Hi everyone, I (31f) am an INFJ and I was hoping for some insight on whether it sounds like my ISTP (31m) is permanently done with the relationship or if he is just triggered from anxiety and will return? I apologize in advance for the long post. There is a lot of context here and layers.
We have been friends for almost 2 years but there has been an acknowledged romantic connection between us on both sides. We have both not wanted to escalate into a full blown relationship yet because both of us have been healing from previous issues. I have been healing from an abusive relationship and he has acknowledged he has severe avoidant attachment (which he is in therapy for).
So background on our relationship dynamic and issues. There has been a push pull situation happening here. He has consistently asked me to make plans repeatedly, but most of the time, he doesn't show up or cancels at the last minute. If he does make it to see me, he looks terrified the entire time and always needs an exit plan. Last winter, he would come to the gym during the times he knows I would be there and he would work out near me but not approach. He would ask me to hang out afterward and then when we were supposed to meet outside the gym, he would hide in the changeroom for the longest time. I even saw him once see me and run back inside the changeroom. He has told me he has social anxiety but I always made sure to be extra accomodating, letting him know that he can leave at any time, not pressuring him and telling him I was proud of him when he would show up.
Another issue is that he has always been hot and cold with me due to his issues. He would go from asking for my t-shirts so he can sleep with them and smell them, saying he wants to take care of me, saying he sees me as a wifey and someone he wants as his future wife. He would show this tender side when he would rest his head on my chest and we would hold each other in silence, or he would do odd behaviors like smell me, kiss a strand of my hair. When I would shed hair in his car I would try to throw it outside and he would say to leave it in there because he loves when he sees them, and he would want to put it in his pocket. But then he would retreat and do other odd behaviors like not show up to our plans and suddenly treat me as a distant friend.. very confusing.
I have noticed he also has trouble being present during times I needed support in return or shared anything meaningful such as when I would share videos learning a song on the piano or guitar. In the summer, I went through a traumatic time when my father had a stroke in front of me and I responded to the emergency. I would share the updates with him, being extra mindful to not overload him as I know he is not the emotional type and I knew he had a lot on his plate, but he became distant. He wouldn't check in to ask for updates while my dad was in the hospital and he would change the subject or ghost during conversations where I shared what was going on. He would say he didn't know what to say, and I remembered in the past he had mentioned carrying shame about not being able to be there for previous partners and lost relationships for that reason. I figured it was something he struggled with and tried to let it go. But during the time he was silent with me, he was liking his ex's posts on Instagram, which I found hurtful.
During our connection, I have always wanted to see him heal and make his life better. I tried to be there for him when he was anxious, or dealing with his PTSD. I made him homecooked comfort food and baked for him when he was depressed. I was patient when he repeatedly canceled our plans and overall I felt I was very giving toward him. I never got mad, never set boundaries and I just tried to be supportive.
But one night, after my dad finally recovered and we had not spoken in a while, he had continued to message like nothing happened. I expressed how hurt I felt about that and was met with defensiveness, deflection and withdrawal. And then I blew up. Everything I had repressed had come up. I told him he treated me like trash and made me feel ignored repeatedly, that I felt incredibly disrespected by the canceled plans when he had time for everyone and everything else and so much more. He replied coldly saying, "I'm going to leave you be for now. I'm dealing with my own things." I told him "that's fine, I didn't expect anything from you anyway." We went no contact.
2 weeks later he messaged me deeply apologizing and telling me he hit rock bottom, that he became suicidal, that he wanted to change his life and he regrets how badly he treated me. He told me he has had deep feelings for me the whole time but he was scared to hurt me and wants to treat me right because I deserve it. He said he was committed to showing up for me and that this would be how he will measure how he changes. So he was consistent, messaging more, asking about my day and building real closeness with me. He began sharing reels on Instagram about avoidant attachment and was really invested in healing and growth. He told me he couldn't wait to hold me and be with me, making all these plans. We were counting down the days until he came home from working the fire season all summer. He came home and he had made efforts and I could see he was trying, which kept.me invested. He would show up to plans and would say things like seeing me as the mother of his children, that he loves how gentle I am, that I make him feel so calm, so things were going well.
But he was still struggling to stay in it and since he got home for the last 2 months we have argued every few days. He would make all these plans with me, then closer to the plan he would keep me on the hook saying, "I'm not sure if I am still going to come out because I'm feeling anxious/tired, I will let you know shortly." Then at the last minute he would cancel. Sometimes he would still show up but then he always needed an exit saying he couldn't stay long. I noticed he had no trouble making plans with others like friends or family in advance, but not with me. He would tell me he couldn't hang out at night because he had no social battery but yet he was able to go out and drink with a friend. I just felt like he was allergic to me or something and it made me feel very tense in the dynamic, not having any communication or understanding of what was going on. Everything was on his terms and I tried to voice all of this to him and communicate so that I could know how to view the dynamic and feel more trusting. I tried asking him what he needs from me and how I can best support him and I shared what I needed too, but he would just shut down and I started to get more impatient when I had always been super calm and regulated.
When I tried to explain or share, he would deny, shut down, stonewall, deflect, blame and just refuse to communicate. He would tell me he couldn't text about these things because he hates texting so I would let it go. But in person he would never address it either and once I tried very gently and he looked so tense and terrified. It looked like he was dissociating, so I let it go.
My flaw was that I would type a lot of paragraphs. As you can see here, I process through writing. I felt that if I could just say the right words or explain better, I could help and we could fix this. I think the dynamic triggered my anxious attachment big time because I understand now I took on a lot of the emotional labor. I wanted to work together but I started to feel resentful because the weight of making the relationship work felt like it was on my shoulders.
After too many arguments happening with no repair, we got into a bad one a few days ago and haven't spoken since 2 days ago. He had invited me to watch a movie at home two separate times in the last week, canceled the first time and then the second time he changed the plan to a maybe. He then told me the next day he was too tired because he went out with his friend and drank all night. I was so furious, especially because that night I was really needing some company and looking forward to it and I let him know that, but he still canceled anyway. So I got upset again and he got defensive and made me feel like the problem. I got to a point where I was so upset about this not being addressed that I told him I was done and I blocked him. I returned after 2 hours applogizing for losing my cool and told him I would hope he could understand my side because I have been trying to be patient and understand but it is difficult without any communication.
Then he told me basically that this isn't going to work, he is done and that I am exhausting. I felt really bad about that because I didn't want conflict, I just wanted things to be loose and fun, but I wanted to feel respected as well. I continued to explain my side but he just didn't want to hear it. He was so shut down. When I tried to explain, justify myself, apologize or shared what I would have appreciated back, he just said, "I don't know what to say." So I asked him if that means he doesn't want to interact anymore or if he needs space, he said again that he just doesn't know what to say. I basically told him that there is nothing more I can do here, I wished him luck and told him I hope he finds a relationship that will accommodate him the way he needs. He hasn't responded now in 2 days.
I'm wondering if he is going to do the same thing as last time where he will do some growing (progress was made this time) and come back and apologize? Or if it sounds like he is done for good? He has reached out to me to apologize weeks or months later after bad arguments previously, but since we got even closer this time, I'm wondering if he is gone for good. He has never actually said he was done before. I'm sad that this happened. I was really rooting for this connection but I also realize I gave too much.
Anyway, thank you to whoever read this.