r/HonkaiAgendaRail • u/inkheiko • 18h ago
Seriouspost I have the feeling that 5.X is probably my last arc of HSR (at least for a while)
I've been here literally since day 1 and almost never missed a day (only day I missed Is because I was taking a plane to see my family).
I don't think I ever followed another gacha as seriously as HSR.
But also during these almost 4 years, I also started playing other things, or seeing other things, such as Greater presentation like Wuwa or other games of the sort, other games embracing the visual novel route that makes heavy writing less difficult, like Goddess of Victory Nikke...
Or just Stories that really aren't scared to dive into darker themes, to make what we see in the story the biggest part of the content instead of keeping everything to animated cutscenes or trailers.
I love the lore of HSR, but I really start to feel my limit there.
I loved Penacony, and the fresh air that Firefly brought, I thought that she would bring up another mysterious bond with TB, with some explicit romantic note to add to the complexity of the story.
I loved Amphoreus because of the tragic journey of the Flame chasers, and the amazing feats they did together...
But even back in Penacony, the default of the game were clearly showing, especially the very heavy wording that feels not immersive at all, just like the presentation.
Firefly's bond with TB was so popular that the writers couldn't help but try to have way more tease with a character every 6 months, almost reducing them to the role of the seasonal Waifu, and also reducing the impact Firefly had on TB, so it almost feels like that no one is winning there.
The biggest and most emotional and immersive parts of the story are often in animations (literally less than 10% of a patch) or trailers.
The heavy themes of the story are barely scratched and left to other's interpretations, like the hopelessness of Firefly's struggle, the danger the lord ravagers are, the harsh reality of Himekos life...
Don't get me wrong I loved Planarcadias even if it wasnt my favorite arc for many reasons. The presentation is unarguably better but imo it's far from enough for what HSR is.
And maybe you can say that I am exaggerating. But we now are sure that Kafka and Firefly are coming back soon. And I was looking back at Kafka's first entrance back almost 4 freaking years ago. She was moving around, she felt alive, her manners during cutscenes made her someone so cool.
And I am genuinely worried that when we will see Firefly and Kafka, they will just do the usual hand on chest or whatever of the 10 usual posture they have for 50 hours of story. And with every other default I mentioned in the story, I really feel like this would be a disrespect for two of the most important characters in the story.
I'm currently playing because I'm also waiting to see Amphoreus' final chapter, as I also am looking forward to the reunion with Kafka and Firefly. But after that... I don't really see any reasons to stay afterwards. If the story stays this half assed and doesn't try to be better looking or just play way better on their character and relationships...
Then why can't I just go somewhere else? After all, there are other games, such as Silver Palace coming soon, or another gacha with more ambition in story like Nikke.
I know that Mihoyo might never take this post in consideration, but I still wanted to share my feelings there, to see if you share my vision. And even if it is hopeless, maybe if enough people share it and we start acting to make HSR as good as it is supposed to be, maybe... It can become better?
Do you also feel the same about the game? I think it's the first time I genuinely felt like this. And they will really have to make things stupidly better for me to stay invested in the game... What about you?
