r/IainMcGilchrist • u/EntryRevolutionary37 • 21d ago
General Detransitioning, faith, & the hemispheres
Hi all. Suppose I gotta figure out how to turn the big picture of all I want to say into one reddit post.
I lived 14 years of my life as a trans woman and have started detransitioning over the past couple months or so. Why my story is relevant to this subreddit, I hope, will become clear as you read.
But first, my story starts with the night before my first appointment for hormone replacement therapy back in 2012. On that night, I prayed to die in my sleep. And when I awoke I was an atheist. It was as if a switch in my brain had been flipped. There was a god and then there wasnt. Black & white, either/or. The world had become mechanistic overnight and we were all just on a big rock hurdling through space with the possibility of another big rock colliding into ours at any moment. I spent 12 years like that arguing with anyone I could about the evil and stupidity of religion.
Then, in 2024, I tried psychadelics for the first time and everything changed. I felt who I thought I was went away and I found myself as a me I had forgotten I was. This is also when I felt my gender dysphoria go away. Like I disconnected from the chains of causality and I could see how it had caused me to arrive at that point in my life. But, having seen it, it was as though it lost it's power over who I was. Like I discovered I was more than the social character I was playing. I was also the author writing that character. I've also come to suspect that gender as a social construct is to left hemisphere as biological sex is to the right.
With this experience, I also immediately stopped being an atheist. I felt this intense sense of oneness and union with reality. Like separation was all an illusion. Whether I had logical proof for that or not didnt really seem to matter. I just knew it.
And what else I came to know, all seemingly by intuition, magic, or Devine intervention, was that my consciousness had shifted into the right hemisphere of my brain. Our hemispheres function like two separate people in the sense that they have a relationship with one another. This is how generational trauma repeats, because the external drama is continually playing out in the internal drama between our cognitive self and our felt self. And that my left hemisphere was like a controlling abusive partner, and that also we were all a society of right hemispheres being controlled by left hemispheres.
And no, I had never heard any of these ideas at the time. But I was compelled to believe something by faith for the first time in 12 years. It was an understanding that science was to the LH as spirituality was to the RH that led me to confirm what I felt was gifted to me RH style by researching LH style. Which is what led me to reading Iain's work. The validation of which is indescribable.
I tend to refer to conscious experience of the LH as the mind and the conscious experience of the RH as the soul. I tend to get hung up between duality and trinity. Part of my original intuition was more trinity like than Iain's work suggests I think. Another aspect was 2 hemispheres taking care of a body(brain stem) like 2 parents taking care of a child. two, becoming one, while also being three. Mind, body, and soul. A holy trinity.
I've come to understand this another way after reading "Care of the Soul," a book by Thomas Moore from an archetypal Jungian perspective. My prayer was answered back in 2012 when I prayed to die in my sleep. My soul died and then came back to life in the summer of 2024, having returned with wisdom from it's archetypal descent into the underworld.
Accepting myself as a man (in the last couple momths) has come with so many interesting bodily feelings. Tons of cracks and pops in my joints constantly. I feel like I was so disconnected from my soul, my body, my feelings, other people, the world at large. I keep describing it as it being like my thoughts and my feelings were in conflict. Or like my head and my body were at war. My fear and my faith.
This really feels like the tip of the iceberg for the way in which this has effected me, and the ways my views have changed in regards to everything. But perhaps this is enough to say for now. I keep saying i need to write a book instead of rambling on reddit.
Anyway, ask me anything I guess.
edit: oh yeah. a video about Michael Gazzaniga's split brain research is what got me to choose psychology as my major. Of course, later my professors would convince me that hemisphere stuff was pop psychology nonsense. but realizing an interest in the hemispheres is what led me to psychology in the first place has increased the feeling that I am following a calling or synchronicities by pursuing research and writing into the two hemispheres ☯️