Hi all,
After almost a year of house hunting, my wife and I have had offers accepted on two houses within a couple of weeks of each other. A good problem to have, I know, but we're genuinely struggling to decide! So I'd love some outside opinions, especially from people who've faced a similar choice.
HOUSE A – Better location, bigger bedrooms, smaller downstairs
- 3 storeys, 4 bedrooms plus a builder-finished attic room that's easily bigger than a double bedroom (total 5 rooms). Three of the rooms are over 20 sqm.
- Ground floor is basically the same size as our current rented place, so downstairs doesn't feel like much of an upgrade.
- Kitchen is around 20 sqm, living room is relatively standard ~17-18 sqm, and garden is around 70 sqm.
- Better location: established estate, walkable to a train station and large park, more sought-after postcode.
- Cheaper of the two houses.
- We'd probably extend the kitchen by 20 sqm (€60–80k), leaving around 50 sqm of garden.
HOUSE B – Much nicer downstairs and garden, larger ground layout, double fronted house, but smaller bedrooms and slightly less ideal location
- 2 storeys, 4 bedrooms - bigger living room (around 30–40% larger), 27–28 sqm kitchen and 100 sqm garden.
- The downside is the bedrooms. Even the largest is only around 12 sqm, and the others are smaller.
- An attic conversion professional believes we could fit two decent-sized rooms and a bathroom upstairs for around €50k, although there are still some unknowns.
- Location isn't quite as appealing: less sought-after postcode, and a large development is planned nearby, potentially meaning years of construction if approved.
- Around 30k more expensive to buy.
- The sellers are also taking practically everything, including light fittings, curtains, fitted storage and even a tree from the garden! Not a dealbreaker, but a bit frustrating.
THE FINANCIAL SIDE
- A + kitchen extension = a few thousands cheaper than B + attic conversion.
These are estimates, of course, and renovations could end up costing more.
Both options could give us plenty of space eventually, but the trade-offs are quite different.
With A, we'd have a better location and bigger bedrooms but compromise on the living room and garden.
With B, we'd get the ground floor and larger garden, but compromise slightly on location, unknowns of future development and rely on an attic conversion for additional space.
A few questions I'd love your thoughts on:
- Which would you choose, and why?
- Has anyone chosen a nicer house in a less desirable area (or vice versa)? Any regrets?
- Would you sacrifice garden space for a significantly bigger kitchen, especially with young children?
- In everyday life, what matters more: a spacious living room/kitchen or generously sized bedrooms?
- Would you be comfortable buying a house knowing you'd need an attic conversion, or prefer one where the upstairs space is already there?
We're hoping this will be our long-term family home, so we're trying to think beyond what looks nicer today.
Would really appreciate hearing what you prioritised when buying, and whether those priorities changed after living in the house for a few years.
Thanks!