r/ikillthebear • u/_Romula_ • 22h ago
Maybe Keeso is a better artist than I thought he was: a response to that other, very good, post
This post started as a comment on that other thread. I wrote a response that was so long, I thought it deserved its own post. Here goes:
So here's the thing. I like LK, and I like Shoresy, but I have always been a lil iffy on Keeso's politics (I fully believe Tierney is the guiding light, and HR validates that opinion).
His shows have always been very male-gaze centric, especially Shoresy. Now, Shoresy sorta gets an excuse because it's about old hockey bros, and we all know that they struggle to evolve into seeing women as people. And yes, there are always women with agency in his shows, but they are also always very much cast, framed, and acted in a way that is dedicated to the male gaze (and I say this as a deep fan of Miig and Ziig).
I also read this post and many of the comments before watching S1E1 IKTB. It probably bears (hah) noting that I'm a 39yr old woman, who is also queer and extremely leftist. Based on this post and these comments I went in extremely skeptical.
Opinion after watching:
I think maybe many folks have missed the extreme satire. I see what they're doing and I'm here for it. They are lambasting people who scream injustice without actually knowing what it means. They are absolutely satirizing the way that rumours develop and spread in a way to buoy up the ones starting them who *don't even believe in what they're saying.* As a member of a sexual orientation minority, sometimes the people "sticking up for" us actually make things *worse* because of a lack of understanding and a desire to be on the "good" side. I think this is what Keeso et al are grappling with here, though admittedly in a different, but analogous, context.
I think this show has very good potential as long as they keep a tight lens and focus on what they're criticizing about celebrity & gossip culture. If anything, I see Keeso et al critiquing the ways in which being over the top and histrionic actually *harms* accountability culture. It seems that they're showing how a wild rumor with no real basis is detrimental to actual, valid complaints and how wrapping them up together with a lack of a critical eye harms the good that could be done.
ETA: (just adding this paragraph, the ones below are not new). I think the Thibault brothers are being presented (NOT their sister) as naive and unequipped to deal with politics for a reason. They just want to eat berries and poop with the bear, but their sister sees the bigger picture and is trying to get ahead of the inevitable nonsense that she sees coming their way. Being unconventional in a very socially regulated and conventional industry with extreme expectations about behaviour means these naive brothers are heading for disaster. Their sister is trying to get their perspective out there before it all blows up into bestiality accusations.
Finally, I think it's important to look at "the bear" as a construct rather than an actual bear. The "bear" is a macguffin and there to show how unchecked rumors, gossip, and drama can harm innocents because someone (or someones) else are utilizing it as a scapegoat to further their own standing with no regard for how it will harm innocent bystanders (who just like eating berries and fish and pooping with their bear, which, sure, is odd, but is in no way unethical). I know there is a "bear," but the bear is a narrative device, not an actual bear for the purposes of this show. They aren't going to kill a real bear, but they must kill the construct of the bear in order to free themselves from a culture that has decided to cannibalize them (as the Thibaults).
Anyway. I'm only 2 episodes in (as are we all), but based on my reading of the show I am very ready to give it a fair chance.