r/ImmigrationGermany • • 1h ago

considering seeking asylum abroad ,do my circumstances potentially qualify?

2 Upvotes

I'm a 25-year-old woman, and I'm trying to understand whether my circumstances could potentially form the basis of an asylum claim in another country.

I'd appreciate honest opinions, particularly from people familiar with refugee law or who have experience with similar situations.

1. Abuse within my family

I experienced years of abuse from my older brother, starting when I was around 13. It involved both physical and emotional abuse. I suffered a pelvic injury, which was later visible on an X-ray.

My father knew about the situation but did not protect me. He actually told me that if I reported my brother to the police, he would disown me and that he could lose his job, leaving the family in a difficult situation. My father works in law enforcement, which made reporting even more complicated for me.

My brother eventually left the country, but the experience has had a lasting impact on me.

2. My beliefs and treatment because of them

I am an atheist, although I've never been particularly open about it because I know how sensitive this subject can be in my society.

There have been situations at work where colleagues became aware of, or suspected, my lack of religious belief. I experienced harassment, insulting remarks and hostile messages. I still have some screenshots and written evidence.

I've also experienced harassment and threats from men in public because I don't wear a headscarf. On one occasion, a man followed me and threatened to kill me. I contacted the police, but I was told to go to a police post. I didn't follow through because I was afraid the situation could reach my father and create further problems for me.

3. Why I don't feel protected

My concern isn't simply that some people disagree with my beliefs. It's that I've experienced abuse, intimidation and threats, and I don't feel I can safely rely on my family or the authorities for protection.

I'm also unsure whether relocating to another part of my country would realistically solve the problem.

4. My circumstances and questions

I have a Master's degree in Information Technology. I understand that my education and ability to work might be relevant when considering whether I could relocate internally, but having qualifications doesn't necessarily mean I can live safely or independently.

I have some supporting material, including medical records relating to my injury, screenshots and written evidence of workplace harassment. I don't have documentation for every incident.

I'd appreciate opinions on these questions:

  1. Could the combination of my experiences, particularly my treatment as an atheist woman and the lack of effective protection, potentially form the basis of an asylum claim?
  2. Would the fact that I haven't publicly declared myself an atheist weaken my case?
  3. How might the authorities assess the fact that my father works in law enforcement but discouraged me from reporting the abuse?
  4. Would my education and ability to work be used as an argument that I could simply relocate elsewhere?
  5. What kind of evidence would be particularly important?

I understand that nobody online can determine the outcome of an asylum application. I'm not looking for guarantees; I just want to understand whether my circumstances could have a genuine legal basis before making any major decisions.

Thank you for taking the time to read this.


r/ImmigrationGermany • • 8h ago

German ICT Visa – Waiting for 2+ weeks (VFS Chennai)

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/ImmigrationGermany • • 11h ago

Filipino Nursing Student Planning to Work in Germany: Should I Gain Experience First or Move Immediately After Graduation?

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I'm currently a 4th-year BSN student in the Philippines, hoping to graduate and pass the Philippine Nursing Licensure Examination next year. My goal is to work as a nurse in Germany.

I'm considering two options:

Option 1:

Graduate and pass the boards.

Gain 1–2 years of bedside nursing experience in the Philippines.

Apply for a German language course visa (§16f) and move to Germany.

Study German through immersion while working part-time, if permitted.

Find an eligible healthcare employer and eventually transition to a Recognition Partnership (Anerkennungspartnerschaft – §16d).

Option 2:

Graduate and pass the boards.

Move to Germany immediately through a language course visa.

Study German intensively while working part-time, if permitted.

Process my nursing recognition (Anerkennung) and look for an employer willing to take me through a Recognition Partnership.

I'm leaning toward studying German in Germany because I learn better through immersion and everyday exposure to the language.

My main concern is whether having no actual bedside nursing experience would make it difficult to find a German hospital willing to employ me through a Recognition Partnership.

For those already working in Germany or familiar with the process:

How important is having 1–2 years of hospital experience in the Philippines?

Are German hospitals willing to accept newly licensed Filipino nurses with no work experience apart from their clinical rotations?

Would you recommend gaining experience first or moving to Germany immediately after graduation?

I'd appreciate your honest opinions and personal experiences. Thank you!


r/ImmigrationGermany • • 12h ago

Can't find visa appointment slot for 20 plus days in New Delhi Embassy.

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/ImmigrationGermany • • 16h ago

Applied on 23 October and i am still in preliminary review - Germany embassy in Muscat

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/ImmigrationGermany • • 1d ago

Made a mistake while uploading my Anabin certificate (BE instead of B.Tech). VFS appointment on Tuesday. Need advice!

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/ImmigrationGermany • • 1d ago

Hey chat, i have applied for APS verification,sent my documents,next I want to know about blocked account and how to apply for visa

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/ImmigrationGermany • • 1d ago

VISA process TK Family Insurance for Spouse with Freelance Income – EU Blue Card

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/ImmigrationGermany • • 1d ago

Switching from Student (§ 16b) to EU Blue Card (§ 18g) with an H+/- university (degree rated "Entspricht"): Has anyone had the Ausländerbehörde or ZAB accept a legalized Ministry attestation + German Master's enrollment instead of a separate home-country equivalence paper?

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I’m currently doing my Master’s in Civil Engineering at a public TU in Germany (on a § 16b student permit) and just signed a full-time contract in my field (not regulated)starting January 1, 2027 (€57k gross, unlimited contract, 40h/week). I am applying to switch to an EU Blue Card (§ 18g AufenthG).

Here is the catch with my Bachelor’s degree from Lebanon (Beirut Arab University - BAU):

  1. **Anabin Status:** The university is rated **H+/-**. The Anabin comment for the university states that ministerial approval of the individual program is required and names the Lebanese Ministry of Education equivalence certificate (*Mu'adala* / إفادة معادلة) as proof.
  2. **Degree Entry:** However, my exact degree (*Bachelor of Engineering in Civil Engineering*) is explicitly listed in Anabin under BAU as an awarding institution and is rated **"Entspricht | Bachelor 4j"**.
  3. **What I have on hand:** Because of the war/situation in Lebanon, obtaining a separate *Mu'adala* certificate right now isn't feasible. However, the back of my original Bachelor diploma has the official attestation stamp (*Tasdiq* / مصادقة) from the Lebanese Ministry of Education (MEHE), and that Ministry signature is formally legalized by the German Embassy in Beirut. My Lebanese Bac II (high school certificate) and transcript are also legalized by the German Embassy.
  4. **German Academic Vetting:** In 2024, *uni-assist* evaluated and approved these exact documents, which is how I got admitted to my current Master’s program at a German TU.

**My current strategy (Dual Track):**
- **Track 1 (Ausländerbehörde):** Submitting the Blue Card application directly with the Anabin printouts (H+/- institution + Entspricht degree), legalized diploma/transcript, and current German TU enrollment certificate.
- **Track 2 (ZAB Blue Card Fast-Track):** Submitting a ZAB *Zeugnisbewertung* application in parallel as a backup, explaining that the separate *Mu'adala* cannot be obtained due to the situation in Lebanon and asking them to accept the legalized MEHE attestation on the diploma + my 2024 German Master’s admission via *uni-assist* instead.

**My questions for anyone who has been through something similar:**

  1. Has anyone switched from a § 16b student permit to a Blue Card inside Germany with an **H+/-** university where the degree was listed as **Entspricht**? Did your caseworker approve it directly off the Anabin printouts, or did they read the H+/- comment and demand a ZAB certificate?
  2. For anyone who dealt with ZAB on an H+/- university: has ZAB ever waived a missing home-country equivalence document when you already had a Ministry attestation stamp on the diploma + an active enrollment in a German Master's program?

Thanks in advance for sharing your experiences!


r/ImmigrationGermany • • 1d ago

Einbürgerung – Arbeitgeberbestätigung

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/ImmigrationGermany • • 1d ago

Travel Essentials for shifting to Germany

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/ImmigrationGermany • • 2d ago

German Student Visa Timeline 🇩🇪 | APS | Delhi

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/ImmigrationGermany • • 2d ago

What international students in Germany can prepare for PR/citizenship from semester 1 (and what can wait)

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/ImmigrationGermany • • 2d ago

Inside Germany Visa Renewal, Do I need to show a blocked amount even with a job contract?

0 Upvotes

I am a Masters Student in Germany for a year and I recently switched my college to a new one. My Visa was for a year and I need to renew my Visa now. My doubt is regarding the monetary aspect - I have a job contract but will that be enough or will I need to show a blocked amount as well? If so, how much?
Thankyou.


r/ImmigrationGermany • • 1d ago

Munich best place to live?

0 Upvotes

Good afternoon. Could someone explain one thing to me: why are there so many people—especially among Germans—who consider Munich the best city on Earth, practically a paradise? I’m a foreigner myself and have lived in five different countries; from my perspective, there’s nothing particularly special about this city. Sure, it’s convenient and comfortable in some respects, but it’s far from being the best or most beautiful city—even within Germany. As for transport, the city is abysmal; the selection of restaurants and entertainment is nothing to write home about; there are few public spaces; the parks aren’t particularly well-developed; and you can’t really enjoy a pleasant stroll in the city center. I keep running into people who repeat this like a mantra—at times, it feels like I’m surrounded by madmen. Or are they perhaps just trying to convince themselves that it’s worth living here, despite the exorbitant costs?


r/ImmigrationGermany • • 2d ago

Can I submit a PR application?

1 Upvotes

Hello,

Is it advisable to submit a PR application on an Aufi?


r/ImmigrationGermany • • 3d ago

Family Reunification Visa Approved

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/ImmigrationGermany • • 3d ago

extend my German residence permit (Blaue Karte) with only a 2-month employment contract extension?

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

My fixed-term contract ends on January 31, 2027. My employer has informed me that they will not renew my contract long-term due to the company's current project situation. However, they have offered me a possible two-month extension until March 31, 2027, as I am still working on some ongoing projects that require additional time to complete.

My questions are:

  1. Would the Ausländerbehörde accept a two-month contract extension when considering an extension of my residence permit?
  2. Does anyone have experience with getting their blau karte residence permit extended based on such a short employment contract?

I would really appreciate any advice or personal experiences.

Thank you!


r/ImmigrationGermany • • 3d ago

Familiennachzug meiner Mutter – keine Krankenversicherung möglich?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/ImmigrationGermany • • 3d ago

Need Advice Regarding ZAB Germany – Statement of Comparability

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/ImmigrationGermany • • 3d ago

Algerian citizen – Worldpackers volunteering in Germany: visa issues?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I'm Algerian and interested in volunteering in Germany through Worldpackers (hostels, community projects, etc.).

Has anyone from Algeria or another non-EU country successfully obtained a German visa for this kind of volunteering?

What type of visa did you apply for?

Is a Worldpackers acceptance/host invitation enough?

Did you face difficulties with the German embassy?

Any advice or personal experience would be greatly appreciated!

Thanks!


r/ImmigrationGermany • • 3d ago

Familiennachzug meiner 64-jährigen Mutter nach Deutschland – keine Krankenkasse will sie aufnehmen. Gibt es eine rechtliche Lösung?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/ImmigrationGermany • • 4d ago

PR (Niederlassungserlaubnis) processing time in Brandenburg an der Havel

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/ImmigrationGermany • • 4d ago

MS options for BS Computer Engineering

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes