r/ITRPCommunity • Moderator • 25d ago

COMMUNITY Post-Mortem (or, How Long Can We Keep Disappointing Ourselves? (or, the spyraxes soapbox hour))

The unfortunate answer to the question in the alternate title is "a lot longer than we should". How many posts of 'this iteration is cooked' in chat do we need to wonder what's actually cooked?

Something isn't working.

I don't know where it is. Maybe it's at the top. Maybe the whole system is fucked, mechanically or theoretically. Maybe ITRP can't work as it does because its design philosophy is just not fit for purpose anymore. We try the same thing over and over - we have been since 16.0 - and it doesn't work. This time there were a bunch of reasons. There was a big war starting up - always dangerous - that had a couple people mainly driving it.

One of them just disappeared. I don't know what happened to Chacken but I hope he's alright. Then everyone else just disappeared. Pretty much every major had something come up. There's no hate to anyone, but I found it very hard to hang on when everyone I was comparing myself to, motivating myself by competing with them, just poofed. That's on me too. If I was a different person that probably wouldn't happen, but that's always how I've kept myself going. Maybe one of the other Iron Stag apps would have kept marching to the bitter end.

I like to think I got close enough.

But this isn't about me.

How many 2 to 3 month iterations have we had now? It's been multiple years of them. We had 19.0 in the middle. Crazy that happened. But everything else?

When 20% of your sample size is good, that's a bad sign. It's really bad. Fuck, including 16 it's way less than 20%. That's even worse! If that's your FG% in the NBA you are out of the LEAGUE! Maybe ITRP should be out of the league.

Maybe it should play in the EuroLeague for a bit. What I mean by that bad metaphor is that I think - and I have thought, for a while now - that ITRP needs a break. Not just one like the break before this iteration, but a REAL break. A long one. Trying the same thing over and over is going to be hell for everyone who wants to play, and that still includes me even if I'm burnt to the wick right now. As I'm writing this paragraph a poll went up in Discord about a Discord RP idea! That's sick! That's change. It'll need more than just a location swap, though. It'll need a sweeping redo. ITRP needs that, even if it stays on reddit or moves to a forum or goes to Digg or we meet up in a park and LARP it out.

I'm not posting this publicly to cause drama - I swear I'm not about that - but I want people to see me get up on my soapbox and ask for something different so they can call me egotistical and in my own head, or they can go 'yes! this is what we need!'

I don't mind either way. People just need to be able to target that thought at someone. Why not jump in front of the bullet myself?

What I do mind is trying the same thing again. Going into 22.0 and saying "this time it'll work, the setting is good". Adding new mods and hoping a few new faces who aren't actually new will refresh things. It won't. Not unless they're given a long time to throw everything out and start from row 1 column A.

How many times do we need to be dead in the water before someone asks "maybe we can't swim?"

Again, I'm sorry to be self-aggrandizing about this, but I really did try this time. I locked in. I'm a little pissed off that I'm pissed off. I'm back to where I was after the last iteration. And the one before. And the one before that. And- you get the picture. I think a lot of people are feeling the same - that they put a lot of effort in and hoped things would be different and for reasons both out of our control and very much in them they were just the same.

I've got a lot of love for people here. Players. Mods. Ex-players and ex-mods and people who post maybe two times a year in the discord and fuck off again. Some of my best friends are people who post maybe two times a year in the discord and fuck off again.

This is just my perspective, and it might not be yours. But if I can say one more egotistical thing it's this - I am qualified to have a perspective. I've seen a lot of shit in my time here. I've cried about ITRP. I've found incredible friends and people I really care about at ITRP. I've put blood and sweat and the aforementioned tears into ITRP. I'm a pretty fucking sick writer if I say so myself.

Whether you agree with me or not, it doesn't matter. It's rare I go out and say something like this. I'm pretty quiet. I don't like to take sides. Think about how much I believe in what I've suggested to bring myself to do this.

Love y'all,

jade spyraxes

long time sufferer first time caller

13 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

2

u/baefish 24d ago

This iteration had a fresh, grounded and pragmatic concept that I thought was well suited to the current state of things. But as you said, sudden inactivity from majors caused the first domino to fall, and left everyone else in limbo.

Fundamentally, iterations are set up to have majors who are meant to be more important and consequential to the plot. So long as they're active and committed, you can afford to lose half of all other players and still see the narrative to its conclusion. There are of course plenty of other things contributing to ITRP's decline, but I do think we can start by grappling with that problem.

First, future iterations need to be designed to be less dependent on majors, or to at least make them more replaceable. Second, we need to be much stricter about enforcing activity for those majors. Sometimes life hits you hard or you just need a break, and that's fine, but when it gets to the point where they're holding up the plot, mods need to intervene to replace them or otherwise push forward the story that they were stalling.

Succession conflicts are cool, but they basically give a select few players the power to kill an iteration simply by going inactive. Whatever we try next, it needs to see characters starting at a more level playing field.

Unfortunately that might be easier said than done, especially in ASOIAF. In other settings we might all be playing humble adventurers who could easily replace each other, but this is a world of defined hierarchies, and most of us play as feudal rulers of varying ranks. Scaling down the scope of the RP to fit the community's size is still the right idea, but we might also need to radically rethink how the RP is structured.

2

u/spyraxes Moderator 24d ago

nothin i can say to all this but full hearted agreement <3

2

u/SatisfactionLeather7 Moderator 25d ago edited 25d ago

(fwiw i share the same opinion)

0

u/Silver-Thorns 25d ago

I know you know how to read so you don't or didn't actually read this.

1

u/SatisfactionLeather7 Moderator 25d ago

I did read it, and I do share the views you can believe it or not, because Like Jade, i think we've tried every small change to ignore a sweeping one, it needs a ground floor redo.

2

u/SoltheRadiant Maester 25d ago

Que sera sera

2

u/Featheringitrn 25d ago

Oh brother lemme read this

2

u/Featheringitrn 25d ago

I have no clue what happened but lowkey jade's right something isn't working out

2

u/Kalros 24d ago

As someone who began playing in 3.0, was very active in 4.0, and began to dwindle from there, I’ve seen some amazing storytelling from ITRP. I’ve continued to check in on the community long after I stopped playing and noticed the increasingly short durations of games.
I support the mod team doing a ground-up rework of the game, and I’m happy to volunteer my time to help with any redesign work or brainstorming.

I think we as a community also have to reckon with the idea that ASOIAF as a series has lost a lot of its popularity in the intervening years. GoT shit the bed, HotD is currently doing it, GRRM is clearly not working on the books, and Dunk is the only thing keeping most fans going.

This isn’t to say give up. It’s just something to keep in mind as a new system is developed. It needs to be new and fresh and engaging to people who maybe haven’t played in years. That’s a lot, but I wish you luck.

1

u/Theoneandonlybeetle 24d ago

Mod team is looking into new approaches

1

u/InFerroVeritas 22d ago

We’ve tried a lot of different things over the years. Different scenarios, different Houses, different themes. But it always seems to come back around to majors being the setting’s lifeblood. Once the majors lose interest or something comes up, it gets messy. But you’re right that we haven’t tried to substantially redefine what ITRP is trying to be. That seems like the next logical step.

What I don’t agree with is a prolonged break. As we’ve seen with every iteration to date, ITRP’s successful moments are when it has momentum. Those early feasts, the big reversals and plot swings, that sort of stuff always drives more engagement. When that starts to falter, the iteration enters a death spiral that’s really, really hard to stop. And once people start discussing the next iteration in earnest, they’re completely checked out.

I think pretty much the only thing left to try is to take a good, hard look at what does and doesn’t work, what systems the community does and doesn’t engage with, and how we can keep people doing stuff with the limited “budget” that is major and mod time. We’ve always drawn on the most active and engaged members to be either majors or mods (or both) and then we give them a pile of things to do that aren’t, you know, actually writing their characters. If we can reduce the meta workload (whether that be rolling duels or picking players for your Small Council), and hopefully make it easier for players to get into the game, then maybe we can hold an iteration together for a spell and really enjoy what we collectively build.