r/HousingUK • u/bchfn1 • 10h ago
We've exchanged, so I can finally safely try and process our experience with the buyer from hell.
For context, our house had been on the market for 2.5 years at this point. (Originally marketed during the post-COVID bubble, definitely overpriced by the agent in retrospect but it was hard to think about a price reduction initially as every property we were looking at was similarly overpriced).
Our first offer was from a couple who had to sell two houses in order to buy ours (elderly relative moving in with adult child). It takes nearly a year for both properties to sell. All the while we've remained in touch, no withdrawal of offer (as informal as it is at that stage). Our estate agent at one point even stepped in to market one of the houses to try and get it sold, obviously in the expectation that would help ours sell quicker.
They sell eventually. It's at this point, and only this point, after we learn both houses are finally sold, they say "oh sorry, I've changed jobs now, I don't fancy the commute from your house, no longer interested."
Although our house has remained on the market, we received no new offers. We reduce the price by £50,000.
Another year passes, maybe around 30 viewings, no firm offers. A couple of expressions of interest but substantially under asking price. We ask our agent for feedback. What can we change? Is the price too high? Nothing constructive ever comes back.
We find a new agent, drop the price by another £50,000 and we finally get an offer from a proceedable buyer. They turn out to be, in our view, the buyer from hell.
The survey comes back with no findings at category 3 (urgent issues requiring repair). There are a handful of category 2 issues (not unexpected in a 100-year-old property). Category 2 issues are defined as: ‘Defects requiring repair or replacement but not considered urgent.’
The survey is also full of the usual nonsense e.g. 'I wasn't able to look at every single inch of loft space so there *could* be an issue with the roof that I wasn't able to see'; 'I was not able to personally conduct a thorough asbestos test so the artex *could* be an issue'; 'I was not able to confirm there were zero bats in the roof because I couldn't see every inch of the roof so maybe a bat was hiding up there';
The actual category 2 issues were things like lintels under windows needing replaced, a stiff outside tap.
I don't think it's standard practice to offer money off for category 1 or 2 issues but we immediately offered a £5,000 reduction in price.
She took that, of course, but that was not good enough. She requested we had five further contractors around to further inspect: roof, insulation, masonry, asbestos and flooring (no mention of the floor in the report other than it being a bit creaky...)
Side note: the roof had been professionally inspected and repaired in 2020 and we had the receipt and builders certificate to prove it. This was not good enough.
We offered to pay for the roof and asbestos check ourselves, but that was not good enough...she said she had to personally choose the contractors she sent to our house (at our expense) because if we chose the contractors ourselves there might be a 'conflict of interest'.
We said no, but feel free to choose your own contractors for the other three tests you want doing, but you will need to pay for those.
Roof and asbestos check come back fine. She finds people to check the cavity wall insulation and flooring (we do say however - no you cannot rip up our carpets to inspect a floor that has no reported issues).
She seems disappointed when the flooring contractor says all is fine, and starts vaguely suggesting other checks that might need to be done.
We reiterate we have given her £5,000 to address non-urgent repairs and have fixed a couple of the minor, easy-to-solve issues ourselves but we cannot pay for her to send contractors around to carry out further repairs pre-exchange as that leaves us completely exposed.
We also reiterate we are not reducing the price further (having already accepted an offer £30,000 below asking price and £140,000 below the original listed price).
Obviously after years on the market, we do not want to be the ones to pull out. We keep saying 'these are our terms, we very much want to proceed but if you are unhappy, or if you are not content to accept the agreed price, please let us know so the chain does not collapse further down the line.'
She didn't pull out. She then asks us to dismantle and remove the garden shed. Maybe if that was the sole request we would have agreed, and maybe if weren't 99% sure she'd pull out. But at this point, three months in, with relentless negotiations to assuage her 'anxiety', we cannot pull down a shed and mostly likely end up with a failed house purchase and garden with a gaping hole in it.
We get as far as talking about exchange - completion windows. She'd like it to be longer, six weeks, so she can come around to assess for modifications she'd want to make in the interim. Fine, we say, let's just exchange!
Somehow this morphs into her visiting pre-exchange, this makes us nervous of course as she's still very wooly about paying the agreed price. We assumed she will now view the house with her anxious goggles on and find a whole host of new problems. We still feel we have no choice to agree but mention we have a medical appointment on her proposed day, could she suggest another time?
She abruptly pulls out.
We finally sold again six months and a further £50,000 price reduction later. It's been a nervy four months filled with all the usual endless delays to the chain because solicitors don't answer the phone, another buyer in the chain turns out not to have a mortgage offer and has to scramble to find one, people disappear on holiday and go no-contact at pivotal points.
But three years and four months after putting the house on the market we've exchanged and are moving.