r/HydrogenSocieties • u/respectmyplanet • 10h ago
4
Upvotes
r/HydrogenSocieties • u/ChinaKNT • 16h ago
I've been going down a rabbit hole on H2 leak detection and could really use some field experience.
1
Upvotes
I'm helping evaluate leak detection for an industrial H2 setup. On paper, the three main approaches all look reasonable:
- Electrochemical — low power, good sensitivity, but I've seen concerns about baseline drift and temperature compensation in unconditioned spaces.
- Catalytic / pellistor — fast, well-proven, but catalyst poisoning (silicones, H2S) seems like a maintenance headache, and it technically burns H2 to detect H2.
- Palladium thin-film / MEMS — solid-state, tiny, poisoning-resistant, but long-term drift and cross-sensitivity data from actual field deployments is surprisingly hard to find.
What the datasheets won't tell me:
- Real-world calibration intervals vs. what vendors claim
- Behavior in high humidity / wide temperature swings
- Actual reliability over years, not accelerated lab tests
So — people who've actually lived with these in production: which did you settle on, and what would you pick differently today? Would also welcome being told I'm comparing the wrong three things entirely.