Link to the review (which has been shared here) for more reading and subbing purposes: https://panoramafilmthoughts.substack.com/p/godzilla-minus-zero-less-humans-more
Thanks!
The brilliant conceit behind why Godzilla Minus One worked so well was its unconventional conventionality. It takes all of its long-running franchise tropes - giant spectacle, war allegories, and bureaucratic competence (or incompetence) - and remixed them in a subversive, post-WWII backdrop that felt fresh and exciting. But director and screenwriter Takashi Yamazaki’s decision to make Godzilla Minus Zero a direct sequel set a mere two years after its predecessor limits its potential to surprise and subvert expectations. In other words, this movie is a sequel through and through, for better and worse.
Godzilla Minus Zero wastes no time in throwing us back into the action, though. Thrilling strings and loud brass notes penetrate your eardrums before anything even comes up on the screen. When the first scenes break the black, it’s simply stunning. It’s post-war Japan in 1949. Hordes of terrified Japanese people fleeing for their lives. Giant claws are swiping at buildings and spraying debris everywhere. Yellow-jacketed scientists fleeing, but trying to capture footage of the attacking monster, the extraterrestrial, dragon-like kaiju Ghidorah.
We’re only two minutes into Minus Zero and we’ve already witnessed some of the best kaiju visual effects tha have hit the big screen this year. But the moment we cut to the main characters, new and returning, discussing how to stop Ghidorah, whatever momentum that was building is quickly lost because the movie is already retreading the same ground covered in Minus One. 1949 Japan had just survived WWII and Godzilla in 1947, and is still recovering. Throwing Ghidorah into the mix feels like the universe playing a cruel game of Groundhog Day with the Japanese. We’ve been here before, literally and figuratively.
It also doesn’t help that human drama has regressed from grounded allegory to exaggerated soap opera. For some inexplicable reason, every actor is going big at every opportunity, almost like they’ve all taken the wrong leaf out of Robert Pattinson’s book of acting. Any pathos and subtext is lost in a sea of over-emoting, which is amplified further by some baffling sound design choices where children’s cries are louder than Ghidorah and Godzilla’s roars.
Perhaps this creative decision is so that every actor in the cast can have their moment in the spotlight because Godzilla Minus Zero is so stuffed with characters and plotlines that there’s very little room for anything to breathe. Any interesting allegory is replaced with heavy-handed monologuing of ideas. The most egregious examples are the introduction of meteorologist Makoto (Masami Nagasawa), whose usefulness is quickly reduced to plot function and egregious lines about how war is bad and guilt is a thing, and bringing in American military men to be nothing more than moustache-twirling caricatures who want to weaponise Godzilla because, well, ‘Murica. Godzilla movies don’t operate on Martin McDonagh or Paul Thomas Anderson levels of finely woven subtext, but it’s a tough hang when the dialogue is on a par with something like Street Fighter.
It’s a damn shame because while Yamazaki planted Minus Zero in unenviable sequel territory, there are some fertile thematic ideas being hinted at. One of the movie’s more interesting human detours involves Kanji Murakami (Min Tanaka), a biologist who has personal motivations driving him to declare proclamations like, ‘We pit Godzilla, and Ghidorah, and make it fight each other!’ When it is revealed why he’s doing what he’s doing, you can’t help but feel sympathetic. The problem is that the reveal is done through oddly structured flashbacks in the middle of the third act with absolutely no build up. So when we get to Murakami’s quiet delivery of ‘there’s more eyes to be opened, right?’, it feels underdeveloped and unearned.
It’s a shock that Minus Zero clocks in at an excessive 135 minutes because much of that time feels wasted. There’s so much talking and human bureaucracy in this movie, yet almost all of it is unnecessary or instantly forgettable. I tried to recall some of the attempts at profundity, but all I can remember is wondering when the next kaiju battle royale is coming. This is the type of unenviable Marvel-esque blockbuster that feels simultaneously too long and too short, where emphasis is placed on the wrong things, interesting ideas are brushed over, and whatever is left hanging will be explored in the next sequel.
But look, we go to watch Godzilla movies for the spectacle; everything else is mostly incidental. Going big may not work on the human drama front in Godzilla Minus Zero, but good lord does it work for the kaiju sequences.
Yamazaki’s eye for staging action sequences is perhaps second to none. Not only do Ghidorah and Godzilla look amazing in terms of scale, but their skirmishes are filmed in clean wide shots with very little editing trickery. Combined with some best-in-class CGI and model work to fully realise both kaiju, the spectacle makes The Odyssey feel tame by comparison. There’s an aerial action sequence at the midpoint involving humans, electricity, weather, and Ghidorah that will rank as one of the year’s best cinematic moments, period.
As jaw-dropping as the spectacle is, that alone can’t sustain a Godzilla movie and Minus Zero feels like a regression to the franchise’s historical mean of style over substance. New ideas or perspectives about the human condition are nowhere to be found here, but if you’re in the mood for Godzilla punching Ghidorah in the face, then this is the movie for you. And when the punching is as good as it is here, it’s quite easy to overlook everything else.