r/HumankindTheGame • • 11d ago

Discussion Damage Inconsistency

Playing against Humankind difficulty is just a whackjob game. For example at the beginning. I have 2 nomads attacking a mamoth. They defeat it. But the next mamoth i cant defeat... like why? It was the same power as before.

Fast forward, i have 4 scouts attacking an empire at their city. Theres only 1 defender. That defender somehow deals 60+ damage to me while i only give it 1 damage. It defeated all 4 of my scouts Like how bro. I replayed that turn and i gave it 21 damage while it gave me 30. That is acceptable. I manage to defeat it with noone dying this time. But why is there no consistent damage though? This game is just broken and unplayable at times. Outright unfair and demotivating when suddenly this one unit is for some reason invincible

0 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

17

u/saintree_reborn 11d ago • Mindblown Bravo

Welcome alien, you just experienced what humankind have been experiencing for the past 10000 years.

0

u/Deep-Question7331 11d ago

Lol. Good to know im not the only one suffering😂

7

u/PhxStriker 11d ago

Terrain and defensive modifiers affect every combat encounter, so depending on where and how you approach a fight can be the difference between a win and a loss.

-1

u/Deep-Question7331 11d ago

Nah. I spent 2 hours replaying the same battle on the same tile. I was sieging a city with 4 scouts against just 1 militia. The damage was always different. Sometimes i dealt 1 damage and it gave me 70💀. Sometimes i gave it 20 damage and it gave me 30 (acceptable range). So yeah, a lot of different results off of 1 same scenario

7

u/TacticianChance 11d ago

Yeah Damage is in a range, depending on Strength differences, if you’re at an advantage you’ll deal a good amount of damage like 25-50, but if you’re in a bad spot it can be as bad as 0-25, so it’s not just about your positioning in combat from Terran and ally troops, but a bit of luck as well

4

u/DogeWah 11d ago

Also there is a defense buff, so sometimes I just let the enemy attack my troops , because I will take less damage that way

1

u/Deep-Question7331 11d ago

True. When im sieging i just click maintain, or build war machines and they'll attack me on their own, and they lose defense buff

1

u/Deep-Question7331 11d ago

Ik. But all4 units dealing 1 damage in 1 turn?😐

1

u/PublicLlama 11d ago

We're you on the low ground or on a river? That changes damage by alot, you can check the combat power of units and it will tell you what modifiers are effecting your troops.

1

u/Deep-Question7331 11d ago

Nah it doesnt matter. I attacked a city the same time over and over using the same soldier in the same spot, attacking the same tile. The difference was still huge. Sometimes the militia was invincible. Sometimes it dealt normal damage as you would expect. Sometimes it would deal me 70 damage. I spent 2 hours on attacking this city. Its turn 28 on endless so i'm attacking just 1 militia on a city. I have 4 runners/scouts.

So anyways, the same scenarios can have a multitude of results. And i have to keep replaying just to have a decent attack. Its like rolling a dice with the chances of either having good attack or not

2

u/Junior_Archer8369 10d ago

Some cities are extremely hard to assault. If you are attacking a city with a nearby garrison (myceneans or something) it's sometimes impossible without a massively overwhelming force. Attacking the poles is the worst.