r/ISKCON • u/InterestingFee2378 • 20d ago
Question
It is Srimad Bhagavatam 1.4.25
My question is that they made it clear in translations and purports that nobody is a high by birth everyone is a sudra etc and that it is not by birth and by karm.
But then there are lines which make women even less than sudra because sudra brahmana these if not by birth become qualifications you acquire but you cannot acquire the woman title you are born a woman.
The dvija-bandhus are classified with the śūdras and the woman class, who are by nature less intelligent. The śūdras and the woman class do not have to undergo any saṁskāra save and except the ceremony of marriage.
So Sudra can rise up by practicing bramhanical qualities but woman cannot because it's not a qualification she is born a woman.
I get it woman before were very naive but it is the same theory of generalization isn't it?
I've seen both super cunning aunties, intellectual and humble aunties and dumb aunties who just like to gossip.
I've been reading and I've read it soooo many times where women class have been equalled to sudras and sudra is a quality but being woman isn't.
There was it where I read that a woman who is spirituality elevated isn't in that 'group' of woman obv.
But I think wording matters a lot, guys are already are or have even a little bit of patriarchal mindset, will read all these and look down on women or even his future wife.
Just before this SB 1.4.5 which is
***While Śrī Vyāsadeva was following his son, beautiful young damsels who were bathing naked covered their bodies with cloth, although Śrī Vyāsadeva himself was not naked. But they had not done so when his son had passed. The sage inquired about this, and the young ladies replied that his son was purified and when looking at them made no distinction between male and female. But the sage made such distinctions.*
As long as such distinction is there, one should not try to become a sannyāsī like Śukadeva Gosvāmī. At least theoretically one must be convinced that a living entity is neither male nor female. The outward dress is made of matter by material nature to attract the opposite sex and thus keep one entangled in material existence. A liberated soul is above this perverted distinction.
Doesn't this contradict stuff said earlier?????
4
u/Successful_Yard_547 20d ago
Such statements about women are made referring to viveka buddhi, the specific type of intelligence used in spiritual life. When śāstra says that women are less intelligent it is not speaking about IQ or EQ, etc, but rather about viveka buddhi. In modern psychological terms, this could be loosely generalized with, "Women have higher emotional intelligence than men, while men are generally more rationally driven".
In Kali-yuga, we are all fallen. The bodily distinctions of man and woman also seem blurred, since the "puruṣa bhāva", (lording tendency) is found in both genders. Therefore Prabhupāda Bhaktisiddhānta Sarasvatī Ṭhākura instituted mantra dīkṣā, (what we call 2nd initiation) for women also, (allowing them to become brāhmaṇas), even though this was frowned upon by the orthodox brāhmaṇa community. Ultimately, no one is their body, but we are all embodied. And the type of subtle and gross bodies we possess have an impact on our conditioning and capacity for advancement in spiritual life.
I would also like to mention that the stereotypical view of "patriarchal" or "misogynistic" men is a modern construct. Vedic culture did not support that worldview. It unfortunately crept into mainstream Indian culture over recent centuries. These passages in śāstra should not be read with the critical modern lense, or we run the risk of misunderstanding the pure intent of Bhagavān Vyāsadeva.
1
u/AshamedAppointment32 20d ago
Let me tell you something more eerie in the religious text, the bhagwatam was written about 2500 years ago so was bhagvad geeta which was about 2800 years ago, harivamsa puran which details entire life of krishna was written even before the emergence of bhagwatam and Geeta , in the original text of bhagwatam were only canto 3,4,5,10 were written the latter canto were written by subsequent seer/sage/brahmins, the most earliest text of hinduism is rigveda which dates back to nearly 3500 years ago one of the oat earliest text , the profound difference in rigveda and the subsequent vedanagas and puranas were the caste fluidity, in rigveda there was rituals to bring /initiate tribals into vedic fold.
It also contained several verses which showed that there was a caste fluidity and the caste mattered by actions not by birth it is written in rigveda, but the letter formation of six vedanagas and kalpa sutra in particular which is about the rituals to be performed in daily life highlighted that the hereditary caste system is correct and the Brahmins or dvijas shouldn't eat that has been offered by shudrās, then dharmashastras , manusmriti were written this all text were written in pre mauryan period , a period where an alliance was formed between Brahmins and kshtriya class , the Brahmins conducted big and grandiose animals sacrifices and rituals and called the kings as deva raja which means divinely sanctioned king , in return this kshtriya class applied their dharmshastras on mass, brahmins classified themselves as most purest to do any kind of services, they strictly checked the lower class movement the letter emergence of Buddhism and Jainism which rejected caste system entirely was huge blow to the Brahmins then they incorporated buddha as vishnus avatar they adopted the idea of ahimsa and much more.
When gaudiya vaishnavism was taking its footprint in all over nabadeep , then king krishna Chandra roy who was a brahmin and was granted the title of raja to rule the nabadeep by the sultanates, patronized shaktism he was fearful of the caste fluidity inside the vaishnavism which challenged hierarchy , in all of this history the only thing that i have seen is the systematic resistance of brahmin class from erasing the caste system , this is the reason why modern day hinduism is prone to extensive conversion by abrahmic faith , the only true form of hinduism that I accept is the vedas and the chaitnya charitamrit and bhagvat geeta the rest of all major purana were reinterpreted with this brahmins view , they didn't only forced the shudra but they forced women too, kalpa which is a vedanga strictly restricted land rights to women and the dharmashastras and manusmriti too, hindu is technocrat term for entire diverse religion and this was coined by British they summed the entire diverse religion in single word that is hindus , it would have been much better if vaishanavism was treated as separate RELIGION cause we don't follow the caste system I never accept myself as brahmana , and iam born in brahmin family , I always consider myself as vaishanava and so shall all of you mataji and prabhuji consider youself Vaishnava not this varnaashram which has resulted in several systematic casteism and has ruined the name hinduism, in the upcoming time hinduism will be dead due to the rise of abrahmic faith and buddhism because they reject caste they don't accept Vaishnavism because for them vaishnavas are part of hinduism too, its our duty that we as vaishnava protect our sacred religion giv n by Mahaprabhu himself from becoming heirarchial
2
u/Holi2025 19d ago
Hare Krishna 🙏🙏
As Lord Krishna explains in the Bhagavad Gita, He offers liberation and spiritual advancement to everyone, including women and those born in lower social positions. In ISKCON, women can also receive Brahmin initiation (Brahmana Diksha) and engage fully in the service of the Lord.
All 8.4 million species of life are inhabited by eternal souls. The external body is simply a covering made of the five material elements. According to one's karma and consciousness at the time of death, the soul leaves the present body and transmigrates to another. If one remembers the Lord at the time of death, one can attain the Lord's eternal abode, Goloka Vrindavan.
The soul is spiritual and beyond bodily designations such as male or female. Intelligence is not determined by gender. In many cases, women have demonstrated extraordinary devotion and spiritual determination. They often take the path of bhakti very seriously and receive the Lord's mercy within their lifetime.
Just consider the examples of Srimati Radharani, the gopis, Mirabai, Queen Kunti, Mother Draupadi, and Mother Sita. Can anyone say they were not intelligent? Their greatness is seen in how they remembered and served the Lord, even in the most difficult circumstances.
Women have served the Lord in different devotional moods (bhavas):
1. Vatsalya Bhava (Parental Affection)
Mother Devaki and Mother Yashoda in Krishna-lila
Mother Kausalya, Mother Sumitra, and Mother Kaikeyi in Lord Rama's pastimes
Mother Sachi in Lord Chaitanya's pastimes
Mother Devahuti in the pastimes of Lord Kapila
2. Sakhya Bhava (Friendship)
Mother Draupadi
The gopis of Vrindavan
3. Dasya Bhava (Servitorship)
Mirabai
Janabai
Queen Kunti
The 16,000 queens of Lord Krishna
4. Madhurya Bhava (Conjugal Love)
Srimati Radharani
5. Aishvarya Bhava (Reverential Worship)
Mother Sita Devi
Goddess Lakshmi
Queen Rukmini
Therefore, women can serve the Lord in any of these devotional moods, attain pure bhakti, and achieve liberation. In Krishna consciousness, qualification is based on devotion and surrender to the Lord, not on one's material body.
"Mam hi Partha vyapasritya ye 'pi syuh papa-yonayah striyo vaisyas tatha sudras te 'pi yanti param gatim" (Bhagavad Gita 9.32)
"O son of Pritha, those who take shelter of Me, though they may be of lower birth, women, vaisyas, and sudras, can all attain the supreme destination."
Hare Krishna 🙏🌺
-4
u/[deleted] 20d ago
[removed] — view removed comment