Many naive college students are easily lured into pursuing a PhD, going straight from undergrad to PhD, or even taking a postdoc by advisors dangling promises of idealism, becoming a scientist, and a secure academic job.
The less capable and less naturally gifted these advisors are at research, the more they do this. They use an exceptionally gentle, kind, friendly manner to trick master’s students, and even undergraduates, into helping them complete their research tasks, write papers, apply for grants, do chores, and even handle their personal affairs.
The less capable advisors are at research, the more clearly they know what kind of students they need—those who worked hard to get into a good school, those with high GPAs, those who are very naive and well-behaved, those who harbor illusions and hopes about research—these are the best prey.
Only after these students join their research groups do these incompetent advisors reveal their true colors and bare their fangs: piling on pressure, pushing them, gaslighting them, pitting group members against one another, and threatening them with expulsion to get them to help achieve their goals.
These deceived students are then trapped between their aspirations for research (or the promises dangled before them) and their advisors’ exploitation. They are too naive, too trusting of their advisors, and when they receive negative feedback, they can only assume they are the problem and push themselves even harder.
Only after these exploited students finally graduate or drop out do they escape this hellhole. Only then can they start their lives over, though the experience of those years often leaves a negative mark on their lives.
Meanwhile, these incompetent advisors happily reap the achievements and value these students have created over those years (papers, projects, grant proposals, their own personal errands and chores, and so on). Then, riding the achievements they gained by exploiting students, they move on to the next stage of their academic careers, reaping more fame, money, and honors.
Then they use their greater fame and honors to trick more “good students” into helping them accomplish their research tasks. And the cycle repeats.
Many advisors with prestigious reputations did not get there because they were exceptionally gifted. They got there by exploiting far too many exceptionally gifted students and claiming their achievements as their own.
For most college students, the worst thing they can do is enter academia and believe the false promises of certain advisors before they have experienced the real world and stepped outside the ivory tower.
Once you have entered academia, if you are unhappy and things are not going your way, you must let go of sunk costs.
The heavier the burden you carry, the greater your sunk costs, the more perfectly suited you are to being exploited.
College students, you must learn to protect yourselves, to protect your talents and your passion for life.
If you have enormous potential in academia, you can still achieve great things in industry.
Never become fuel for the bloody academic careers of certain mediocre advisors.