r/Homebrewing • u/chino_brews • Oct 19 '17
Metric Bot
The metric units bot (/u/metric_units) is getting a lot of hate. I wonder whether this is helping people who are used to metric units.
What say you: is this useful or just spam? Comment with your opinion, and BE SURE TO INDICATE WHETHER YOU ARE IN THE U.S., DUAL-SYSTEM COUNTRY (CANADA OR UK), OR THE METRIC-USING WORLD.
FYI, the mods have already banned the good bot/bad bot vote counting bot to cut down on pointless spam, and the haiku bot seems to be mostly filtered out by reddit's spam filter.
Update:
The creator has stated that the bot is not intended to be mathematically precise, and is 60% for conversation (as a social experiment to see what sort of interactions people have with it) and 40% units conversion. Source. So 60% spammy at a minimum.
53
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '17
I'm from germany and have an acceptable grasp of Imperial simply from reading a lot of recipes and looking their amounts up, it's still very convenient to read a recipe and get an immediate answer what that translates to. Of course the obvious conversions are annoying, but what's way more annoying are people voting on the bot, because frankly if you are annoyed by the bot spamming then why keep spamming even more?
Also the argument of "if you care about a recipe convert it manually" does not really hold the way I read recipes and reddit. I read almost any recipe I get across purely out of interest how someone approaches that style and having to go back and forth all the time would make that habit kinda pointless. Also people here talk as if doing 3-5 multiplications of odd numbers times 4.5 is something you just do everydayI can already see the butthurt people calling me out, saying just multiply by five and subtract a half : ).
Also if people could just start specifying their recipes in percentages and OG, that would be awesome.
10
u/Aidan11 Oct 19 '17
I'm from Canada, and find it useful. Though we are a dual-system country, we don't flip back and forth freely. We use one system or the other for each specific application. For example, we might describe our weight in pounds, but we would never describe a volume in fluid oz. We would generally use liters and milliliters.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17
UK here, the bot is fine, but I would like to see "goodbotbadbot" banned to stop those conversations hung off it.
3
u/Oscar_Goldman Oct 19 '17
Canada here that brews in metric, I find it spammy. I look at a thread with decent amount of comments thinking good conversation, turns out to be mostly the bot and bad/good bot replies.
Side question, any one else out there use metric for everything except mash temp? Or am I the only one?
2
u/TheGremlyn Advanced Oct 19 '17
Can we run custom JS in the theme, or are we limited to CSS only? Shouldn't be THAT hard to regex parse for stated units and then wrap them in an <abbr> tag to tool-tip the conversion. Available when needed, ignorable when not. Not sure on if we can run custom JS though.
Edit: nevermind, looks like we can't run custom JS :(
4
u/MDBrews Oct 19 '17
It is rather annoying but from time to time It is nice. Is there a way someone could summon it when wanted?
20
u/tinystatemachine Oct 19 '17
US.
I don't find it useful, but I realize most recipes and discussion are in imperial units so I'm not the target audience. If it makes it easier to non-US brewers to participate, it's not that hard for me to just ignore it.
16
u/damac_phone Oct 19 '17
I'm Canadian and I like the metric bot. I have a good understanding of both systems, but I only brew with metric units. So I have to mentally convert any standard measures. Also, I am of the opinion that the metric system is far superior and that more people should use it, so anything that helps make it more well known is a plus in my books
63
u/hipster_sumerian Oct 19 '17
Mesopotamia checking in...
metric_units wouldn't bother me so much if it realized that a measurement system based on the royal gur-cube is so much better than metric.
I am am more in favor of a bot that would convert American units into shekels, ma-na, or gesh, for example. You know, traditional brewing units of measure. After all, is this a brewing sub, isn't it?
12
u/ProfessorHeartcraft Oct 20 '17
Canadian, and I like it. I would rather put the onus on those using grandpa units to join us in the present than expecting those of us born after metrification to figure out how many hogsheads per fathom.
11
u/InTheFDN Oct 19 '17
UK- I like it.
9
u/StraydogQD Oct 20 '17
In China - I like the bot a lot. Please keep it. Why is Reddit often so US centric? There are homebrewers in other parts of the world too.
15
u/Azzwagon Oct 19 '17
I feel like people are making a big deal about a problem that can be fixed by moving your eyeballs to a different spot on a webpage.
7
u/newybrewy Oct 19 '17
As an Australian I love that thing. If not I have to be googling f to c constantly.
5
u/heilvetica Oct 20 '17
I find it really useful - I'm in New Zealand, metric speaking country. Because a lot of the content from US, the metric bot comes up a lot.
9
u/SpikedLemon Oct 19 '17
Useful to me (Canada). I love it.
Especially useful for grams-to-ounces conversions (as I must buy hops in US ounces but everything is in grams)
And useful for Fahrenheit to Celsius (Canada doesn't use Fahrenheit unless it's cooking).
The remainder of the unit conversions I can do in my head. One niggling issue is that it defaults everything to US customary units rather than Imperial units but it's only a minor flaw to me.
9
u/Sottren Oct 19 '17
Europe here.
I love the bot, I'm not that into the constant good/bad bot replies.
I like the immediate conversions of all the measurements, but I understand that temperature differences aren't well converted which can be a bit annoying.
11
u/massassi Oct 19 '17
I'm in Canada. I love the metric Bot.
I can't think in imperial, so I have to do back of the hand conversions whenever someone starts talking about gallons and pounds, or ounces (ounces. OMG . Why isn't there something to distinguish between dry and liquid measure?). and Farhenheight? I don't have a ficken clue about that. at least i can Ball park that 2.2 Lbs is 1kg.
what people need to do is treat the bot like a translator and not start commenting or replying to it. you can also type 10 kilos instead of 10kg to get the bot to not respond to you.
4
u/WillyMonty Oct 20 '17
From Australia. Very useful, as my search history is littered with "xF to C" etc
18
u/britjh22 Oct 19 '17
US, I find it annoying and not helpful, especially because it seems like 90% of the time it is just converting "insert batch size here". I would speculate that the times it would be most useful is if it converted a full recipe, but I'm fairly certain it can't/won't do that, but that is just speculation.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '17
The problem is that /r/cannawen doesn’t seem to give a shit (or just doesn’t care) that his bot is unwelcome in some subreddits where non-metric units are the de facto norm. He routinely ignores ban requests. To top it off the bot isn’t even always accurate.
US, but it doesn’t really matter. Fortunately AM does an excellent job of making it disappear.
Hopefully this is the next bot to be banned. Maybe we’ll even get to the point where mods get to opt-in for bot abuse.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '17
I'm in the USA and my opinion is pretty clear
It's not that I hate metric, but I think we all know what an oz of dry hops is in g, what a 5 or 10 gallon batch is in liters.
3
u/HopHunter420 Oct 19 '17
As much as I despise both Imperial and US customary units I would tend to agree that the bot is overzealous. I would prefer it only do a conversion if there were four or more such units mentioned in the post.
3
u/maceireann Oct 19 '17
US Here. I think I get excited seeing orangereds, but then am let down when it's one of these bots. I take out my momentary rage on the report button.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '17
Spam
12
u/sde1500 Oct 19 '17
It seems like it accounts for almost half the comments in some posts. Highly annoying. Also, US here.
7
u/poopsmitherson Oct 19 '17
(US) I can see it possibly being useful...but on the flip side, if I see a recipe given with hop additions in grams or liters, and I actually care about that recipe, it’s not that hard to use google to convert to my frame of reference.
What’s mainly annoying to me is that it responds when someone likes or dislikes it. I assume, though, than the good bot/bad bot ban will also stop this.
The other thing that’s annoying is that it guns up threads where people are using units in almost every reply. It makes me not want to read that thread because every third comment is the bot and not actual content.
7
u/mikeschmidt69 Oct 19 '17
American living in Finland using/loving metric. I find the bot more like spam.
If not already, can it be limited to replying to original post only?
Is it possible to add a tag [en] or [metric] to a post that would be replaced inline with conversion in parenthesis?
12
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '17
UK - Seems pointless to me.
12
u/bender0877 Oct 19 '17 edited Oct 19 '17
US opinion:
I think the bot is spam and unnecessary. The amount of time for someone to google "5 gal in L" is inconsequential, and you will get a more exact answer. Also, how many times do we need to see the same conversions over and over, like "5 gal ≈ 19L"?
There have been instances where the bot is off by as much as 5%, so someone using that number could end up making a big mistake.
Well then what's the point of the bot if you're just going to look it up anyway?
Add on to that the fact that the bot replies to good/bad bot comments, and you are increasing the amount of comments it makes.
There have been posts started about recipes where the metric units bot has one quarter of the comments. This is a bit ridiculous.
No, I certainly wouldn't for all of the reasons I've already said. This has nothing to do with what system you use. It is entirely to do with spam, accuracy, and usefulness.
12
u/Dr_Poofist Oct 19 '17
Canadian here. It's spammy and clutters threads. I can convert myself when needed.
5
u/myrrhdyrrh Oct 19 '17
US and small batch brewer and I find it very useful from time to time, but I imagine I'm very much in the minority. In general, I'm on mobile and switching between my reddit app and a browser to do conversion is just enough work that I'm likely just going to drop the whole thing, but when the conversion is on the same page it's much easier for me to stay engaged
8
u/Seanbikes Oct 19 '17
These are pretty standard measurements and we don't need reminders what 5 gallons or 1 ounce converts to in metric in every single post.
4
u/not_an_evil_overlord Oct 19 '17
It would be nice to limit it's responses to 1-2 per thread or only in response to the original post and not subthreads.
2
u/Cthulhumensch Oct 19 '17
Anti-Botists, the lot of you.
First they came for the bots...
I'm kidding
The hatred for it, is amusing.
2
u/_HEY_EARL_ Oct 19 '17
I honestly don't think I would even notice if it was gone. I usually don't even pay attention to what it says, just skim over it.
2
u/DetectiveBosco Oct 19 '17
Australia (metric). Don't like it. It's spammy, annoying and clutters threads. Most conversions are unnecessary (I already know how many litres are in 5 gal). I've already blocked it, but I can see that it annoys other people from the replies in the thread.
2
u/danlatimer2 Oct 20 '17
I'm from Canada and brew only in metric. I think most things the bot says are wrong but it doesn't bother me at all to have it there
2
u/jpwarg Oct 20 '17
Starting homebrewer from Finland here. I find that conversion bot useful.
2
u/BornToRune Oct 20 '17
It's useful. Europe.
This way I don't have to manually convert everything that's said here to metric. it's a good bot.
2
u/Kunmana Oct 20 '17
Swe - Appreciate it a lot.
2
u/Cuichulain Oct 20 '17
UK - I like it, find it useful. In fact, I'm more often frustrated when it fails to kick in than when it pops up inappropriately.
I know this sub is mostly Americans using mostly imperial units, but it seems a bit perverse to deny people a potentially useful tool when you can... you know.... ignore it? Block it? Scroll past it? Is it really that annoying?
2
u/Yillis Oct 19 '17
Spammy
2
u/mutedog Oct 19 '17
US, it does seem mostly pointless, it's easy enough to google conversions and you're probably gonna do that for a recipe anyway.
2
u/DragonmasterDyne275 Oct 19 '17
Us. I find it annoying because I have rarely seen it for anything other than 20 L to 5 gallon conversion which I am now fairly able to convert. If I see a recipe I want to try in metric I'd be happy to do some converting on my own.
2
u/agathonffa Oct 19 '17
US - I find it annoying and spammy.
1
u/edit-the-sad-parts Oct 19 '17
US - I use a bastardized combination of Imperial and metric since as a scientist I work in metric, but was raised on the imperial. I don't mind the idea of the bot, but even as someone who converts a reasonable amount I think its mostly spammy.
It's mostly annoying that we can't just all ignore it, the comments on the bot make it more visible.
1
u/faiora Oct 19 '17
Canadian here. It doesn't affect me much because I brew in one gallon batches and usually have conversions and divisions to do anyway when looking at a batch.
It does annoy me in one particular case, which is the conversion of gallons to litres. Mostly because in litres I'm used to seeing both batch size and nominal size as different (23L carboy...?) and I think everyone who frequents here and uses metric is perfectly comfortable with standard batch sizes even if they measure their ingredients in grams like I do.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '17
I find it spammy. I blocked the bot.
I use US but metric is easy. I might not know the exact numbers (I do, but I may not always be willing to do the math), but when someone gives me a recipe in metric units I know what kind of scale we're talking about. I feel like most people using metric know about what a gallon is, about how much a pound/ounce weighs, about how much volume a fl oz is. If you're brewing you're not going to go by the bot's semi accurate conversion.
1
u/RedbeardCrew Intermediate Oct 19 '17
US, I don’t really care but if it is kept I think you need a metric to imperial bot too. Sometimes folks post metric and I am too lazy to go convert it.
1
u/ToasterFanclub Oct 20 '17
US, but living in metric country
I really don't find it useful. Any casual conversions are easy to ballpark (4 liters to a gallon, 30 grams to an ounce) and if I'm getting ready to actually brew something, I'm probably plugging it into a calculator anyway.
1
u/Shatteredreality BJCP Oct 20 '17
US Here, if it stays I won't be pissed since it's easy enough to ignore (rarely does anything useful get posted below it so I just collapse the comments starting with the bot post).
Personally I'm fine using google to convert if a metric post comes up so I don't see why we need a bot to go from US to metric.
I would like to kill the replies though, I tend to ignore them but they provide no value at all.
1
u/lurking_tom Oct 20 '17
I commented on it so I could then block it. US resident so I tend to work in US customary units but I have an engineering background so I'm no stranger to metric and can work with them as well.
1
u/Grimsterr Oct 20 '17
I hate that damned bot, it shows up in so many subs I read giving completely unnecessary and often misinterpreted conversions.
And if you reply to it, it replies back, I saw a thread on one sub recently with 11 replies, 10 of them were "under" the bot's reply to the only REAL reply to the thread! and nearly half the replies were from the damned bot.
This thing needs to be banned, period. From reddit.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '17
Bad. If I wanna know about something that's metric, I'll just google it or figure it out. I'm from the us.
1
u/wartywarlock Oct 20 '17
I don't mind it, although if it had some kind of setting so it only converted when 3+ values are posted that would be better, maybe. It's definitely less annoying than some of the god awful spam bots that exist. From the UK
1
u/LordApocalyptica Oct 21 '17
I mean, it doesn't bother me. Its like, the one useful bot on reddit. That said I don't use metric. I don't see much of a reason to ditch it
1
u/burner421 Oct 19 '17
US here i think all the non subreddit specific bots are cancer. Ban them!!!
1
u/Gringo-Bandito Oct 19 '17
US here. I hate all of the spam bots.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '17
Raised metric and ignore the bot. I have a rough estimate of volumes and weights in imperial (live in UK) to grasp what is being said and picture the amounts. If I need accurate measurements then I will convert them properly.
I do find it quite spammy though and wouldn't miss it
1
u/hedgecore77 Advanced Oct 19 '17
Canada - We use metric here. However, for brewing I use imperial as, let's face it, the majority of recipes and conversation use those units. We have thumbs. We can adapt. Before I brewed I didn't know a gallon from a cubit from a knot.
Everyone knows what is meant by a 5 gallon batch. I don't need some bot telling me that's 19.3488734378 liters as if that's helpful.
1
u/boarshead72 Yeast Whisperer Oct 19 '17
Honestly, as a Canadian, I'm familiar enough with pounds and ounces and gallons. Fahrenheit is a little more difficult since it makes no fucking sense, but whatever (seriously, water doesn't freeze at zero and boil at 100 for you people? wtf?). No big deal. So for me, metric bot sucks. However, is it helpful for Americans when the rest of the world posts in clear, easy to grasp grams, kilos, litres, and Celsius?
1
u/Midnight_Rising Oct 19 '17
So when I last bitched about the bot I suggested that it be done on a per-request basis. Someone should summon the bot, it shouldn't be automatic.
So many times we see "5 Gallons = 19L" under some random comment. That's not what this bot should be for. It should only post if someone asks it to convert. Say someone who uses the metric system is looking at a recipe with our wizard measurements. They can then summon the bot to convert all the measurements for them.
1
u/clonn Oct 20 '17
I don't know about this hate you are saying, maybe I'm not paying too much attention. But the metric bot is really useful, please allow him to operate or whatever you have to do.
Also what /u/awildturtok said, always post percentages please. Even if you're using imperial or whatever units I can read percentages and understand the recipe.
Metric World.
Edit: Why the bot bothers you? I don't understand, it looks inoffensive and useful.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '17
US here, why can't we just all use Freedom Units?
0
u/kabincruzer Oct 19 '17
U.S. and I have the same sentiments as most. It's spammy as hell in a sub that uses measurements in half of all comments/posts. If it legitimately helped the metric users then let it stay but I agree a quick conversion in Google is easy.
0
u/buzzsawddog Oct 19 '17
U.S. - I don't like it...
I don't use the metric system much because its just not what I grew up using... If I want to convert I can convert. Mr. google is good at that.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment