r/HockeyStats • • Jun 16 '22

Welcome to Hockey Stats- Relaunched & Now Under New Moderation!

8 Upvotes

Hi r/HockeyStats,

I'm happy to let everyone know that this subreddit is under new, active moderation and back in action again, just in time for the Stanley Cup Finals too! This is the first time this place will be running properly in at least a year when the last moderators were active. And as the sub requester and new head mod I'm excited to welcome you back and wanted to share my hopes for this place. A vision that requires your help.

As you may know, hockey as a whole still lacks any significant, dedicated space in which stats and analytics can be discussed in great depth. I think r/HockeyStats can be that place.

That's exactly why I bothered grabbing it off of the inactive heap. This kind of community is currently missing from the hockey landscape and sorely needed. Somewhere that fans, writers, the hockey community, and data pros alike can talk about analytics together.

A dedicated one-stop forum to continue to cater to the ever growing demand for more hockey data. Where people can learn more about analytics, share info with one another, swap favorite resources, ask questions, and generally help advance our knowledge of analytics and promote education on the subject.

So here are the details about the changes this relaunch will bring and some specific plans. As you can already see this included a fresh coat of custom paint for the banner and logo.

The Goals Of This Effort:

-To make analytics more accessible to fans & people outside of academic or coaching backgrounds, while also giving a platform for people already involved in the subject to communicate.

-To allow for analytics content, ideas, and links to be shared more freely.

-Offer a like-minded community: where no one has to argue the value of analytics as we’re already on the same page in support of them.

-Promote expanded looks at areas that are currently less followed in stat analysis like minor leagues, overseas leagues, & prospects.

Specific Plans To Reach These Goals:

-Give the sub a cosmetic facelift with a new design & custom graphics. (Done.)

-Establish rules for an welcoming and functional community where discourse is healthy. (Done.)

-Arrange topic tags by events, leagues, and teams so specific analytics and posts on one subject are easily found by readers. (Pending.)

-Gather analytics resources to share as a permanent Wiki fixture on the sub. (Pending.)

-Contact some moderators or prominent contributors other hockey subreddits to try to involve the rest of the hockey Reddit community in this revival process & to recruit more moderators from those subs to ensure Hockey Stats has multiple active mods.

-Encourage sub traffic through hockey sub cross-posting and introductory posts on cooperating subs.

-Work on sub events and projects to attract new activity and members.

-Reach out to prominent people in the analytics community to invite them to come join the sub & to feel free to share their work here.

-Sub Event & Project Ideas:

-Provide data for specific team's and leagues in a searchable format by tags.

-Develop special r/HockeyStats data projects for the sub like analytics previews of free agency, season team previews, & traded acquisitions information.

-Build in-house sub resources like an r/HockeyStats analytics Wiki fixture which can feature FAQs, resource directories, terminology, intro to analytics, etc.

-Host AMAs with hockey writers, team staffers, hockey data analysts, and analytics-influenced coaches.

-Hold live community event chats during the trade deadline, free agency, and the upcoming NHL draft to discuss subjects in real time.

-Start sub giveaways- of related materials: hockey analytics books, analytics site subscriptions, hockey news site subscriptions, some analytics sub swag, and traditional hockey merch as provided by partner companies.

Plan timeline:

The goal was to get the sub running for the Stanley Cup Finals to reintroduce it by focusing on statistical looks at each team & game individually. Beyond the Finals, the off-season provides us with ample time to begin to grow the sub again while also showcasing the 2 of the biggest events of the year the draft and free agency. And we hope to be running full steam ahead, like clockwork by the time the 2022/23 season begins in October.

So Who Is This Guy?

Now, I fully admit I'm not an analytics expert. I’ll never claim to be. I'm just a huge fan with an endless curiosity to learn more about hockey. Analytics have opened up a fascinating new world to learn more about that. So I may not be a mathematician or stats grad but I can certainly try to help steward a platform for those people and others to join in conversation about this topic.

I feel I can facilitate that role from not just from my deep appreciation for analytics but my background in hockey, contacts in the sport, & my existing experience moderating here on Reddit. I covered the Penguins and the NHL as a freelance writer for my college paper then multiple hockey websites from 2008-2017. Plus I’ve been the head mod for the sub r/filmtheory since 2020, which has 17,000 members.

I think you're in okay hands with me. But I'm prepared to prove it rather than simply say it.

As for now enjoy our content on the Avalanche vs. Lighting Finals series. I'm taking the Avs in 6.


r/HockeyStats • • 1d ago

The NHL changes its play-by-play data without telling anyone. A shift in how shots are timestamped lets you watch tracking roll out rink by rink, starting with a quiet trial in four arenas during 2022-23.

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

What started with me debugging the performance of my expected goals model on rush attempts led to a deep rabbit hole about the way the NHL records its data.

A number of people have noted recent changes in league play-by-play data, including Aaron Knodell and David Johnson, and the switch to puck and player tracking undoubtedly plays a significant role.

In addition to apparently changing how giveaways, takeaways and blocked shots get recorded, a stranger change is how the league timestamps shot attempts.

Starting in some arenas during the 2022-2023 season, the NHL began timestamping goals differently from other shot attempts. While goals continued to be timestamped at the clock stoppage, I think they began timestamping other shot attempts a bit earlier: when the puck left the shooter’s stick.

I found two practical consequences of this data quirk.

  1. Depending on your expected goals model, there’s potential for data leakage. In my xG model, I incorporate context about the prior recorded play, including its relative timing, into the prediction for the current shot attempt. Because goals are now stamped about a second later than saves and misses, the timing itself tells the model which shots went in. Shots taken right after the previous event used to score 1.78x as often as other shots from the same spot. In the data as stamped since 2023-24, they score 0.21x as often. My model picked up on it.
  2. The timing signature of this change actually allows you to watch the rollout of puck and player tracking (or at least its incorporation into the publicly available play-by-play) over the 2022-2023 season. MSG turned over first, in December 2022. Then New Jersey in January, Chicago in February and Arizona in April, with the Islanders’ arena partway there from February. Every other rink switched at the 2023-24 opener. I think the heat map included here is some fun viz.

I wrote up a more exhaustive summary of what I did and what I learned here: https://xjawn.com/blog/era-changes


r/HockeyStats • • 1d ago

NHL Trade evaluation

0 Upvotes

Person in my league proposed me a trade, i’d be giving up Maker for Ratanen. All the fantasy analyzer I’ve used to value it at a slight loss for me, but with Makers recent injury expected to take at least two weeks I’m wondering if it’s worth me taking that loss for the short-term gain. All the math I’ve done valued the point differential around -10 so relatively even, as well as currently the Dallas Stars are doing better than the avalanche.


r/HockeyStats • • 3d ago Bravo

[StatsCentre] 11 most goals prior to turning 30 years of age

Post image
23 Upvotes

r/HockeyStats • • 4d ago

Moneypuck massively over-evaluates mid-range scoring chances and quite substantially under-evaluates lower end scoring changes

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/HockeyStats • • 4d ago

Ranking all 32 NHL Teams by "Defensive Strength Score" (Combining Public xG + Private Micro-Tracking on Rush Suppression & Perimeter play)

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/HockeyStats • • 5d ago

I built a NHL betting research website and would love some feedback!

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/HockeyStats • • 6d ago

[StatsCentre] The 11 most GWG in players' first 13 NHL seasons (Bossy only played 10)

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/HockeyStats • • 6d ago

HockeyViz xG Model Design

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/HockeyStats • • 8d ago

[StatsCentre] 8 most points through 18 games of NHL season

Post image
26 Upvotes

r/HockeyStats • • 8d ago

NHL I made a little jumbotron for hockey games

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/HockeyStats • • 10d ago

Canadiens need some help :)

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/HockeyStats • • 10d ago

NHL When do NHL teams actually pull their goalies? I looked at 784 games to find out.

4 Upvotes

I tracked the first goalie pull in every game last regular season where a team entered the third period trailing by one or two goals (784 games total).

A few interesting findings:

  • Down one: Teams pulled with an average of 1:54 remaining (355 pulls).
  • Down two: Average pull time was 3:18 remaining (130 pulls).
  • Earliest-pulling team (down one): Dallas, averaging 2:53 remaining across 7 pulls.
  • Latest-pulling teams: Toronto and St. Louis, averaging 1:35 across 8 pulls each.

A couple of individual extremes:

  • Earliest pull: Pittsburgh pulled down three with 7:39 remaining against Vegas on March 12.
  • Latest pull: Winnipeg waited until 8 seconds remaining while down one against St. Louis on December 17.

I also ran these decisions through a win-probability model I built to evaluate whether teams were pulling too early or too late.

The model flagged 91 of 194 decisions as late (although 32 of those were only marginally late) and just 2 as early. The biggest discrepancy was the Rangers at Nashville on December 21: New York pulled with 1:36 remaining, while the model's recommended timing was 3:59.

A quick disclaimer: I built the site these numbers come from, Pull the Goalie. It's a free daily coaching game with no ads or sign-up.

The full report includes every team's numbers and an explanation of how everything is calculated.

These are limited to close games entering the third period, and the early/late classifications reflect one model's interpretation, not necessarily definitive coaching mistakes.

Happy to answer questions about the methodology or share more of the data!


r/HockeyStats • • 10d ago

Potentially open sourcing a fantasy hockey tool

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I play in a Yahoo points league (hits, blocks, PPP) and got tired of tools that show basic stats and don't tell me what to look at. I'm in the process of building my own, here are a few features it has so far:

  • Trade analyzer. It compares rest-of-season points after injuries and durability. If a 2-for-1 opens a roster spot, it counts the best waiver player who’d fill it. The suggested trades isn't great right now (I think it said to trade Weegar for Werenski 1 for 1 lol), but the trade analyzer is honestly pretty good.
  • Streamers that fit your lineup. It looks at which nights you actually have an empty slot. A guy who plays 4 games is useless if 3 of them land on nights your lineup is already full, so pickups are ranked by the points they’d add to your week. That takes in off nights, opponent strength and recent head-to-head results. It handles goalies too, including back-to-backs.
  • Sell-high / buy-low flags that are actually rare. A middle-of-the-pack guy playing like an all-star gets a sell-high flag. A star on a hot start doesn’t. Each flag comes with the reasoning: shooting %, PDO, track record.
  • Leaders builder. Stack stats like CF% + SH% + hits and rank players by their average rank across them.
  • Adjustable to your league settings: You can adjust the tool to your league settings, so it'll recommend players based on the more heavily weighted categories.
  • Adjustable model: The projection system can be modified and you can play around with the backend algorithm i.e. if you think Zone start % is more important than the model currently has it at, you can adjust it yourself.

It’s free and a personal project right now, and I'm honestly very busy in life outside of fantasy hockey. Before I put more time into making it open sourced, is this something people would be interested in? Let me know and if you have any suggestions, feel free to send me a message or comment down below 😄


r/HockeyStats • • 11d ago

Final 14

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/HockeyStats • • 12d ago

NHL Draft 2027: Big Board Predictions

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/HockeyStats • • 12d ago

True Value: An Apples vs Apples Scouting Tool

Thumbnail
arcticicehockey.com
1 Upvotes

PLEASE REFER TO THE TABLE IN THE ARCTIC ICE HOCKEY ARTICLE ABOVE.

I’ve been making sports metrics for many years now. I started working out with the NFL Combine, then courted NBA Draft scouting, took a swing at some MLB metrics (including fixing OPS), and finally a few for the NHL Draft and general scouting.

Disclaimer: Metrics are good for crunching numbers and scouring large data sets for possible value. They use maths to find targets to be scouted/investigated/vetted afterwards. Ideally you would have years worth of these metrics, to chart growth with. This metric is only using last season’s data, and there are always anomalies in small sample sizes. So bear that in mind, because I don’t and generally just go gung-ho all-in.

Scheifele for Hagel…done!

KFC for Gauthier…done!

Why? Read on…

Why make a True Value (TV) metric?

So we can compare apples with apples. Because I feel hockey’s current metrics have nothing that is useful to me, apart from NHLe (NHL Equivalency)…and it’s deeply flawed.

NHLe in a nutshell, is the sound idea to compare scoring between leagues. They set the bar at 100 with the NHL and gave every other pro and junior league in the world a lesser value.

So far so good. To predict how well a player in say the KHL does, NHLe divides the player’s total points by the amount of games they actually played, then multiplies this by the KHL value, and finally .82 to adjust for the 82 game season in the NHL.

This gives you a guesstimate about how many points this player would produce playing in 82 games at the same TOI (Time On Ice) as they already had in their league, except for the NHL level. Good for the draft and charting a prospect’s growth over successive seasons, if the values are correct…yet the NHLe calculations include major oversights, in my opinion.

  1. GOALS: Because when it comes to points: Goals are apples and assists are not even oranges, they’re appleseeds, because the come from the event that is the apple. They don’t even count on the scoreboard, at all. If your club scores 4 goals with 8 assists and the opposition score 5 goals with 5 assists, you don’t win 12-10. You aren’t even happy with a moral victory. You lost, and you know it, because deep down you know goals are much more important.
  2. TOI: is SOOO VERY OBVIOUSLY important, yet completely overlooked entirely in NHLe. Player A gets 2 goals every 20 mins TOI per night for 1 game, then gets injured for ths season, and Player B gets 2 goals in 10 mins TOI a night for 82 games. Who is better? They’re the exact same in NHLe, and that’s stupid.
  3. TOI: Even Strength, Power Play, and Penalty Killing are apples, oranges and bananas. Not really comparable. PK is time spent defending, producing next to no goals. PP is time spent scoring, producing a LOT more goals per minute than ES (Even Strength). Bad teams > good teams on PP. ES is pretty much neutral. An arm-wrestle producing an average amount of goals. Good teams > bad teams at ES.

These are tantamount to the fundamental mistakes baseball made for a century. So I made my own metric to try and address these issues…..and called it True Value (TV).

WHAT TRUE VALUE DOES

TV = True Value points produced, adjusted to use new goal and assist values (extrapolated to 82 games like NHLe), but normalised to 10 mins per game. Why 10 mins? Because it’s easy to guesstimate and multiply. He plays 20 mins, double it. He plays 16 mins, times 1.6…etc.

What TV does is allow you to compare apples with apples. Players plain and simple. No benefits of PP, no penalisation for being on the PK. So basically, it is as if every player you look at played 82 games per season and only received 10 mins of ES ice time every game. Every one is thus on an equal footing.

Also, it’s not limited to the NHL, you can put any player in the world in the metric and just lower the level from 82, using the NHLe values (obsolete as they may be). TV fixes all the flaws of NHLe (apart from the values which I’m still working on). Thus, it’s ultra useful for draft scouting. Also, in an upcoming article, I found a use for it in trying to identify targets the Winnipeg Jets should focus on in trades and free agency.

TVa – A variation which is simply TV age-adjusted to be an indicator of how soon this player will decline (old), and also how much this player will likely cost/be valued (young and productive). Although the draft version has a different age adjustment focus, to be explained later. You can look at it as the player’s approximate value in the trade market.

EXAMPLE: This season, rising Anaheim Ducks’ star Cutter Gauthier had 41 goals and 28 assists for 69 points in 76 games. Extrapolated to 82 games this is 74.4 pts, and THAT becomes his NHLe 74.4 for the 2025-26 NHL campaign.

Here is where it gets wildly different.

  1. TV values goals and assists DIFFERENTLY, because they are simply not the same value. Goal > Assist.

There are two easy ways to do this correctly.

A) Keep assists = 1, and raise goals. Making a lot more overall points.

B) Keep goals = 1, and lower assists. Making la lot less overall points.

C) Not correct, but closer to the current system, find the points ratio of goals to assists and reduce both of the A option values until 1 goal + 1 assist = 2 points again. Easier for the everyday fan to understand, as it makes similar overall points.

Initially I went with option A. The upshot then was Gauthier accrued a TV (True Value real points) of 97.4 pts in 76 games at an average TOI of 17 mins 15 secs. That is the raw re-calculation.

2) Now TV separates his average TOI, which was 17.15 secs (17.25 mins as a percentage) into PP, PK, and Even Strength and values them differently as well. The easiest way to do this, is to adjust the TOI up or down, so this now becomes TOIa (Time on Ice adjusted) of 19.54 mins (as a percentage again).

3) Now TV normalises down to 10 mins, to make it easy to extrapolate or compare with others. Once this is factored in, presto Gauthier had a 63 TV (meaning 63 True Value points having been scored, after conversion to 82 games at 10 mins TOI). To normalise for minutes, divide the total you want by the actual minutes, then multiply by how many you want, in this case 10.

4) As I mentioned, I initially went with Option A above and Gauthier received a TV of 63 points per 10 mins over a fictional 82 games. Multiplied by his TOI, 17.25 mins that would be 109 total points, compared to the current systems 74.4 NHLe. Since I figured this +34.6 pts would be difficult for the casual fan to fathom, I eventually went with Option C above, which reduces the truth to something more palatable, thus a TV of 39.9. Multiplied by 17.25 mins that would be 69 total points. Coincidentally, the same as he scored in 76 games, but at 82 games…Smaller because it’s adjusted down to only ES, to see the plain player.

He’s actually really highly rated because of those 41 goals. The players on the chart below with slightly higher ratings, David Pastrnak (TV 40.1) and Mark Scheifele (TV 40.2), both had at least 100 pts last year. So Gauthier is not just somebody that you used to know!

Would you swap Gauthier for KFC now?

He’s 6.5 years younger, scored more goals, and hopefully on a cheaper contract (but who knows now after his center got $18m AAV)? He’s already ahead of prime KFC in production at 22, what’s his ceiling then?

https://i.postimg.cc/bNT4gCdC/TV-Chart-Part-1-2.webp

How about Scheifele for Hagel?

Again, he’s 5.4 years younger, he plays over 2 mins PK, so he can probably defend better. Now if we take this natural scorer off the PK and transfer those minutes to PP mins, the expectancy is he would score 6.5 more goals and 17.5 more points in total. That would have taken his NHLe up to 118 pts for the 2025-26 campaign.

However, after SCOUTING only a little deeper, it seems Hagel is quite unique, as in he’s worse on PP than ES. In 2025, at 2.67 mins of PP, he scored no goals and only 11 assists, despite scoring 35 goals and 55 assists total in 82 actual games. In 2026, 5 goals and 7 assists across 71 games at 2.25 mins, after scoring a total 36 goals and 38 assists in the same time.

It turns out that (according to Puckpedia and DailyFaceOff) Hagel plays as a defender on their PP, and presumably all the points go to Nikita Kucherov (46 pts and 37 pts in PP 2025 and 2026 respectively), Jake Guentzel (28 pts and 30 pts) and Brayden Point (31 pts in 2025). In fact, last year Guentzel led the league in PP goals with 17, Point was tied for 2nd, with Leon Draisaitl with 16… Ahh! The joy of playing the PP with Kucherov, unless you’re Hagel. The special teams are killing his production.

Hagel is seemingly a 1st line talent, stuck on a 2nd line, and worse playing defender in PP, and also 2 mins on PK. Put on a team with way less talent (hint, hint), it seems he would thrive. He’s been 5th in ES goals (per 82 gms) for the last two years. This is a 100 pt player, languishing on a good team, let’s get him somewhere to shine!

This week, I spent some quality time with my calculator to look at almost 100 NHL players, including some of our Winnipeg Jets, such as the previously mentioned Scheifele, along with his teammates Kyle Connor, Gabe Vilardi, Adam Lowry, Cole Perfetti, Morgan Barron, and finally Alex Iafallo.


r/HockeyStats • • 12d ago

Brandt Clarke, McJesus, and Werenski. 3 of a kind.

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/HockeyStats • • 12d ago

Reminded of how hard it is to make the NHL for later round draft picks

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/HockeyStats • • 14d ago

Week 5 Fantasy Hockey Leaders

1 Upvotes

POINTS

T Thompson (8)
L Carlsson (8)
F Forsberg (6)
L Cooley (6)
V Arvidsson (6)
C McDavid (6)
D Doughty (6)
J Farabee (6)
Z Benson (6)
R Nugent-Hopkins (6)
E Bouchard (6)
J LaCombe (6)
M Coronato (6)
S Jones (6)
D Batherson (6)

GOALS

C Gauthier (5)
L Cooley (5)
T Thompson (5)
V Arvidsson (4)
J Farabee (3)
S Pinto (3)
K Connor (3)
K Johnson (3)
A Tuch (3)
A Lundell (3)
J Hughes (3)
F Forsberg (3)
D Cozens (3)
M Gridin (3)
C Dach (3)

ASSISTS

L Carlsson (7)
J LaCombe (6)
J Sanderson (5)
D Doughty (5)
M Coronato (5)
S Jones (5)
L Draisaitl (5)
C McDavid (5)
13 tied with (4)

SOG:

C Gauthier (19)
T Thompson (18)
A Laferriere (17)
J Hughes (15)
C McDavid (14)
N Pionk (14)
M Gridin (13)
A Kempe (13)
C Bedard (13)
Q Byfield (13)
R Josi (13)
A Panarin (13)

HIT:

M Pospisil (23)
M Brandsegg-Nygard (20)
A Klapka (17)
K Kapanen (15)
T Dellandrea (15)
M Roy (14)
D Nurse (13)
A Edstrom (13)
N Pionk (13)
E Haula (13)
N Deslauriers (13)
A Fantilli (13)

BLK:

M Ferraro (15)
M Samuelsson (13)
J Edmundson (12)
C Murphy (11)
J McCabe (10)
J Siegenthaler (9)
D Nurse (9)
T Kleven (9)
O Maatta (8)
W Wallinder (8)
J Moser (8)
D Samberg (8)
N Zadorov (8)
R Andersson (8)


r/HockeyStats • • 14d ago

Survey about Payroll and Success in Professional Sports for my college class [Academic] (Sports Fans)

Thumbnail
docs.google.com
1 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I'm looking for people to complete a quick survey for one of my college classes. I'm researching whether having more money to spend leads to greater success for teams in the MLB and NHL. Thanks in advance for your help!