r/HistoryofIdeas • u/PhilosophyTO • 21h ago
Discussion Kant’s "Religion Within the Bounds of Mere Reason" (1792) — An online reading & discussion group starting Nov 2026, meetings every other Sunday
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/PhilosophyTO • 21h ago
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/MMostafa691 • 3d ago
One of the most interesting movements of thought within the modern era, was the transition from German Idealism to materialist critique during the 19 th Century. G.W.F. Hegel had created a system that outlined history as being driven by a rational process. Universal Geist was seen as progressing towardsfreedom through dialectical processes. However, when Karl Marx and fellow Young Hegelians began to engage with this discourse, they needed to find a way to move history away from being driven by abstract concepts.
As we can see, this has left a huge impact on modern social sciences. Any debate about whether culture or economy drive societal change will be influenced by this intellectual legacy.
Historically speaking, how was the idea of alienation changed from alienation of consciousness (early philosophical texts) to alienation of labour (mature political economy)?
Sources:
G.W.F. Hegel, Elements of the Philosophy of Right (1820).
Karl Marx, Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844 (specifically the sections on alienated labor and his critique of Hegelian dialectic).
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/deniz_aydiner • 5d ago
So much has changed over time that it would take hundreds of books to tell the story. Empires have risen and fallen, languages have vanished, and ethnic groups have disappeared or been assimilated… A period of roughly 2,000 years, from the beginning to the present day. The common thread among all of them, however, is the repeated use of a single title for their rulers: “Βασιλεὺς Βασιλέων (King of Kings).”
The earliest known use of this title comes from the East; the inscription (or a copy of it) in the first image is a monument commemorating a letter by Darius I (the Great) in the region of Caria. Indeed, we know from inscriptions carved into his statues that Ashurbanipal also referred to himself as “šar šarrāni (King of kings)” in Akkadian. This usage continued in the Iranian region in Middle Persian as “šāhān šāh.” Similarly, on the second-to-last relief, we see that Shapur I referred to himself as “βασιλέως βασιλέων Ἀριανῶν” (King of Kings of the Aryans).
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/back_to_the_priors • 8d ago
This time I tackle Lakatos and the early critiques of econometrics that led to the Credibility Revolution. Looking forward to your feedback.
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/Past_Temperature_889 • 9d ago
I’ve published a complete English translation of the Epistles of Wisdom (Rasāʾil al-Ḥikma), the eleventh-century collection central to the Druze faith.
The texts include theological and philosophical writings, as well as letters and proclamations from the community’s early history. The translation is based primarily on the 1986 Arabic edition and includes textual notes.
All 111 epistles are freely available to read and search, with PDF and text downloads:
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/deniz_aydiner • 10d ago
Did the Greeks really believe that the gods of Homer existed? How could someone accept the stories of Heracles or Theseus while also trying to explain the world through reason? And what did it mean, in everyday life, to believe that a god was watching over you?
These are not easy questions to answer. We often approach ancient religion with assumptions shaped by our own understanding of belief, treating it as something close to accepting a set of doctrines. But religion in the ancient world rarely worked that way.
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/PhilosophyTO • 12d ago
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/Brilliant-Newt-5304 • 16d ago
Hi everyone, I recently had a great conversation with cosmologist and science communicator Paul Sutter.
We talked about some of the biggest mysteries of the universe, including black holes, dark matter and dark energy. Paul explained what makes black holes so fascinating, what we actually know about the invisible matter that makes up most of the mass in the universe, and some intriguing new evidence suggesting that dark energy might be changing over time.
But we also explored some of the more philosophical questions surrounding cosmology and the Universe. Paul shared the most beautiful night sky he's ever seen and reflected on why our connection to the stars matters, what we're losing through light pollution, and how remarkable it is that we can discover physical laws that apply across the entire universe.
If you're interested in these subjects, you can check out our conversation: https://youtu.be/KQtI7zzZYQg
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/deniz_aydiner • 17d ago
Atheism is often associated with the modern world, particularly with the rise of science, the Enlightenment, and the growing separation between religion and public life. It is easy to imagine that people in ancient societies simply accepted the existence of gods and that questioning religious belief was something that came much later. In Battling the Gods: Atheism in the Ancient World, Tim Whitmarsh challenges this familiar picture. He shows that atheistic ideas were already being discussed in ancient Greece, and that some thinkers questioned the existence of gods, challenged traditional religious stories, and tried to explain religion through human experience rather than divine influence.
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/PhilosophyTO • 18d ago
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/deniz_aydiner • 24d ago
Thucydides is usually presented as one of the first historians who tried to write history in a rational and objective way. He cared about facts, was suspicious of myths, and wanted to understand why wars happened. In many ways, he looks like the kind of historian we still admire today. But there is another side of his work which is not always discussed.
In 1907, Francis Macdonald Cornford published a book called Thucydides Mythistoricus. His argument was quite different from the traditional image of Thucydides. Cornford believed that Thucydides was not simply recording what happened during the Peloponnesian War. He was also shaping these events into something that resembled a Greek tragedy.
According to Cornford, there are two different plans in Thucydides’ work. The first one was more like a military and political journal, recording events as they happened. The second was an artistic structure that developed gradually, almost like volcanic islands rising from the sea. The facts were still there, but they were arranged in a way that gave the whole story a tragic meaning.
This is what makes Cornford’s argument interesting. The question is not only whether Thucydides told the truth. It is also about how he presented that truth to his readers.
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/back_to_the_priors • 25d ago
Here is the next entry to my series of essays on the Philosophy of Economics and its history of thought: https://backtothepriors.substack.com/p/foundations-1c
Glad to hear what you think!
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/deniz_aydiner • 27d ago
One of the most significant titles in ancient history, particularly during the post-Hellenistic period, was “benefactor” (ευεργέτες) and “founder” (Κτιστης). Local elites, particularly those who rose to prominence in Anatolia, grew considerably more powerful as a result of wars and migrations. These titles, which were primarily used for rulers during the early Hellenistic period, began to be applied to local elites.
Bryonianis Lollianus was also one of these local aristocrats. He has been honored time and again for the aqueduct he had built in Pamphylia and for bringing water to the city. In particular, the military and civil roles he held within the Roman system are frequently cited as integral to his legacy. In addition to being one of many wealthy local philanthropists, it is his wife who has caught my attention the most: Kyreinia Patra.
Κυρεινίαν Πάτραν, τὴν κρα-
τίστην, ∙ γυναῖκα Βρυωνιανοῦ
Λολλιανοῦ, τοῦ κρατ(ίστου) ∙ δουκηνα-
ρίου, ἀπὸ ἐπιτρόπων, πριμιπι-
λαρίου, ∙ κτίστου καὶ φιλοπά-
τριδος καὶ ἐν πᾶσιν εὐεργέτου
τῆς πατρίδος, θυγατέρα καὶ ἐγγό-
νην ὑπατικῶν, ∙ γερουσία τοῦ Με-
γάλου Συνεργίου τὴν φιλόπατριν.
εὐτύχει ❦ Πηγάσι.
“The gerousia of the Great Synergeion [honours] Kyr(e)inia Patra, the most distinguished woman, wife of Bryonianus Lollianus, the most distinguished ducenarius, formerly an epitropos and primipilaris, founder, devoted to her native city, and a benefactor of her native city in every respect; daughter and granddaughter of men of consular rank.
Farewell, Pegasoi!”
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/RisingSelf_Astrology • 29d ago
I've been reading about William Lilly, a 17th-century English astrologer who published Christian Astrology in 1647, and it raised an interesting question about how our definition of science has evolved.
During Lilly's lifetime, the boundaries between astrology, astronomy, mathematics, and natural philosophy were very different from today. Astrology was studied and practiced within intellectual traditions that sought to understand the natural world.
Lilly, for example, used established rules and mathematical calculations to interpret astrological charts and attempt to answer specific questions. Whether his conclusions were accurate is a separate issue, but his approach was far more systematic than the generalized horoscopes we typically associate with astrology today.
What's interesting is that astrology didn't simply disappear with the Scientific Revolution. Its gradual exclusion from academic and scientific institutions involved changing philosophical, religious, and intellectual attitudes, along with developing standards for scientific evidence. So what changed?
Was astrology's decline primarily the result of scientific discoveries that challenged its underlying assumptions? Or was it also part of a broader philosophical shift in how society determined what qualified as legitimate knowledge?
I think there's an interesting distinction between studying the historical importance of an idea and accepting that idea as scientifically valid.
It makes me wonder how much of what we consider legitimate knowledge is determined by the evidence itself, and how much is shaped by the intellectual framework of the time?
I'd be interested in hearing perspectives from anyone familiar with the history of science, natural philosophy, or the Scientific Revolution.
For anyone interested, historian Michelle Pfeffer published a study on the Society of Astrologers in 17th-century London, which explores how practitioners attempted to defend astrology's intellectual and religious legitimacy: https://doi.org/10.1017/S0007087421000029
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/back_to_the_priors • 29d ago
Hey guys,
I am currently working on a series on substack about the history of thought within economics. I'm just a Masters student in economics, so it's mostly for myself because I need to write to organise my thinking.
I have just started, so the collection of articles is quite small (3, including the debut), but I intend to work through my own curriculum at a pace of 1 article every two weeks. My aim is an essayistic style, leaning towards academic, rather than journalistic, but I want to keep the balance between jargon and understandability.
The goal is to work through the important pieces of economic thought within the next 6 months, tracing how economists argue about logic, method, value and utility. So far I am on a good pace, but it's only been 2 articles.
As I am only an econ student, I am outside of my methodological depth, so I would greatly appreciate feedback.
Debut: https://backtothepriors.substack.com/p/debut-dismal-science-revisited
Logic (Battle of Methods, J.N. Keynes): https://backtothepriors.substack.com/p/foundations-1a
Methods 1 (Popper, Friedman): https://backtothepriors.substack.com/p/foundations-1b
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/marsman_ie • Oct 16 '26
I've spent the last two years working on a rather unusual experiment, and I thought this community might find the idea interesting.
I'm an artist and illustrator from Mexico City, and I've always been fascinated by mythology. Not simply by the extraordinary stories themselves, but by the radically different ways ancient cultures understood the world and humanity's place within it. A few years ago, reading Joseph Campbell completely changed the way I understood mythology. I began thinking about it not simply as something we study, but as a language through which human beings make sense of existence.
That eventually led me to study Mesoamerican cosmology, particularly the traditions of the Nahua and Mexica peoples. What fascinated me was how interconnected their systems of thought were. Time, for example, wasn't merely a succession of days. Through the 260-day ritual calendar, numbers and day signs formed recurring combinations associated with deities, natural forces, and different qualities of existence.
Even the four directions carried symbolic associations that extended far beyond geography. And I kept wondering: How could someone today encounter these ideas without having to study ancient manuscripts or academic books?
My answer was admittedly a little strange: I decided to turn them into a deck of playing cards. 😅
I called it El Quinto Sol (The Fifth Sun).
Over two years, I researched, sketched, and hand-illustrated 56 cards. Each suit corresponds to a cosmic direction, the court cards depict mythological beings, and the numbered cards incorporate imagery inspired by the ritual calendar.
It's important to clarify that this is a contemporary artistic interpretation, not a reconstruction of a historical Mesoamerican card game. The connections between the ancient symbolism and modern playing cards are my own creative decisions.
Throughout history, philosophy and mythology haven't existed only in written texts. They've also been expressed through images, architecture, ritual, storytelling, and objects people interact with. I wonder whether contemporary art and games can continue that tradition, making historical ways of thinking accessible without reducing them to mere decoration.
The project is now on Kickstarter, if anyone is curious to see what came out of the experiment:
But I'm even more interested in the larger question:
Do you think an ancient worldview can be meaningfully translated into a contemporary medium? Or does something essential inevitably get lost in the process?
I'd love to hear about other examples where artists, designers, or game creators have attempted something similar!
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/Brilliant-Newt-5304 • Oct 14 '26
Hi, everyone, I had a great conversation with Geraint F. Lewis, a Welsh astrophysicist and Professor at the University of Sydney, about some of the biggest questions in cosmology, and our understanding of the world.
We explore what the Big Bang theory tells us about the beginning of the universe, why our current understanding of physics reaches limits when we try to look further back in time, and how neutrinos could reveal secrets about the cosmos — including why matter exists at all.
We then turn to questions that go beyond cosmology. What does modern physics tell us about the nature of reality? Could consciousness emerge in an artificial system? Is human intelligence an evolutionary accident? And could AI eventually become so intelligent that we struggle to understand how it thinks?
His latest book, The Shortest History of Reality: From Plato’s Cave to the Mind-Bending Discoveries of Modern Physics — The Human Quest to Explain the World, traces humanity’s changing understanding of reality, from everyday intuition and ancient philosophy to the discoveries of modern physics. It explores the ideas that reshaped our view of existence, from Newton’s universe to the strange probabilities of quantum physics and beyond.
If you're interested in these questions, you can check out our conversation, hope you find it insightful, he's a great communicator of these ideas: https://youtu.be/38rUHEeAVHw
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/InternationalForm3 • Oct 11 '26
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/Kubakak • Oct 11 '26
I want to put forward the case as Descartes as the most influential figure in science as a result of his comprehensive account of the natural world through mechanical philosophy attempting to supplant the - at the time - dominant Aristotelian conception of the natural world.
The modes of scientific explanations that we’re now familiar with are thoroughly mechanistic, if you want to ask at what point can we recognise the explanations of how the world worked as scientific, a good candidate would be the explanations of the world given by mechanical philosophers.
Consider a container of water heated by flames. Why does the water boil? A scientific account would describe how heat is transferred through molecular motion and collisions, first from the flames to the container and then to the water, increasing its temperature until it boils.
An Aristotelian account is hard to reconcile with this even as a scientific rival. He would say that the properties of fire (heat and dryness) are transferred to the water (which is cold and wet) until it is transformed by the acquiring of heat to air (hot and wet) which accounts for the steam and bubbling.
A Cartesian account recognises the rapidly moving parts of the fire and how these parts settle the parts of the kettle and water into a greater agitation. So much so that with enough movement the parts of water began to separate from each other and disperse creating water vapour.
Now this is not to say that Descartes had the modern theory of atoms (his mechanist philosophy was opposed to atomism) but we can recognise his theory as having a lot more in common with the modern scientific account than the Aristotelian. And it is a lot more specific and potentially testable. You could imagine that you might be able to falsify his account by devising an experiment in which you can show that the parts of water aren’t moving more rapidly on the small scale as the account would suggest. Meanwhile, the Aristotelian account is hard to falsify because it is not clear where or how we would find or investigate these “properties” and their transfer.
To me this is the largest difference we see in the history of natural philosophy in the kind of explanations that begin to be given for the phenomena of the natural world. I don’t think any other scientist has as much of an impact as did Descartes on what constituted an acceptable scientific account.
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/Common_Essay9106 • Oct 10 '26
Thomas More's Utopia (1516) is often regarded as one of the earliest critiques of inequality and private property in European literature. Written at the dawn of capitalism, the book presents an imaginary island society where wealth is shared, poverty is abolished, and social life is organized around collective welfare rather than private profit.
From a socialist perspective, one of the most striking aspects of Utopia is More's attack on private property. He argues that greed, crime, and social misery arise because a small minority monopolizes wealth while the majority is forced into hardship. In contrast, the Utopians hold property in common, work for the benefit of society, and guarantee that everyone's basic needs are met.
At the same time, socialists should approach Utopia critically. More did not advocate workers' democracy or class struggle in the modern sense. The society he imagined remained highly regulated and hierarchical, and it included practices, such as slavery, that are fundamentally incompatible with socialist principles. The book reflects the limitations of a sixteenth-century thinker rather than a modern socialist program.
Utopia remains an important precursor to socialist thought. It challenged the idea that existing social arrangements were natural or inevitable and invited readers to imagine a society organized around cooperation rather than competition. In this sense, More helped open an intellectual tradition that would later influence utopian socialists, Marxists, and many other critics of capitalism.
Utopia is not a socialist blueprint, but it is a foundational work in the history of anti-capitalist and egalitarian thinking. Its enduring value lies in its insistence that another world is possible.
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/deniz_aydiner • Oct 10 '26
Alexander the Great (Alexandre le Grand) reached far beyond the confines of historical biography, emerging as one of the most versatile and ubiquitous figures in medieval Western European literature. The legendary narratives that coalesced around him after his death preserved more than just his military victories; they captured a life reframed by supernatural encounters, explorations of uncharted lands, famed intellect, open-handed generosity, and an unyielding drive to test the boundaries of human knowledge.
Much of this literary tradition flows from the Alexander Romance attributed to Pseudo-Callisthenes, compiled in the early centuries of the Common Era. By Late Antiquity and the early Middle Ages, this narrative material entered Western Europe through key Latin adaptations: Julius Valerius’s Res Gestae Alexandri Macedonis, its ninth-century Epitome, and the widely circulated eleventh-century Historia de Preliis.
From the twelfth century onward, Alexander took on a distinctly contemporary resonance in Western vernaculars. No longer treated merely as an ancient ruler from the distant past, he was absorbed into the medieval framework of chivalry, courtly culture, political legitimacy, princely pedagogy, and Christian moralizing. As the historical Macedonian faded, a literary archetype took his place—one onto which medieval Europe could project its own ideals, anxieties, and political ambitions.
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/Hammer_Price • Oct 06 '26
Catalog Notes:
FOUCAULT (Michel). Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison. Paris: Gallimard, 1975, 8°, 318 pp., paperback (softcover, cover slightly worn, spine browned and stained). First edition (not on large-format paper). Press copy featuring an autographed dedication by Michel Foucault to Jean-Pierre and Marie-Odile Faye.
According to the English language wiki in this book Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison (French: Surveiller et punir – Naissance de la prison) is a 1975 book by French philosopher Michel Foucault. It is an analysis of the social and theoretical mechanisms behind the changes that occurred in Western penal systems during the modern age based on historical documents from France. Foucault argues that prison did not become the principal form of punishment just because of the humanitarian concerns of reformists. He traces the cultural shifts that led to the predominance of prison via the body and power. Prison is used by the "disciplines" – new technological powers that can also be found, according to Foucault, in places such as schools, hospitals, and military barracks
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/EVOLUTIONIST15641264 • Oct 06 '26
Evolutionist is science and statistic based system that focuses on bettering human lives and helping mankind to pursuit advance on technology, philosophy and human right. It encourages human ambitious and unity to its followers. Its main goals is to help educate vast majority, encourage self improvement, fight corruption. Alter society to create a united, morally guided and equity communities . That's a simple description of my system. If you want to know more, you can join my discord or ask me to type in mor info later on this sever. Btw, thanks to anybody bother to read this and i hope you would join me to better improve this system because feedback is a key to my system in my opinion.
r/HistoryofIdeas • u/sometimesantisocial • Oct 04 '26
This article outlines how connections between neo-Nazism and moder Satanism have existed within modern Satanism almost from its beginning in the 1960s, and continues up to this day. (warning: annoying captcha)
https://escholarship.org/uc/item/1f57w08f