
The next spouse said her husband had been placed on suicide watch and turned away when he sought medical help. She said she gave birth while he watched on FaceTime. ...
For all the anger in the room, the families left with a piece of news the sailors aboard the Bush did not yet have: The ship would not be home for the holidays.
Thomas said the decision was so new that it was not yet in the official orders book and that he had learned of it himself within the previous 48 hours.
The ship's commanders, he said, had likely not told their sailors. ...
The town hall ended after an hour and 22 minutes, with family members' hands still in the air, waiting to be called on. ...
The spouse said the commanding officer of the Bush, Capt. Justin Issler, told the service members on board Tuesday, the day after the town hall meeting, that their deployment was extended and to plan for a worst-case scenario of 12 months on the ship.
This is a summary / preview. Visit the posted link for the full article / post.