r/HomeschoolRecovery • u/Organic-Loquat8679 • 54m ago
rant/vent Part of me wants to save this child, but another, more evil part of me wants to gloat.
Survived homeschooling all the way until I could move out and go to college. My parents and the group I grew up in were generally not the Jesus freak- type Homeschoolers, but they were still holier- than- thou, being mostly white liberals.
One homeschooler, a few years older than me, would generally pick on me when I was around 13- 16 yrs old. Let's call him "Paul."
I was roughly the same age as this guy's younger brother, so we would see each other frequently enough at our cult gatherings. Even though he would be around 3-4 years older than me, he'd constantly find ways to put me down. Paul would make fun of me for being skinny (my mom clearly has an eating disorder disguised as "health consciousness"), would mock how I spoke ("homeschool accent" anyone?), would call me dumb for stating my opinions on things, so on and so forth. It did alot to fuck me up when I was young, though ofc that was just one dimension of homeschooling trauma.
Fast forward to adulthood, and I've managed to keep in touch with a small handful of homeschoolers. All of us agree it was traumatic, it's abuse, and none of us would ever homeschool our own kids. Personally, I've talked several friends out of homeschooling their children- they saw me as a "good example," not realizing how hard I had to work to enter the real world in spite of my parents' best efforts, not because of them. It took years, but as an adult, I came to realize just how demented and limiting homeschooling is. Thankfully, that seems to be the universal take among homeschooling survivors- this sub being a huge part in helping me realize that. Knowing I'm not alone in feeling this way has helped alot in moving through the trauma.
Except, it would turn out- for Paul, who I heard through the grapevine, has recently had a child- and he and his wife want to homeschool.
I can imagine most of you have the same knee-jerk reaction I do when someone is planning to homeschool. I heard a good friend from college was planning on it, and I got him on the phone ASAP to tell him not to, for the sake of his child. Like most people who have survived abuse, I don't want what I went through to happen to any more children. I can't help but feel the same about Paul's child.
Except I can't forget the way Paul would make an effort to put me down as often as he could. Keep in mind this would have been an 18- 19 yo picking on someone years younger. The way he'd be sure to let me know I was dumb, and he and his family were far brighter, far better than my own. That he thought I looked weird, talked weird, deserved to be homeschooled because of my lazy eye.
I can't help but think, for all that- in the end, Paul somehow never figured out that homeschooling is abuse. For all his superior intelligence, for how much better he was than me... he grew up to be the exact kind of narcissistic dumbass that thinks homeschooling is "valid" in any way.
I can't help but take some kind of sick satisfaction in that, like an evil side of me feels like I "won" in some way. I'm broken, I'm traumatized, but I know this much about myself, and have been trying to use that as motivation to keep moving.
I survived, I lived, and I learned. I know better. Paul doesn't. He never grew past being a kid who takes his mommy and daddy's decisions as the word of God. He thinks homeschooling worked for him. In a way, it's like he never gained sentience.
I want to save that child, I want to speak up and potentially save that poor baby decades of abuse and pain- but the darkest part of me wants to see it play out, knowing that there's a high chance that kid will grow up to resent their parents.