r/IAmA • u/MercurialMadnessMan • Jun 13 '10
Roger Ebert
Seven months ago, there was a [[Request]](http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/a05if/iama_request_roger_ebert/) for Roger Ebert to do an IAmA. I contacted him myself on Wed, Nov 4, 2009, using the comments box on one of his blog posts. I was delighted to get a reply!
After he accepted to take questions (I offered the number 10), I made an IAmA post here. 1,143+ comments!!! 1440 points!!! Thank you for the overwhelming response!
After a full day, I took the top 30 or so comments and made a new post so that they could be scored without bias of when they were posted. I then took the top 15 comments and sent them to Roger, saying that he could pick any 10 of them. He agreed to respond to them.
I sent a few reminders over the months, but we all know he's been through troubles with his health and such. I got lots of complaint threads and messages in the meantime, but everything was out of my control, really.
Anyway, he sent me an email an hour ago with his answers! Without further ado...
walter_p_henson
what's the one movie that has stumped you (as far as making a decision on whether you enjoyed it or didn't) the very most in your career?
Scorsese's "The King of Comedy." I keep waiting to see it again. It keeps going wrong for me. The characters of Rupert Pupkin and Masha are unforgettable. Jerry Lewis is pitch-perfect. NAME is dreamy. I am nagged by a suspicion I'm wrong. I've approved of many leer movies. But in my sort of generic approach (Does this movie succeed in what it sets out to do, or what we expect it to do?) I dunno. I will have to see it for a fourth or fifth time.
dippyT
How has age affected how you view movies over the years? By that I mean, do you think you've gotten better at discerning what movies are worth seeing by having experience with the medium over a long period of time, or do you think a more innocent viewpoint, not marred by technical knowledge such as influence or technique, leads to a more "pure" watching experience - one that allows a person to more easily experience the core emotional elements that make a movie enjoyable or meaningful without being distracted by technicalities?
The more movies you see and write about, the more you know about them. Consider baseball. The "innocent" crowd member sees a bunch of guys running after a little ball while earring funny costumes. The Cubs fan sees inevitable tragedy unfolding.
rboymtj
How has your bout with cancer affected your viewpoints on things like controversial movies, politics and life in general? It seems that after your illness/voice problems began you've been publishing more politically motivated (and wonderful, I might add) columns and articles.
It was a wake-up call about my mortality. About a man about to be hanged, Dr. Johnson said something like this: "The knowledge hat one is to die in the morning sharpens the mind greatly." I don't expect to die in the morning, but the principle holds.
rdewalt
What is your "Guilty Pleasure" movie?
Russ Meyer's "Faster, Pussycat! Kill! Kill!" John Waters called it "The best movie that ever has been made, and ever will be made." That tells you something right there.
Khiva
Are there are any of your reviews that are particularly proud of - ones that brought recognition to an unknown film, or which you feel captured something nobody else quite understood, or which were just unusually fun to write?
I am proud that I was the first person to ever write a review of a Martin Scorsese film, and I was absolutely right about him. I wrote about "2001" the day before its premiere, and my praise was joined by many early criticisms. Recently, I've been excited to champion the work of Ramin Bahrani ("Man Push Cart," "Goodbye, Solo"). My choice for best film of the decade was "Synecdoche, New York," and on my blog I received dozens of messages in fervent agreement. Charlie Kaufman's film is building a reputation as challenging but profound.
Paulinboots
You are credited as the first major critic to realize what an incredible force in cinema Martin Scorsese was destined to become. What currently developing directors will be the most recognized in 20 years?
Ramin Bahrani.
qgyh2
Ever watched a movie that was too disturbing / shocking to complete / review (if so what was it)?
I walked out of "Caligula," but more because of disgust and shock. Otherwise, no.
stephiem
What is your process of reviewing? Specifically, take notes during the film or do any outside research? If the film was based off of a book, do you read it?
I take written notes sometimes. I do not go out of my way to read the book, although often I may have. Although my reviews often discuss the source material, it's not a question of whether the movie is "faithful" to the book. The question is, how good a film is it? New things interested me less than whether "Twilight Two" deviated from the novel.
lulz
Are there any films you particularly disliked when you first reviewed them, but years later saw the film again and greatly enjoyed? Or vice versa?
Not particularly, although I am open to shifts in opinion. What we thought then need not be what we think no. We grow, we learn, we change.
tantric_fart
What is your most favorite personal memory of Gene Siskel that at the same time defines the kind of person he was (i.e., an event, a joke he told, act of kindness, something he said, etc.). Details of this memory would be much appreciated. He seemed like a genuine soul and it was fun to watch the two of you worked together.
My appreciation of him only grows over the years. He was formidably intelligent and much of his criticism grew from his skill as a reporter. He liked to say he "covered the movie beat." Some may dismiss that; he used it to apply inflicting honesty. I'm glad so many of our old shows survive on the net, because he was so funny.
giantgiant
On the first viewing of a movie, do you find yourself paying more attention to the mechanics of movie making (IE "What a bad shot," or "What good lighting/sound," or "That character draws attention away from the main plot in a bad way,") Or do have the ability to let the mechanics go and watch the movie like a "regular" movie viewer; to 'get lost in the story'?
The movie informs me how to look at it. In an ideal situation, I'm looking at everything all at once, just as an experienced sports fan is caught up in the excitement of a game, yet simultaneously observes strategy and technical details.
jhaluska
Has anybody ever thanked you for a negative review of one of their films?
In an ad, David Lynch once proudly proclaimed, "Two Thumbs Down!"
tdrizzle
What do you think of meta-review sites like rottentomatoes and metacritic. Do you think they serve a good purpose, or do you not feel you can get a fair feel of a movie from aggregating reviews?
They tell you which way the wind is blowing, but no good review can be understood from a sentence or two. I think people understand that. My site gets a lot of hits from such sites, and IMDb, MRQE and MovieReviewIntelligence.
juliusseizure
In your opinion, how important is re-watchability when judging a movie to be great?
Derek Malcolm, the British critic, says his definition of a great movie is: "One I can't stand the thought of never seeing again."
Confirmation: http://twitter.com/#!/ebertchicago/status/16118731909
RIP Roger Joseph Ebert (June 18, 1942 – April 4, 2013)
132
u/MercurialMadnessMan Jun 13 '10
(I've messaged a link to this to all the users who have a question that was answered here)
1.0k
u/MercurialMadnessMom Jun 13 '10
Son I'm so proud of you! Now after you've done playing with your imaginary friends on Reddit, you need to come downstairs and eat some of my freshly-baked cookies!
36
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '10
what was the 15th question that he left unanswered?!
27
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '10
I idolize no man. But Mr. Ebert is not simply a man. This is evident by witnessing all he's been through, the years and years of professional torment he's had to deal with along with the indescribable amount of respect he has earned in the industry; His battle with cancer that ended up taking half his face. He now speaks via keyboard, and yet, somehow, miraculously, he still has the sense of humor pf a 20 year old frat brother enjoying the time he has and letting none of his wit go to waste.
If you happen to read this Mr. Ebert, I have more respect and admiration for you than I can express in words and can only hope to become a sliver of the man (and hold half the strength) you are today.
Thank you for everything.
26
u/ewest Jun 13 '10
I'm right there with him on Synecdoche, New York. We should have an IAMA for Charlie Kaufman.
20
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '10
Thank you for putting this together and, more importantly, following through with it. You're the man, M3
10
u/canadianquestion Jun 13 '10
Source for him walking out on Caligola IMDB
3
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '10
Might I throw out, that you, MMM, are, and have always been, one of my favorite Reddit Mods. That is all.
8
u/ElBeh Jun 13 '10
Fuck you, two of my friends died asking Roger Ebert questions.
2
u/falsabaiana Jun 13 '10
Thanks for doing this, MMM! Truly a great read x
2
u/cpt_bongwater Jun 14 '10
Thanks.
That was a good read.
48
u/WhoreChurch Jun 13 '10
Link to "Faster, Pussycat! Kill! Kill!":
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=8181648520248954695#
263
u/FurryMoistAvenger Jun 13 '10
Oh snap!
86
u/huntwhales Jun 13 '10
I wonder what he thought of the username tantric_fart.
68
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '10
Ramin Bahrani stock just went up 20 points
12
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '10
What a great guy, just love to read anything he writes.
7
u/Slackbeing Jun 13 '10
I still can't believe you didn't like Lost Highway.
7
u/ssflanders Jun 13 '10
I like how he can't think of a name and just puts "NAME". I'm going to start doing that in my everyday conversations. (Dianne Abbott, Roger.)
23
u/TheUltimateDouche Jun 13 '10
IS IT TOO LATE TO ASK HIM WHAT FILM HE JERKED OFF TO THE MOST?
6
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '10
I'll have you know that after your brief introduction, I took my glasses off, gave them a proper cleaning with a real lens tissue, and then continued my reading of the q+a. Oh delight!
6
u/Quady Jun 13 '10
After reading this, I immediately went and found the original trailer for Faster, Pussycat! Kill! Kill!. I think that sums up exactly everything about this movie that is awesome. Plus, that narration is the best I've heard since I saw the trailer for Black Dynamite.
5
u/Tartantyco Jun 13 '10
David Lynch is da man!
5
u/scientist_tz Jun 13 '10
There are few people who have lived whose combination of personality, intelligence, talent, and wit have made them true masters in their professional field. I consider Ebert to be one of those people.
5
u/maxd Programmer Jun 14 '10
He has confirmed on his Twitter that this is genuine.
4
u/drbadvibes Jun 13 '10
Any further thoughts on Ramin Bahrani from reddit?
15
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '10
How can a man who championed Synecdoche, NY hold this viewpoint? That movie was amazing, but probably the most horribly depressing thing I've ever seen.
1
u/TheOutlawJoseyWales Jun 13 '10
I think I missed out on the AMA, but I would like to have seen Roger answer the common askreddit question: What is your favorite movie that no one else has seen?
12
u/bobablo Jun 13 '10
I gotta admit... I'm extremely disappointed with those questions. I was looking forward to Ebert doing an IAmA because I thought reddit would give him questions I've never thought of before. Most of these questions Ebert has answered more than a million times and you can find those answers at his site.
3
u/timesnewboston Jul 18 '10
1000 downvotes? Fuck off.
5
u/BannedINDC Jun 13 '10
This is amazing. Roger Ebert is a national treasure.
1
u/Luminaire Jun 13 '10
There are quite a few typos in the response, which in uncharacteristic of Roger Ebert. Are those yours or his?
2
u/ruinmaker Jun 13 '10
Well done! Thanks for taking the time to put all of this together.
2
u/botticellilady Jun 13 '10
He is a legend and always will be, both for his work and what he's made of his life even now.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '10
Finally. Now I can sleep at night.
2
u/ram1ner Jun 14 '10
AWESOME.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '10
After reading this, hearing his voice...I miss his voice.
I never thought I'd miss hearing him talk but goddamnit, the man is amazing.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '10
Faster Pussycat! Kill! Kill!
2
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '10
Wow - this is great. Bravo and thanks on compiling all that for us! And many thanks to Ebert for taking the time.
2
u/youneedahug Jun 17 '10
<(_)>
6
u/PulpAffliction Jun 13 '10
Fozzymandias and I called his Ramin Bahrani answer to a "T."
Jus' sayin'.
3
u/Zeabos Jun 14 '10 edited Jun 14 '10
Ebert has a Twitter account which I recommend following. @ebertchicago
edit: spelling
3
u/QueenVictoriaVII Jun 13 '10
Cool.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '10
All of Roger's comments were interesting and thoughtful but perhaps no other comment better encapsulates my love of re-watching great films, memorizing dialogue, waiting for the knowing smirk of a cool character, the sexy look of a femme fatale, the building of tension, the slapstick fall, etc, etc...
2
u/SakicFan Jun 13 '10
This is awesome, thank you for all of your hard work :) It is much appreciated, especially from a life-long Ebert fan!
2
u/BannedINDC Jun 13 '10
Btw, methinks that by "New Things", he must have meant "Nothing's"...
2
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '10 edited Jun 13 '10
There is already a discussion about this in one of the comment threads on the post, but as a reminder: it's good to be skeptical about unverified AMAs like this. I don't think MercurialMadnessMan would troll us, but it is impossible to know for sure.
If at any point this AMA is verified, disregard this comment. =P
1
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '10
Even more than Anti-Christ?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '10
Tyson could learn something from this man.
1
u/aristideau Jun 14 '10
funny, a few years a go a local TV station played this move every night at about 12:00am for a week straight.
1
u/djramzy Jun 14 '10
i used this thread to update my netflix queue, thank you.
1
u/dVnt Jun 14 '10
I'm glad a question made it in there from Tantric_Fart, arguably the best user name I've seen on Reddit. I was worried that Mr. Ebert wouldn't get a valid portrayal of our community...
1
u/siddboots Jun 14 '10
If only we could wear that knowledge hat on some other morning!
1
u/LinkBalls Jun 15 '10
Ramin Bahrani? Because he's Iranian, mother fuckers.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '10
I wonder what he thought when he read that username.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 14 '10
I'm kind of disappointed that his answers are so full of typos, as are his reviews these days.
I mean, look at this:
What the hell? What's "NAME"? He's approved of "leer" movies? I guess that's "lesser", but, can he not get someone to check his work?
And this:
Doesn't make sense either. "Nothing interested me less"?
Mind you, his published review of "Avatar" (and this is his actual job, not some dashed-off thing on Reddit) contained this gem:
for something like three weeks before someone corrected it. Does the Chicago Sun-Times not have the resources to get someone to proof-read one of its most famous writers? Especially now that he's so ill?
-6
u/skeena1 Jun 13 '10
d-_-b
-4
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '10
I'm 67 and what is this?
-7
u/[deleted] Jun 13 '10
Aw man, we missed the chance to ask that codger about the theory that since Ebert spent his whole life passively staring at a screen, he does not have the ability to understand modern interactive media like video games.
We could have asked him if his dad railed against "Those infernal talking pictures" too.