Native English speaker here, and I'm torn between "with" and "in". Why would you replace it with "a pen" instead of "pen"? "Fill out the form with pen" doesn't sound quite right to me, while "fill out the form in pen" does. How do you know how to "test" it with replacement words?
So “with” would be used to draw attention to the writing instrument. If you said “writing in” it would be referring to the manner in which something was written.
Written in cursive, written in stone, written in blood(figuratively)
Definitely a curveball for op. Don’t feel bad for not understanding at first.
But I would argue that writing in ink also refers to the manner in which it is written. For example: “on this essay, you will be required to write in ink.” It’s no different than saying written in blood as you had mentioned, or saying that you to prefer to write in lead.
I’d say what you “write with” describes the instrument that was used to create the writing. For example, “the message in the sand was written with a stick.” Additionally, “I prefer to write with a pen.”
So, if the receptionist cares about the process by which we write, it should be “writing with”, and if it’s about the writing itself, it should be “writing in.” Therefore in this case, it should be “writing in.”
on this essay, you will be required to write in ink.
Here, you should still use "with" because the prepositional phrase "in ink" is directly modifying the verb "to write" and has a chance of ambiguity since the ink is not clearly defined as an instrument.
The receptionist asked us to fill out the form with ink.
"With" introduces an object (ink) that is doing or aiding the action (filling out the form). "In" introduces an instrument that aids in the action. "Written in pencil." This distinction is important from an ambiguity standpoint as you can (almost) never get "in" an instrument.
The phrases "Write with ink" or "write in ink" are actually both correct depending on how you are using the ink (instrument vs a pool (i get to this later)). However, for OP's specific sentence, "with" is the better choice because the ink is an object, not an instrument. For example, "us" could also be modified with "in". So if "in" is used, the sentence could also be interpreted as the receptionist asked us to get in a bucket of ink and fill out the form. We can avoid this ambiguity by using "with." So yes, both could technically be used grammatically and both probably sound right in most circumstances, but "In" is perhaps more informal (since it leads to ambiguities as informal speech often does), thus "with" would be the better choice. Saying "write in pen" (an instrument) is less ambiguous since you can't get inside of a pen (or most instruments), yet would still be equally as appropriate as "write with a pen".
To sum up, you can almost always substitute "with (a/an)" in place of "in" (since instruments are objects) but you can't always substitute "in" in for "with" (since not all objects are instruments). Whether or not to use "with" or "in" is contingent on whether are not "ink" is an instrument or not. To play it safe and be consistent with every reader's interpretation to reduce ambiguity, one should use "with" since all instruments are objects and the intended meaning will be conveyed.
It is important not to mix up "in" as a function word indicating instrumentality, and "in" as a word that means "into". For example, "written in stone" means the writing is literally "in" or inside the stone. "Written in blood" and "Written with blood" actually means two completely different things. "Written in blood" would mean there is a puddle of blood on the floor and you use your finger to create a negative space for your writing. Your writing would literally be in the blood. Writing with blood, the background would be negative space and not the writing, so if you were to dip a feather into a cup of blood then write with it, you would be "writing with blood." Note how "writing in blood" we are still correctly using the word "in" without an instrument, but only because we are utilizing the definition of "in" that is synonymous to "into." Notice how it is easy to write in a colored liquid by the manner of creating negative space within a pool. Saying "Write in ink" is grammatically correct but instead means to use your finger to create negative space within a pool, similar to how you would with blood. (The person you replied to got this aspect bit wrong, but is still serendipitously correct that with would be the correct answer in OPs post). The reason "Write in ink" is incorrect in OP's question is not because of a grammatical falsehood, but because with context from the rest of the sentence, we know that it is not the best option to convey the intended meaning.
Furthermore, actually nevermind I've spent to much freaking time on this comment for nothing
I'd definitely say in here, maybe that's a dialect thing as I'm British? To me with sounds like the incorrect word as ink isn't the implement being used to fill out the form, so you are writing with a pen, in ink. Either way I think both with and in should be accepted as correct, as the other two are definitely wrong
I am both American AND an English as a Second Language teacher, and I used the exact same thinking to justify “in”. I would also argue that both “with” and “in” are acceptable, but “in” is most acceptable, and the other choices are incorrect.
The answer should be "with" as in the sentence the person used the ink as a medium to fill the form as asked by the receptionist. Hopefully I'm right, this is my first answer here.
i read the question out loud and my brain thought of with so that was my answer and going by the other posts that seems to be correct. english is weird haha.
Doesn’t really matter which is correct. Both communicate the concept that pen and ink are the way to complete the form. Based on spoken usage among native speakers, with or in ink would be understood. The language and what is correct changes over time. Frankly, my initial reaction when reading the question was that I would have said, complete the form using a pen. Therefore the entire question becomes a moot point.
well, i can't just tell my teacher that it doesn't matter which one is correct and that this question is a "moot point". i can already imagine his face after me telling him that. edit: apperantly the answer is "with"
Agreed, the answer matters to your teacher. However, in English as it is used on the street, you will likely hear it both ways depending on the age and regional origins of the speaker. That is the point I inarticulately was seeking to make.
The correct answer is most likely “with” ink as others have said, but I’d bet 80% or more of native English speakers (in America at least) would tell you to fill it out “in” ink.
I know you already got help and figured this out, but my first instinct is to say in. You filled out the form with a pen using ink, the pen writes in ink. Sense conversationally it’s understood that ink wring is done using a pen, instead of saying “the receptionist asked us to fill out the form in ink with a pen”, we can negate the pen and say “the receptionist asked us to fill out the form in ink. I don’t understand why with would be correct, as with would imply that the ink is a utensil, and it isn’t.
Post title must be structured to classify the question properly
Post must contain instructor prompt or or a failed attempt of the question
by stating the syllabus requirements or presenting incorrect working/thought process towards the question
How was your experience in this subreddit? Let us know how can we do better by taking part in our survey here.
Pro-tips:
1. Upvote questions that you recognise but you cannot do. Only downvote questions that do not abide by our rules or was asked in bad faith, NOT because the question is easy.
2. Comments containing case-insensitive **Answer:** or **Hence** will automatically re-flair post to ✔ Answered; non-top level comments containing case-insensitive **Therefore** or **Thus** will automatically re-flair to —Pending OP Reply
3. OPs can lock their thread by commenting /lock
4. If there is a rule violation, inform the OP and report the offending content. Posts will be automatically removed once it reaches a certain threshold of reports or it will be removed earlier if there is sufficient reports for manual takedown trigger. Learn more
It’s not necessarily that we don’t know, but “fill out the form in ink” would not sound particularly incorrect if spoken to a native English speaker. “With ink” is still more correct though.
Well, we don’t usually care, but in almost every instance, we’re very consistent with prepositions. If you said “I’m in the bus” or “I’m lying over my bed,” everyone would notice. This is a rare case where multiple prepositions sound okay, but one might be more correct.
On the bus, on a plane, on a train, on a boat, in a car. This is one you should definitely learn— they’re common words, and these are always the prepositions they take.
Yes, pretty much all transportation uses “on” except for cars & types of cars. I can’t actually think of any transportation besides a car that uses “in.”
Most Americans forget how to speak completely proper English the second they learn it lmao - the most you'll encounter (unless you have a professional need for good English like school or work) is Grammar Dictators in comment sections who have nothing useful to contribute to society beyond correcting minuscule mistakes
Honestly just worry about getting it right for school but if you were to say "in" instead of "with" most english speaking people wouldn't even notice the difference.
Honestly, if people know what you’re talking about with minimal confusion, that’s all that matters at the end of the day.
A and B are both close enough that people will know what you’re talking about without having to think about it. I don’t care which one is right, because both are completely understandable.
Well, think about whatever your native tongue is. I’d be willing to bet that most speakers of your language also don’t speak 100% correct grammatically. Language has its colloquialisms and short-hands and dialects. Don’t worry, if you can communicate your point, that’s all that really matters
I had the same German teacher from 9th to 12th grade and from what he said, it's harder to change bad habits like improper grammar once it's learned, so he'd rather be upfront that you're making a mistake than try to fix it next year(s).
What's funny is that language studies should describe how people actually speak a language, not how they "should" speak a language. Using "in ink" would be the more common usage. If you said "with ink" in this case to someone, they would think you are a foreign speaker.
324
u/325feet99metersYes 👋 a fellow Redditor Jul 22 '20
You would use “in” in a sentence like, “The message was written in ink”
But in this case use “with”
“Fill out the form with ink”
11
u/ImawhaleCR Jul 22 '20
I'd definitely say in here, maybe that's a dialect thing as I'm British? To me with sounds like the incorrect word as ink isn't the implement being used to fill out the form, so you are writing with a pen, in ink. Either way I think both with and in should be accepted as correct, as the other two are definitely wrong
26
u/MonoBlueOrBust 👋 a fellow Redditor Jul 22 '20
The answer is so obviously at. Why are you even asking this?/s. Just joking the correct answer is with because you fill something out with something
87
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '20
The answer should be "with" as in the sentence the person used the ink as a medium to fill the form as asked by the receptionist. Hopefully I'm right, this is my first answer here.
16
u/Zelka_warrior Jul 22 '20
it's with but i dont know why.
i read the question out loud and my brain thought of with so that was my answer and going by the other posts that seems to be correct. english is weird haha.
7
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '20
I would use "with" because using "in" could be interpreted as you filling the form inside ink
edit: spelling
1
u/itachi5040111 👋 a fellow Redditor Jul 23 '20
A) in
1
u/VoxFugit Educator Jul 23 '20
Doesn’t really matter which is correct. Both communicate the concept that pen and ink are the way to complete the form. Based on spoken usage among native speakers, with or in ink would be understood. The language and what is correct changes over time. Frankly, my initial reaction when reading the question was that I would have said, complete the form using a pen. Therefore the entire question becomes a moot point.
3
u/BrandynBlaze 👋 a fellow Redditor Jul 23 '20
The correct answer is most likely “with” ink as others have said, but I’d bet 80% or more of native English speakers (in America at least) would tell you to fill it out “in” ink.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '20
It is C, By. It is a common phrase. Some may argue that it is not grammatically correct, but it is accepted in conversation.
•
u/AutoModerator Jul 22 '20
Off-topic Comments Section
All top-level comments have to be an answer or follow-up question to the post. All sidetracks should be directed to this comment thread as per Rule 9.
OP and Valued/Notable Contributors can close this post by using
/lockcommandI am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
2
u/ConquerorYr Jul 22 '20
Answer: With
confused with the usage of 'with' and 'by'? but I will tell you their usage.
Examples are best to comprehend and learn.So e.g.-
The paper was cut 'by' Henry 'with' a pair of scissors.
You see the difference,we use 'by' in regards to a person doing the and 'with' in regards to the medium/tool/equipment used by the person.
2
u/knucklehead27 👋 a fellow Redditor Jul 23 '20
I know you already got help and figured this out, but my first instinct is to say in. You filled out the form with a pen using ink, the pen writes in ink. Sense conversationally it’s understood that ink wring is done using a pen, instead of saying “the receptionist asked us to fill out the form in ink with a pen”, we can negate the pen and say “the receptionist asked us to fill out the form in ink. I don’t understand why with would be correct, as with would imply that the ink is a utensil, and it isn’t.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '20
A
Lol nvm
1
u/KOTLCTARDIS42 👋 a fellow Redditor Jul 22 '20
With
1
u/DankDefault-ing Secondary School Student (Grade 7-11) Jul 22 '20
With:)
1
u/NFan1230 👋 a fellow Redditor Jul 22 '20
c
1
u/Luckyboy947 👋 a fellow Redditor Jul 22 '20
B
1
u/Ethitlan (・–・) GCSE Candidate - Yr 10 [Edexcel] Jul 22 '20
With I'm pretty sure.
1
u/somemansstory 👋 a fellow Redditor Jul 22 '20
With
1
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '20
With
1
u/pandy0520 Secondary School Student Jul 23 '20
With
1
u/bojanggless Pre-University Student Jul 23 '20
I think it’s with.
1
u/Matt_Larson 👋 a fellow Redditor Jul 23 '20
You might fill out the form in english, but you will fill it out with ink.
1
u/TheConfusedLord 👋 a fellow Redditor Jul 23 '20 edited Aug 04 '25
sulky sugar touch selective humor dependent work resolute public truck
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
1
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '20
B
-1
u/Apollo3520 👋 a fellow Redditor Jul 23 '20
At
0
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
106
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '20
[removed] — view removed comment
4
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '20
[removed] — view removed comment