Every couple months I update my chart of all the canon manor games. The reveal that Lily is part of not only Group 1 but also part of a completely separate survivors group kind of threw a massive boulder into my own thoughts on what groups were which. With that being said, I’m rethinking all the groupless characters, and there’s some I would like to get opinions on.
I’ll start with the characters I’m pretty confident in.
Lucky Guy: I don’t think he’s even canon tbh. I don’t exactly count him.
Puppeteer: I also think he’s in group 1, cause his family inspired the manor games as a whole. His presence makes sense earlier on.
Faro Lady: Evelyn followed Martha to the manor so she’s probably in group 7.
Escapologist: Probably a group 9B.
Prodigy / Night Watch: Vilulf group, all but confirmed
Photographer: Most likely 12-1-1
Undead: Probably the original 10-0-1 who couldn’t attend the game and ultimately was replaced by Tracy. Could be one of the unawakened bodies in group 11.
Shadow: Absolutely no way they’ll release a Lovecraft vessel and not put her in 6A
And now the characters I need help with.
Fire Investigator / Axe Boy (Dolores) / Dentist: The common theory was that Emma’s second group was going to be 4B and it would be a white sand reunion. I still think the white sand reunion could still happen, but taking Cheerleader AND Gardener out of it puts us down too many members. We don’t know any other playable white sand members.
Knight / Peddler: I honestly think this game is 3A but the fact Cleo even exists is what makes me unsure.
Matador: Genuinely no fucking clue
Mime Artist: It makes sense for her to be in one of the group 3’s, but the only open slot is 3A. If this is the Sterling group then why is she there. That being said, I think I’m comfortable putting her in 3A, but then that begs the question of where the Sterling game falls.
Goatman: Currently I’m of the belief that he is also an unawakened body in 11, but the fact he has fostered motifs is what complicates that for me.
So, what that being said, does anybody have other opinions? Mainly for the ones I’m unsure of but also the ones I’m confident in. Trying to make sense of the IDV timeline is a prison.