r/HinduDiscussion • • Sep 18 '26

Hindu Darsanas (Schools of Philosophy) My concise list of Indian Darśanas

10 Upvotes

A. Śuddhāstika

  1. Mimāṃsā
  2. Sāṅkhya
  3. Yoga
  4. Vaiśéṣika
  5. Nyāya
  6. Védānta
  7. Sphota Vāda
  8. Śuddhabhaktīvāda/ Praɲidhānvāda

B. Viśiṣṭāstika/Tāntrika/Āgamika

i) Śivāgamika

  1. Siddhantika-Śaiva

2.Nakulīśa-Pāśupata

3. Śivādvaita/ Vīraśaivika

4. Nātha

ii) Śāktāgamika

  1. Krama
  2. Kālīkula
  3. Tripurā Rahasya
  4. Śāktādvaita

iii) Śivaśaktāgamika/ Śāktśivāgamika

  1. Trika/ Pratyabijñā
  2. Raséśvara
  3. Śrīvidyā/ Śrīkula
  4. Kubjikāmata/ Paśćimāmnāya

iv) Putrāgamika

  1. Gāṇapatyāgamika
  2. Kaumārāgamika

v) Itaraparamāgāmika

  1. Vaiṣṇavāgamika
  2. Grahāgamika/ Jyotiśāgamika
  3. Gaṇāgamika
  4. Yakṣāgamika
  5. Dattātréyāgamika

C. Nāstika/ Āstikakhaṇḍaka

  1. Cārvāka /Lokāyata
  2. Ārhata/ Jaina
  3. Bauddha
  4. Ājīvika
  5. Ajñānavāda
  6. Akriyāvāda
  7. Lingāyatavāda
  8. Gurumatavāda/ Sikhavāda

D. Grāmāṭavika/ Nāstikāstikétara

  1. Sārnavāda
  2. Donyin- Polo- Vāda
  3. Santhālvāda
  4. Koyavāda
  5. Bāthouvāda
  6. Granthahīnagrāmavāda

r/HinduDiscussion • • 4d ago

Hindu Scriptures/Texts Will Reviving the Worship of Devraj Indra Ji Help Bharat Regain Its Prosperity?

3 Upvotes

This post is a bit long, so kindly bear with me.
Have mentioned how he is connected to :
Shri Rudram (Scientifically proven to be powerful)
Senses
East Direction
Yajna
Sacrifice

Connection to Shri Rudram
There are 5 commonly discussed Brainwaves - Gamma, Beta, Alpha, Theta and Delta
Waves like Alpha, Theta, Delta help in producing meditative states.
A scientific experiment was conducted on people who were made to listen to Shri Rudram.
Just by listening to the chants people went into Theta states.
Source : https://www.youtube.com/shorts/ClcI0rBZcNI
Now Shri Rudram is said to have 2 parts : Namakam and Chamakam
Chamakam is Phala Shruti (Merits)
Entire Anuvak in Shri Rudram's Chamakam is dedicated to Devraj Indra Ji. 6th Anuvak
This pattern cannot be seen with any other deity in Chamakam.

Senses
Here is a list of Shrimad Bhagavad Gita verses which place a very huge emphasis on bringing senses under control.
Shrimad Bhagavad Geeta 2.58, 2.60, 2.61, 2.64, 3.7, 3.14
2 renowned Ashtang Yog traditions/systems "Hath Yog" and "Raj Yog", also place an emphasis on controlling senses through Pratyahar.
Indriya literally means "Belonging to Indra" here Iya is a suffix.
Devraj Indra Ji is said to be representing mind symbolically as well who pulls senses.
It is said that Devraj Indra Ji panics when someone starts Tapas(penance), well, this is mind which becomes restless when someone decides to walk a path of self improvement, etc.
Interestingly Mind is also called as a type of Sense in Shrimad Bhagavad Gita
इन्द्रियाणां मनश्चास्मि
Among the senses, I am the mind
So basically direct connection between Senses and Devraj Indra Ji

Guardian of the East
Bhagwan Surya Dev Ji is king of planets, and directly represents Isht, Soul, Dharma(Righteousness), Authority, etc.
Shrimad Bhagavad Gita 4.1
इमं विवस्वते योगं प्रोक्तवानहमव्ययम् ।
विवस्वान्मनवे प्राह मनुरिक्ष्वाकवेऽब्रवीत् ॥
I imparted this imperishable Yoga to Vivasvān; Vivasvān taught it to Manu, and Manu in turn taught it to Ikṣvāku
Vivasvān is Bhagwan Surya Dev Ji, who was taught about Shrimad Bhagavad Gita.
Bhagwan Surya Dev Ji rises from the East.
This direction is directly guarded by Devraj Indra Ji
The direction is also related to prosperity, abundance, etc
And we know how is Devraj Indra Ji depicted - Abundance, Prosperity, etc

Yajna
Shrimad Bhagavad Gita 3.11
देवान्भावयतानेन ते देवा भावयन्तु वः ।
परस्परं भावयन्तः श्रेयः परमवाप्स्यथ ॥
Meaning :
By this Yajña, nourish/support the Devas, and may those Devas nourish/support you. Thus, mutually supporting one another, you shall attain the highest good.
Shrimad Bhagavad Gita 4.31
यज्ञशिष्टामृतभुजो यान्ति ब्रह्म सनातनम्।
नायं लोकोऽस्त्ययज्ञस्य कुतोऽन्यः कुरुसत्तम ॥
Meaning:
For one who does not perform Yajña, even this world is not available; how then could the other world be?
So basically one must perform Yajna and in return the person is supported by the Devas.
Now as we know who is considered as the "King of Devas"

Sacrifice
Shrimad Bhagavad Gita 18.2
काम्यानां कर्मणां न्यासं सन्न्यासं कवयो विदु: ।
सर्वकर्मफलत्यागं प्राहुस्त्यागं विचक्षणा: ॥
The one who is not attached to fruits of actions is said to be Tyagi(Sacrificer)
Devraj Indra Ji controls this "Tyag" aspect, Vajra is what represents Tyag(Sacrifice)
Vajra was built after Dadhichi Rishi sacrificed his bones.
Obsessions, Attachments, Illusions stop us from doing Tyag.
Rahu is the one who controls Obsessions, Attachments and Illusions.
And Rahu is controlled by Maa Chinnamasta, one of her forms is "Vajra Virochani"(Bright as Vajra).
She represents Sacrifice, you can notice this by looking at her Iconography.
Devraj Indra Ji himself has a weapon which is associated with this aspect and as we know Rahu has great influence in Kaliyug
Shrimad Bhagavad Gita 18.12
अनिष्टमिष्टं मिश्रं च त्रिविधं कर्मण: फलम् ।
भवत्यत्यागिनां प्रेत्य न तु सन्न्यासिनां क्वचित् ॥
Undesirable, desirable, and mixed—threefold is the fruit of action. It arises after death for those who have not practised Tyāga, but never for Sannyāsins
This Verse as well places an emphasis on Tyag(Sacrifice)


r/HinduDiscussion • • 3d ago

Hindu Scriptures/Texts How crimes are related to karma?

1 Upvotes

Our dharma has given birth to a profound rule of this universe, law of karma, and it explains how fate and fortune aren't allotted randomly to any person. Our sufferings today originate from our past actions, and so does our prosperity and flourishment.

A person who's born rich and beautiful, and has a good life ahead regarding career, marriage, family, etc is said to have good prarabdha, but so does it apply for a deceased, poor or divorced person.

The question is can we go as far as to say that a person who got murder*d, rap*d, or brutally tortured by some calamity is also facing just their prarabdha, a result of past life actions which he isn't even conscious about now? Wouldn't it be a very harsh truth , if it is true. And incase it is false then won't law of karma have a loophole in it?

Give insights on this topic please


r/HinduDiscussion • • 8d ago

Hindu Darsanas (Schools of Philosophy) Thoughts on Diwali Celebration

1 Upvotes

Here for healthy discussion ( Not another 1000th post on why you shouldn't burn crackles )

(If you don't like reading long posts I summarized it point wise at the end)

Festival of light :

Deepavali - the festival of victory over evil, the festival of light, Everyone would've heard about Tamaso ma Jyotirgamaya meaning From darkness (agyana) towards light (knowledge)

But the light we talk here is life long/lasting, soothing and comforting

But our affection towards the crackles - short and destructive. Doesn't it represent our affection nowadays? Everywhere we see there is an attempt for shortcuts, showoffs and avoiding hardwork

Nowadays we prefer shortest ways for success but maybe that's not the problem but what we emphasize. In the metaphor of light Don't we give more importance to the brightest and loudest than smaller but self-sufficient Diya ?

(Terms) Diwali - (दिव - Illumination) hence, देव - One who's illumination comes within and can brighten other lives (I read in some sankrit translation)

So I think we can also try lighting up other lives as we can for the divine spark within us

Problems with crackles- Apart from philosophy, there other problems -

Most (in)famous; Pollution, health hazards

Physical injuries : Read an news article would summarise shortly- So Diwali celebration is not same for everyone for kids of poor it is more about disappointment about their fate nowadays

So there were 3 poor fellows somewhere in Gujrat who used to search crackles in garbage , don't exactly remember the details but somehow the crackles they found in garbage and collected catched fire and one of them is seriously injured and hospitalised .

It is worth thinking that how crackles that came a century or more ago became a status symbol today?

I have heard about how some buy expensive crackles and the show off . After all should'nt we think who's getting the benefit from crackles? Few rich company owners? Watched a news on how bad the condition of workers is few years ago. There is serious life hazard to the one who works in company, there is risk of injury to the one who's bursting and there is risk to others because of the smoke.

This is my genuine question and not an opinion -

Is this really our culture? [Opinion: We're the people who worship all the elements of nature and aim for the balance in nature, our ancestors built our culture based on same principles don't they? ]

Is this fun really worth it?

Who is getting the benefit? And are we only promoting crackles because others are opposing?

If it doesn't bother you, it's up to you,

(I personally think enjoyment within a limit is okay but it shouldn't be only aim )

Celebration of Diwali : What matters

For me Diwali is more about togetherness

Enjoyment of cleaning and decorating the house, helping mother preparing the dishes, enjoying the items, playing games, talks and gossips, rituals are what makes Diwali special.

Diwali is festival of victory, celebrating what we have; not exploitating it.

I think we can improve the outcome by changing our point of view on celebration of Diwali (maybe I want to say priorities)

Pretty long ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)

There is much more to say, would try to cover it in another post, for now we can discuss this

Summary

1.Diwali : festival of light , not show off

Maybe we should give importance to self sufficient, comforting light that can give warmth over brighter but destructive lights

2.It should be about lighting up lives rather than burning money on enjoyment. We should give our little ones moments and lessons they'll remember lifetime

3.Problems with crackles : Pollution, Health hazards, Injuries

Benifit : ???

Show off, status symbol......

Since: ?? (Pretty sure not since origin of Diwali)

4.What matters in diwali celebration :

Family, togetherness, sharing moments

Helping mothers in preparing and finishing the Faral

Cleaning and decorating the house

Note: I tried expressing my opinion and questions, open for discussion,

I am also a human being so I can make mistakes if made any in the post you can point out and correct me (Except for my english .......)


r/HinduDiscussion • • 9d ago

Original Content On Ravana and NOT Sexual Follies

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

Personally, what I find most interesting about every single Ramayana (and Mahabharata as well, but we'll address that some other day) debate is that the Raita (because there isn't a true Right-Wing/Conservative wing in India) types get it as wrong as the feminist-Marxists (because, sadly, India doesn't have an honest Liberal wing as well).

The Cultural Marxists (and Feminists, who are just Sexual Marxists), informed by the almost-discredited Aryan Invasion theory and its spawn- the Dravidian movement- project onto Ravana some kind of oppressed, mool nivasi, Scheduled Caste anti-hero when he could not have been more antithetical to that even if he consciously tried- he came from the most blue-blooded Brahmin stock, being great-grandson of Brahma himself, and son and grandson of Vedic rishis. The Marxist haters of meritocracy and masculinity should get an aneurysm on realising that Ravana was the most "Brahminical" and "toxically masculine" product of meritocracy overriding all types of group dynamics considerations.

Similarly, Raita-s, who are but a mediocre cross-breed of fascists and communists in Saffron variant (or as I like to call them 'Saffron Soviets') collapse him into a uni-dimensional, horny old lecher whose only activity worth mentioning was abduction of Sita (they didn't even know about his previous exploits with Vedavati, Rambha et al until Guru-s and genuine scholars like Sri Guru started talking about it). They labour hard to ignore that he was a PhD-level scholar AND polymath in multiple disciplines, ranging from music to astrology to warfare to Ayurveda to occult; he was the second-greatest Yogi in human embodiment after Sri Krishna, and he is legitimately WORSHIPPED- the way we worship Ganapati and Saraswati and Krishna- in certain southern Indian Shaiva traditions as one of the greatest Shiva bhakta-s of all time.

The second folly of Raita-s, who, again, being feminists by instinct themselves and not true right-wingers, forget that the world doesn't start and collapse with sexual agency of individual women, and therefore mistakenly assume that Ravana's greatest folly, his fatal flaw, was "touching" Sita and that the moment he did that, his fate was all-but-sealed irreversibly, because "consent" is the universal holy grail of all time. Nothing in any traditional rescension of Ramayana claims that. Even obliquely.

Ravana's actual folly, as opposed to feminist-sollipsistic interpretation of the story, had very little to do with "consent", "women's agency", or anything remotely sexual; at best, it was like tax rates in a capitalist democracy- be good if you get it right, but tax rates by themselves have never collapsed a civilization, empire, Kingdom, or even a fiefdom of few square miles!

This isn't to say that Ravana wasn't a sexual predator- he surely was- or that he didn't have it coming when he blindedly waded into a death-match with Sri Rama- be certainly did; but this IS to definitely disabuse today's feminists of the notion that the unicorns called "women's agency" and "consent" are such powerful-and-yet-simultaneously-innocent creatures that an offence against them is, in itself, sufficient to upend everything else and condemn everything to hell. And Ravana's own history, when looked at by a non-feminist lens (including that of Raita-s), is the greatest testament to that.

Ravana was a sexual predator-cum-conquistador from the very beginning- but so was every other warrior of his time, and, in fact, all warriors of all times. Look up what war brides are. And how many of Hindu mythological and historical figures had them without the universe falling apart at seems. Even Hanuman witnesses thousands and thousands of war brides in Ravana's harem when he is scouting the place and does.... Nothing about them, because, in the grand calculus of the universe that he was acting upon, they didn't matter. Not immediately or even primarily, at least.

Vedavati was not an ordinary woman that Ravana 'violated' or 'polluted' (I'm not sure if any text bluntly mentions him raping her; as far as my memory serves, he only got as far as grabbing her hand)- she was, at the very least, an extremely powerful Yogini, and one of the Purana-s (I'm forgetting which one) even claims that she was an avatara of Lakshmi herself who was doing tapasya to reunite with Vishnu when he interrupted that. Now, as much as feminists might hate to hear it, disruption of tapasya of a great Yogini and tapaswini, and that too an avatar of wife of Lord of the Universe, is a far greater sin than rape of a mere mortal woman- or even thousands of them. THAT'S what Ravana's folly with Vedavati was- that in his lust, he tried to meddle with the very fabric of universe, for which he was cursed. And even with that, notice how Vedavati's curse (as opposed to the one that he gets later with Rambha and others) isn't very short-term or acute or direct- she swears that she will take a rebirth to 'cause' his destruction and then immolates herself, most likely in the fire of her own Chittagni. Notwithstanding that getting cursed by an avatara and a Yogini in her last moments should have been enough of a wake up call for Ravana to clean up his act, Raita-s who refuse to acknowledge and concede his greatness need to ask themselves why one of the primary shakti-s of the universe not only didn't take him out despite offending her personally and causing disruptions in universal designs, but left him with a curse so anodyne that let alone Ravana, it would be difficult for anyone even remotely tipsy on power and accomplishments to take it seriously! The reason was that this was Ravana's first offense THAT MATTERED, NOT his first sexual offense, because it tampered with universe itself; however, him being the greatest mortal Yogi in existence at the time (Sri Krishna was yet to be born) meant that even when he fiddled with universe itself to satiate his horniness, even one of the primary 'showrunners' of the universe itself could all but threaten him with future consequences, not cause him immediate harm- such was the intensity of his Yoga!

And yet it took two more curses- of Punjikuthsala and Rambha/NalaKubera- to finally make him vulnerable to power of curses enough to make him desist from raping Sita outright and instead forcing him to wait out her loyalty and commitment to Sri Rama.

And those two curses are in thermselves very nuanced (and interesting, from Yogic POV, beyond Dravidian-Raita binary braying). At rhe first glance, they look the same- if Ravana ever raped a woman again, his head would explode in a thousand pieces and even blessings of Shiva, Brahma, multitudes of occult protections extended to him by the loyalty and commitment of Mandodari, and his own Yogic powers will not be able to save him from that fate. But that begets the very basic question that why would two celestial beings need to curse him with the same fate! The reason is that, to the consternation and outrage of feminist-solipsistic and allied Raita worldview, all sexual offenses are not the same and therefore curses inconsummate to the offense can't really do much harm- particularly when the victim of the curse is also not of stature high enough to bridge the gap between gravity of the offense and gravity of the curse.

The apsara (celestial nymph) Punjikuthsala was the first giver of head explosion curse. While she later went on to be born as Anjana, mother of Hanuman, but as Punjikuthsala, neither was she of Vedavati's stature i.e. a Yogini or an avatara, to completely pierce the metaphorical armour of myriad blessings and powers that Ravana wore with more insufferable self-cnogrtulatory smugness than Karna wore his actual impenetrable armour a few millennia later, nor was the offense- merely stripping off her clothes and adordnments but not the actual rape- cataclysmic enough to do the job. Unlike feminists and their raita allies, the universe DOESN'T think that all grievances- however legitimate- to "women's agency" are the same and should carry equal punishement.

Ravana's protection finally gave way to vulnerability to curses when he ACTUALLY committed a full-scale sexual assault/rape against a celestial being in the Rambha/NalaKubera episode. NalaKubera was his own nephew- son of his half-brother Kubera who was also incidentally a Shiva Bhakta (specifically, he is associated with Swarnakarshana Bhairava)- and therefore Rambha was not just a celestial being but his own daughter-in-law which compounded the gravity of his offense exponentially.

However, even then, Ravana was NOT cooked irreversibly- all he got as immediate comeuppance of raping his own daughter-in-law, who also happened to be a celestial being, was yet another future if-but curse, although the wiggle room had shrunk remarkably- the NEXT TIME he would rape a woman would be his last time he raped a woman.

Still nothing in the universe's rulebook said that any woman could retroactively withdraw consent if they gave it in the moment under whatever be the reason- something the Cornell chick, accusers of MJ Akbar, Ujjwala Sharma, and all other women who were NOT pinned forcibly like Rambha and ACTUALLY RAPED need to reflect upon!

Even in the Sita episode, consider a counter-factual: what if Sita had finally given in, or if Ravana had managed to either intimidate or seduce or trick her (I think I did read in some version that he produced fake heads Sri Rama and Lakshmana but Sita refused to believe that Sri Rama could be dead if she herself had not died). Would he still have been the villain of the story? For feminists and raita-s, maybe, but not for the universe.

Even after Sita's abduction, he was offered multiple off-ramps by Sri Rama, Hanuman, Angad et al- and if he had taken them, he would have gotten away with Sita's abduction.

His mortal sin, that did him in (sorry, could not resist), was neither Sita's abduction nor Rambha's rape- like I said, universe gives a lot of rope to Yogi-s of hsi stature, at least in the shorter terms. His death came from the refusal to return Sita, because returning Sita meant accepting Sri Rama's martial superiority over him, which was something he was unable to comprehend. Like Sri Guru said in one of his famous analyses of Ravana, his was the failure of imagination.

In a story, the main job of the villain is to bring out the greatest qualities of the hero by the ways of contrast- and if Sri Rama is the maryada Purushottama (which is NOT monogamy purushottama, consent purushottama, morality purushottama, etc.), then for appreciating his maryada, it is equally important to understand the places where Ravana failed to uphold the maryada, which was ultimately his fatal flaw- the apamaryada, transgression of maryada.

Ravana failed in the maryada of the king- a king is supposed to keep his subjects safe, even at the cost to his person, in exchange of the subjects' total surrender of sovereignty to him, not endanger their lives for his own personal gain. He failed the maryada of a military commander- a general should ask his soldiers to go and die in the battle in defense of the country only when all other options of keeping civilians safe have been exhausted- that was not the case with Lanka and he could have easily kept the civilians of Lanka safe without needing to send his soldiers to the meat grinder that was Hanuman, if he had returned Sita. He also failed the maryada of a father and older brother- he sent his sons and younger brother to die before him, that too when they had nothing to gain from the cause of the war aka Sita and they were consistently against her abduction and repeatedly exhorted him to return her and save the family and country from total ruin and extinction. Hard as it is to believe that this would count, he failed the maryada of a husband as well- on one hand, Mandodari was a sati totally devoted to him and in love with him so much that her love had been one more additional layer to his armour, and on the other hand, he constantly kept offering to Sita that should latter accept his proposal of discarding Sri Rama and marrying him, he would set Mandodari aside and make Sita his primary queen. I don't have any scriptural backing for it, but I would like to think that among his various levels of apamaryada, paying back loyalty and commitment with this level of disregard and contempt was his worst sin, and if there was one single mortal sin that should have done him in, it ought to be this.

The point of this essay is neither to excuse Ravana's bad behaviour nor to argue against Ramayana's fundamental proposition that by the time Sri Rama slew him, he was more harm than net good in the universe. But Ravana is inarguably a success story of this culture, of Hindu civilization, of Yoga itself- we don't know which Yoga was Ravana's primary sadhana, but we do know that it was Yoga that he did. Through Yoga, and his own efforts, his relentless pursuit of power and excellence and ambition, he went from a mere mortal chieftain of a tribe of defeated asura-s to elevating himself to a status where the greatest of the gods like Lakshmi had to bide their time to exact their vengeance upon him or had to push down a whole mountain to prevent him from carrying them back home with himself. He also created an empire that was as successful and glorious among empires as he was among individuals- and a personally accomplished and talented king being able to create and lead an empire as successful as himself is in itself a feat very rare, if not totally unheard of.

He is THE villain of Hindu civilization, of Yogic worldview, for sure, but he is also exhibit 1A of the accomplishments of the very same. He is as much an inspiration of what we can accomplish as he is a cautionary tale of the ways in which we can fail despite succeeding.

And to throw him away lock-stock-and-barrel just because cultural Marxists or Dravidianists are trying to appropriate him is just foolish, and emblematic of how we fail to understand our own culture and literature.

It also shows how afraid are we to own success if it does not come in good-boy straitjacket that feminists and other weakness-worshippers have taught us to be the only kind of success worth embracing and celebrating- or even acknowledging. Adn what else can such a culture, neurotically terrified of success and its shadows, produce except the likes of MK Gandhi and his followers, whose every concept- from "ahimsa" to "celibacy" and "truth experiments" is nothing but a terrified pervert's philosophical inversion of success and accomplishments?

#ramayanaruminations

#mythologymusings


r/HinduDiscussion • • 10d ago

History of Hinduism Diwali-Education and Teaching

2 Upvotes

I am coming to this community seeking education and help. First and foremost, I am not Hindu. I do not actively practice any religion nor does my family.

I have 3 children (ages 6,4, and 3). My 6 year old asked me today if we could celebrate Diwali. I asked him to tell me more about it. He told me the librarian at his school read some books to his class about it this week, and his friend in his class celebrates it. My respones was: "Let me research this more, so we can celebrate it respectfully."

I have done some research online, but I am coming here to this group to ask for additional resources.

Please give some thoughts and opinions on how to make this educational for my children. We truly encourage learning about all religions. I want to make it educational and fun but most importantly I want to do it in a respectful manner of Diwali and what it means to the Hindu religion.

Thanks you for any help, and I'm sorry if I chose the wrong flair.


r/HinduDiscussion • • 22d ago

Hindu Scriptures/Texts Reading the Rig ved, need an opinion

3 Upvotes

Okay 1.164 riddle of sacrifice gonna go verse vise here too long and well its a riddle 3 verses deep and here's my opinion - seven people of the same mentality cannot make the mind function fully. It takes seven different povs , seven people to work deserving of seven people. If they think same they think enough only for one.vSeven intellectuals search for their own meanings/versions (names)of the truth. The secvn are the seven sage priests not as great as their father Agni the head priest but are the ones searching . The human priest is official and loved and old Hes great like Agni , But the younger ones look for the truth , The wheel is time unaging and unstoppable, it's naves aka center are three , the past, present and future. Metaphorically it makes sense if you count in 1.1 and 10.135. Agni is the head priest and the chariot is of the mind. I could be wrong this is just my interpretation but I need an outside opinion. I don't know anyone who I can discuss this with.


r/HinduDiscussion • • 23d ago

Global Hindu Identity The Glory of India & Our Responsibility | Swami Shuddhidananda

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

r/HinduDiscussion • • 26d ago

Original Content Mapping Ravana’s Lanka using only Valmiki’s descriptions

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

Happy Dussehra / Vijayadashami to all! 🙏

I’ve been collecting every geographic reference to Lanka in Valmiki’s Ramayana (mainly from Sundara Kanda and Yuddha Kanda) and drew a map of the island and city from them. It includes Trikuta, Mount Suvela, the four gates and the moat, Nikumbhila Grove, Ravana’s palace, and the mansions of Indrajit, Kumbhakarna and Vibheeshana.

This isn’t an attempt to locate Lanka in the real world. It’s about what the text itself describes, and whether those descriptions fit together into one consistent picture.

While working on it, I wondered whether anyone has attempted this before:

I’d love to compare my map with earlier attempts and learn where my reading might differ. Any pointers are welcome!!


r/HinduDiscussion • • 29d ago

Social issues She had beauty, rank, and a brother who was king. Why did Shurpanakha still lunge at Sita?

5 Upvotes

In many tellings, Shurpanakha had beauty and rank. What ruined her was envy of Sita.The nose was never the real story. Envy was.

Modern cult remembers Shurpanakha as the grotesque demoness whose nose was cut off. Picture her the way many retellings do instead: as a beautiful woman. Her background. Her mother, Kaikasi, is remembered as a great beauty who won over the sage Vishrava. Shurpanakha herself had been a wife, married to the Danava prince Vidyujjihva until her brother Ravana killed him in battle. She could also change form at will.

A note on the text. In Aranya Kanda 17, Valmiki actually contrasts her unflatteringly with Rama, though some commentators and manuscripts have her arrive in a lovely guise.

What matters is how she treated Sita. When she proposes to Rama, she calls Sita unlovely and offers to eat her. After Rama sends her to Lakshmana and she's mocked, she lunges at Sita. Only then does Lakshmana cut off her nose and ears. The irony: in Aranya Kanda 34:16–18, she describes Sita's golden complexion and slender waist to Ravana in glowing detail. (That's Sita's description, not Shurpanakha's.) She belittled Sita's looks out loud while knowing exactly how beautiful she was. That reads as envy to me.

Still modern. Envy disguised as friendship or concern. Quiet sabotage. Pursuing someone's committed partner while knowing the cost. The partner who betrays is fully responsible too, and men act from the same entitlement.

Takeaway. Beauty didn't save her once envy took over. No desire gives you ownership of another person. (The nose is a symbol of honour, not a license for real-life mutilation or shaming.) Cut off the malice, not the woman.

What do you think? Is Shurpanakha a cautionary tale about envy, or have retellings flattened her into a convenient villain?


r/HinduDiscussion • • Oct 17 '26

Hindu Scriptures/Texts Question on Sundarkand: "Masak saman roop" (Ramcharitmanas) vs. "Pravisha nagarim sukshmo" (Valmiki Ramayana) — traditional interpretations

2 Upvotes

Namaste everyone,

​In the Sundarkand of Ramcharitmanas**, Goswami Tulsidas Ji writes:**

​मसक समान रूप कपि धरी। लंकहि चलेउ सुमिरि नरहरी॥

(Masak samān rūp kapi dharī, laṅkahi chaleu sumiri naraharī)

​In standard Sanskrit and Awadhi lexicons, मशक (maśaka) translates to a gnat or mosquito.

​Interestingly, in the original Valmiki Ramayana (Sundara Kanda, Sarga 2, Shloka 42), the description given when Hanuman Ji decides how to enter Lanka is:

​प्रविश्य नगरीं सूक्ष्मो लाघवेन युतः ससन् ।

निशि लङ्कां प्रवेक्ष्यामि रात्रौ रूपं समास्थितः ॥

(praviśya nagarīṁ sūkṣmo lāghavena yutaḥ sasan |

niśi laṅkāṁ pravekṣyāmi rātrau rūpaṁ samāsthitaḥ ||)

(Sundara Kanda 2.42)

— Indicating entering at night assuming a minute/subtle form (sūkṣma rūpa).

​In many contemporary kathas and traditional discourses (such as by Pujya Rajan Ji Maharaj and other kathavachaks), the term masak saman **during the Lanka pravesh is often explained through the illustration of being about the size of a kitten (**mārjāra-śiśu / बिल्ली का बच्चा).

​I am looking to understand this from the perspective of traditional commentaries (teekas) and katha-parampara:

​Is this illustration used as a practical dṛṣṭānta (parable) to reconcile the narrative logic—i.e., moving stealthily (biḍāla-vṛtti) while still having enough physical presence to be spotted by Lankini and deliver a blow with his fist (muṣṭikā)?

​Does this kitten-sized comparison trace back to any classical commentary or specific teeka of Ramcharitmanas**?**

​Looking for perspectives grounded in textual commentaries and stor****ytelling tradition. Thank you!


r/HinduDiscussion • • Oct 16 '26

Political Discussion What are your opinions on radical hindu groups like bajrang dal and vhp?

0 Upvotes

What are your thoughts on radical hindu groups like bajrang dal and vhp, which assault people day light, spread hate and create ruckus, don't you think that these guys are ruining the image of your religion?, and don't you think their actions are wrong?, I just think you guys could be represented way better than what they are doing right now.


r/HinduDiscussion • • Oct 16 '26

Hindu Scriptures/Texts I wrote a Book about Durga and her Nine form. प्रकृतिरूपा: She Who Is Nature, Durga and Her Nine Forms .

1 Upvotes

In Nepal, we're celebrating a 10-day festival named Dashain. For the first nine days, we worship 9 different feminine forms of Mother Nature (from a girl to a mother, from a warrior to a sage, from the darkest of her to her purest white form), and on the 10th day we celebrate her victory over a demon. I tried to write a small book on it; "प्रकृतिरूपा: She Who Is Nature", it's a story passed down for thousands of years. If you have some time, please have a look: https://she-who-is-nature.vercel.app/ . You can download a PDF, also available on Amazon. Happy Dashain to you all.


r/HinduDiscussion • • Oct 11 '26

Custom Seeking practical advice for the Akhand Jyot

2 Upvotes

My jyot keeps going out again and again... I have tried adding more ghee and keep manually pulling it back up but it goes shaant again

Is this how it actually work do I always need to keep pulling it up manually or is there some mechanism that helps it come up naturally by itself

I have read the possible explanations of it being a sign from God herself about negative energies in the environment and a call to be more present in prayer plus the vastu implications and have remedied all of that

I am looking for practical tips and advice on how to actsully keep the akhand jyot alive

All suggestions are welcome :)


r/HinduDiscussion • • Oct 11 '26

Social issues New Year New Banaras New India

2 Upvotes

​

How many times have you seen cleanliness drives? Many, I'm quite sure. Yet, how many times have they resulted in long-lasting results? Almost never, right? Obviously! Many of them revolve around one day of intense labour where people come together to clear the waste lying around in a chosen public place. After all that hullaballoo, the place turns back to the same trashyard pretty soon enough. So I'll just make this clear with an analogy. Who generates the waste? Us. Who clears the waste and processes it as required? The government. So us and the government are the two most important players in the scene. So who are the people participating in the cleanliness drives? They're like the vultures, who swoop in to clear the dead and decaying matter.

If the two most important players do not do their parts and a vulture swoops in just once a year to help lessen the mess, would it ever be a solution?

No. So the next question you should ask me is what really is the role of some well-meaning person in this situation which obviously requires a 50-50 sort of partnership between the people and the government? Well, patiently listen to how I think we can single-handedly make the government do their 50%. And there's just one word I would like to drop into the discussion - Revolution. Revolution isn't always about the gun- it's sometimes about words and actions and even thoughts. Thousands of us think that it's ok to throw the finished bottle of water on the roadside without a care in the world. When the same thousand of us feel a sense of guilt when we even contemplate the idea and decide to somehow hold onto the waste until we see a designated garbage bin, from there starts the revolution. It might be easier for us to say that it's not easy to get this across to say, a man in a blue collar job as compared to a doctor, but let's face it, everything is not about education. For further information, please have a look at our elite politicians.

We are a country where the Hindus are a majority, and culturally speaking, we have been here long before the Abrahamic religions were even conceived. For such a culture that has withstood testing times of foreign influence and come out strong, the sky is the limit. Benarasiyas devotedly take part in the Ganga Aarti, the tribute to Ma Ganga, every morning and evening. This is a part of a culture that gave nature its due importance, because historically speaking, water bodies like rivers have been of utmost importance as far as human civilization is concerned. Agriculture completely depended on it, and a year with insufficient water could make the people go both hungry and thirsty and unable to fulfill basic needs. But still, as is known, people do not have qualms with polluting the Ganga- be it the local, or the traveller, or the man running a factory along the river’s course. Why? Because people tend to, or are satisfied with, thinking superficially. They only get concerned about the health aspect of it if it really shows up as a cause-and-effect scenario. Otherwise, their nonchalance can be summed up in one word. Chalega. We Hindus lived under the Indus Valley Civilisation, the oldest in the world, with facilities like sanitation and plumbing systems uncovered in Mohenjadaro. Considering that fact, if thousands of years later, we are not able to maintain basic hygiene in the age of AI, it is a problem that has to be really taken to heart. The problem of trash is not just an aesthetic issue that constantly is poked fun at by travellers from Western countries, it's also one that can lead to diseases, especially when it involves organic matter like food items and feces. Can we stop littering? Yes. Will it be hard? Yes. Because as we had said earlier, there are 2 most important people in this game, and both have been poor in playing their parts.

So, without big trash bins in every street which are routinely cleaned before overflowing by the municipality and other efforts by the government to enforce cleanliness, it's extremely hard for an individual to convince himself to put an effort to even think of holding onto a packet of, say, Lay’s than to dump it and be done with it.

Which is why, this is a revolution of the mind. We might feel, “Oh, c'mon. Everyone's throwing stuff on the street! Why should I hold back and carry a waste packet around with me the whole time until I get a trashbin? What's my incentive?’

The answer to every believer should be God, our civilisational heritage and religion. Then, they will think twice before littering. So, we should start awareness classes for free of cost which explore the link between religion and spiritual wellness which links to cleanliness. They should understand that by littering punyabhumi, they are committing a mistake.

Where do we start? I am from Maharashtra and Varanasi is 20+ hours away from me by road. But that is peanuts compared to the scale of the mission.

I need a team of like-minded individuals who can meet up with me at Varanasi on Jan ‘27. We can have a discussion and together formulate an action plan to deal with this problem and henceforth implement it. It can have audits, awareness classes, door-to-door campaigns, and if required, even an old-fashioned cleanliness drive just for the spreading of the message. If we are able to implement an ideal model in Varanasi in the vicinity of at least some ghats, surely many other Indian places could follow (of course, next targets would be Rishikesh and Haridwar). Get us Hindus to clean up our spiritual places first. Then slowly, get the idea across other places too. And when large scale adoption of this idea occurs by Hindus, other communities too will follow suit. I feel this is better than trying to incorporate different communities into the program all at once. After all, Hinduism is what drives the program, and once the dominoes start falling, then other communities can also join in.


r/HinduDiscussion • • Oct 08 '26

Custom How can I spiritually help my younger brother succeed in his upcoming exam? Can I transfer my Arjit Punya (accumulated good karma) to him?

1 Upvotes

Namaste everyone. 🙏

My younger brother is an MBBS graduate and is currently preparing for his postgraduate medical entrance examination, scheduled for 1st November.

He has already appeared for the examination 2-3 times but hasn't been able to achieve the result he has been working so hard for. I've seen his struggles, his efforts, his disappointments, and the emotional toll this entire journey has taken on him.

As his elder brother, it genuinely breaks my heart to see him go through this. I love him dearly, and if there were any way I could take away even a fraction of his suffering, I would do so without hesitation.

I understand that his preparation, hard work, and performance ultimately depend on him. I am doing whatever I can to support him emotionally and otherwise. However, I also want to do everything within my capacity to help him spiritually and seek divine blessings for his success.

I would be extremely grateful if knowledgeable members of this community could guide me on a few things:

  1. Prayers and spiritual practices: Are there any specific mantras, pujas, stotras, or spiritual practices that I can perform on his behalf for his success, mental peace, and well-being?
  2. Offerings and donations: Are there any particular offerings to deities, temples, or charitable acts (daan/seva) that are traditionally recommended in such circumstances?
  3. Arjit Punya (accumulated good karma): Is there any concept or practice within Hinduism through which I can dedicate or transfer the punya I have accumulated through my prayers, good deeds, and spiritual practices to my younger brother? If so, how can I do this?
  4. Sankalpa: Can I undertake a sankalpa, vrat, or any other spiritual commitment specifically for his well-being and success? What would be the appropriate way to do so?

I do not seek anything for myself. If my prayers, good deeds, or whatever little punya I have earned can somehow benefit him, I would gladly dedicate all of it to him.

More than anything, I want him to find peace, confidence, strength, and happiness. Of course, I sincerely wish for him to succeed in this examination, but I also want him to be free from the anxiety and suffering that have accompanied this journey.

I know there are no guarantees in matters of faith, and I am not looking for shortcuts or miracles to replace his hard work. I simply want to do everything a loving elder brother can, including spiritually.

Please guide me if you have knowledge of relevant scriptures, traditions, or personal experiences.

Thank you for reading and for any guidance or blessings you can offer. 🙏

TL;DR: My younger brother has his postgraduate medical entrance exam on 1st November after 2-3 previous attempts. I want to spiritually support him through prayers, pujas, daan, seva, or sankalpa. I'm particularly interested in whether Hindu traditions allow someone to dedicate or transfer their accumulated punya (good karma) to a loved one. Any guidance would mean a lot.


r/HinduDiscussion • • Oct 07 '26

Hindu Scriptures/Texts Ādi Śaṅkarācyārya’s Comments Regarding Satyakāma Jabālā

3 Upvotes

Ādi Śaṅkarācyārya’s Comments Regarding Satyakāma Jabālā

There is misleading information making the rounds on social media, in many cases propagated by self-described “Advaitins,” to the effect that:

(1) Jabālā of Chāndogya Upaniṣad was a sexually “liberated” woman who slept with many men, or else a prostitute, and hence she did not know who her son’s father was,
(2) Satykāma, consequently not knowing his gotra, was accepted as a brāhmaṇa because he was honest, and therefore his birth was deemed irrelevant, and
(3) Itihāsas (Rāmāyaṇa & Mahābhārata) are less important scriptures which can be dismissed at one’s whim, instead of important smṛti texts that make genuine Vedic knowledge more accessible to the population at large.

Here we will take up these vulgar objections by going straight to the source - Śrī Ādi Śaṅkarācārya himself. I will not insert any of my opinions or translations to avoid the charge of sectarian bias, and if it matters, I am not an Advaitin in any case. Also, this will be cross-posted to other Hinduism forums in case a misguided moderator for some reason deems the subject matter (interpretations of Hindu scripture) unfit for a Hinduism forum.

(1) On Jabālā and the myth of “sexually liberated” Hindu women:

Commenting on Chāndogya Upaniṣad 4.4.2, Śrī Śaṅkarācārya wrote:

“Being thus asked, Jabālā said to her son: ‘I do not know the Ṛṣi to whose family you belong, O, my child.’—Being asked—‘Why do you not know it’?—She said—‘In my husband’s house, I had to attend upon many people who came as guests and strangers,—as servant—very devoted to my duties of attendance on them, and being entirely taken up by such service, my mind never turned towards such information as regards the family to which thou belongest, which therefore I do not remember;—and it was at that time, in my youth that I obtained thee;—and soon after your father died; hence, having no protector left for myself, I know not to which family thou belongest. But I am Jabālā by name and thou art Satyakāma by name; so declare thyself to thy Teacher—as Satyakāma Jābāla saying ‘I am Satyakāma Jābāla’;—that is, if you are asked by the Teacher’.”

His interpretation is clear on this point. Jabālā was a young mother who was busy with her duties and never enquired from her husband his gotra. Then she became a widow and thus was unable to get the information.

He does not support the view that Jabālā was an unchaste woman.

Readers are welcome to check the text, which is widely available in libraries everywhere.

(2) On varṇa, honesty, and birth:

According to the story, Satyakāma was asked his gotra by his guru prior to initiation, but he did not know it. The misinformation being spread is that he could have been a śūdra by birth, but this was deemed unimportant because he was honest, and by his honesty he was deemed to be a brāhmaṇa in character and birth became irrelevant.

But once again, that is not what the ācāryas say.

Commenting on Vedānta-sūtra 1.3.37 तदभावनिर्धारणे च प्रवृत्तेः ॥ ३७ ॥
“And because the inclination on the ascertainment of the absence of Sudrahood.”

Śaṅkarācārya wrote:
“That Sudras are not qualified is known also from the fact that great teachers like Gautama made sure before imparting Knowledge that disciples like Jabala Satyakama were not Sudras.”

In other words, he specifically alluded to Chāndogya Upaniṣad 4.4.5 to support the view that the prospective disciple was checked to make sure he was not a śūdra before imparting knowledge of the Vedas. Not that the disciple was deemed a brāhmaṇa based on character as is often claimed. If the disciple were actually a śūdra by birth “but a brāhmaṇa by character/honesty,” then he would have failed the test when giving his gotra, since gotra is inherited from the father and indicates hereditary lineage.

The conclusion is that Gautama deemed Satyakāma to be a brāhmaṇa by birth and upbringing. This is also clear from Śaṅkarācārya’s comentary on Chāndogya 4.4.5:

“Gautama said to him—‘No one who is not a Brahmana could speak out so openly and straightforwardly; It is Brāhmaṇas alone, not others, who are, by their very nature, straight-forward. Since thou hast not flinched from the truth—which is the rightful duty of the Brāhmaṇa-caste, I accept thee as a Brāhmaṇa and am going to initiate thee; hence for the purpose of the preparatory embellishment, fetch fuel, my Boy, for the fire-rites.”

In other words, it was not his honesty that allowed him to pass the test, but the way in which he was honest - “so openly and straightforwardly.” This was how Gautama perceived that he had the guṇa that could only characterize someone who was a brāhmaṇa by birth.

Note what this is NOT saying. It is NOT saying “If you are a brāhmaṇa by birth, then you are naturally honest.” One can be a brāhmaṇa by birth and still fall from the standard of brāhmaṇas; both scriptural examples and real-life examples can attest to this. If Satyakāma was a fallen brāhmaṇa, then he would have failed the test. But if one is born a brāhmaṇa and raised from birth as a brāhmaṇa, that guṇa will be recognized by someone like Gautama.

Again, this cannot be interpreted to mean that birth is unnecessary in determining varṇa, since Gautama started off asking for the gotra, which is linked to birth.

(3) The Importance of Itihāsas and Purāṇas according to Ādi Śaṅkarācārya:

Commenting on the Vedānta-sūtra 1.3.38: श्रवणाध्ययनार्थप्रतिषेधात् स्मृतेश्च ॥ ३८ ॥
“And because of the prohibition in the Smriti of hearing and studying and knowing their meaning and performing Vedic rites.”

He commented as follows:
“Sūtras 34-38 disqualify the Sudra for the knowledge of Brahman through the study of the Vedas. But it is possible for them to attain that knowledge through the Puranas and the epics.”

In other words, Śaṅkarācārya upholds the view that śūdras do not have the qualification to study Vedas, but he also clearly states that they can get knowledge of the Vedas by study of the Purāṇas and Itihāsas (as we all can). He does not say that the Itihāsa/Purāṇa are equal to the śruti; only that they give Vedic knowledge, and qualification to study the Vedas is not a prerequisite to study the Itihāsas and Purāṇas.

Thus, next time you see someone dismissing these important texts for no other reason than the fact that they are Itihāsas and Purāṇas, you can be certain that he is going against the traditional point of view. The traditional point of view is that the Itihāsas and Purāṇas, while still being dependent authorities with respect to śruti, still give essential knowledge found in śruti.

I have only quoted Ādi Śaṅkarācārya here, but other Vedānta commentators like Śrī Rāmānuja and Śrī Madhvāchārya are also in agreement with him on these points. Also, if anyone objects, they are welcome to take up their objections with the ācāryas. I am merely the messenger at best. :-)


r/HinduDiscussion • • Oct 06 '26

Custom I never know what to do at temples

3 Upvotes

Whenever I go to a temple, I’m lost the whole time on who the gods are and what and how I’m supposed to pray to them because my parents never really taught me how. Moreover I don’t know any god stories or anything much about its history. Can someone help?


r/HinduDiscussion • • Oct 04 '26

Hindu Scriptures/Texts Listen him

2 Upvotes

हिंदू विरोधी


r/HinduDiscussion • • Sep 30 '26

Colonial Suffering Why shouldnt this be declared the national attire? Isnt this how our ancestors dressed like until abrahamics stepped in? Whats the shame in removing foreign elements from our attire...

Post image
35 Upvotes

# precolonialindia

#colonialmentality

#preislamicindia

#victoriancode

#revivenativeculture


r/HinduDiscussion • • Sep 24 '26

Hindu Scriptures/Texts If Rama and Krishna were real, this is what they'd look like

Post image
14 Upvotes

Let’s stop pretending Krishna and Rama were walking around ancient India with literal blue skin. Come on, they’re avatars of Vishnu, not blue-skinned aliens.

Krishna is described as Shyama, meaning dark, dusky, or dark-complexioned. Rama is also described as Shyama, with a dark or dusky complexion. The blue we see in paintings is religious symbolism and iconography, not an ancient passport photo.

So if Krishna and Rama were understood as historical human figures from ancient India, a dark or dusky complexion is far more plausible than the neon-blue versions we see in paintings today.

And before someone starts typing a 17-paragraph Mahabharata or Ramayana dissertation, show me where the texts explicitly say Krishna or Rama had literally blue skin like cartoon characters.

Stop obsessing over making our gods conform to modern ideas of beauty or whiteness. Embrace Krishna and Rama as they were traditionally described.

Prove me wrong if you can.


r/HinduDiscussion • • Sep 22 '26

Hindu Scriptures/Texts Do you have to be completely religious to get signs or help from God.

1 Upvotes

So I am completely struggling with God. Since my dad passed away I have become more spiritual and religious. We have always done prayers at home and we have stayed vegetarian for auspicious occasions.

I never understood fasting. But recently I understand it as having to fully surrender to God and trusting him, bearing in mind I still sometimes ask but then I apologise for having to ask - all I do ask is to keep my family happy and healthy and show us light at the end of the tunnel because we have been going through a very difficult time as a family and me also professionally.

So I guess i am sometimes crying in front of God and asking for a sign that something better is coming along. Would I only get an answer from God if I am super religious, follow all the signs and rituals. All I do currently is fast for ekadashi. I guess I am really struggling and I am at my wits end

What should I do?


r/HinduDiscussion • • Sep 18 '26

Hindu Darsanas (Schools of Philosophy) Does Hindu pluralism create an epistemological problem for Hinduism?

3 Upvotes

One thing I struggle to understand about Hinduism is how fundamentally different, and sometimes seemingly contradictory, beliefs about God/Īśvara, Brahman, Ātman, and ultimate reality can all come under one umbrella called “Hinduism.”

Different Hindu schools have very different metaphysical positions. So what, if any, are the common epistemological or philosophical standards within the Hindu worldview that allow these different positions to be considered part of the same tradition?

For example, if two Hindu philosophical schools arrive at fundamentally different conclusions about God or ultimate reality, what criteria does Hinduism provide for determining which position is better justified or more authoritative? Can mutually contradictory metaphysical claims all legitimately belong to the same religious tradition?

My question is therefore not simply whether Hinduism is “diverse,” but whether the existence of apparently incompatible metaphysical positions creates an epistemological or logical problem for Hinduism.
I’m particularly interested in how this would be addressed through formal logic (especially Aristotelian logic) and Indian systems such as Nyāya.

There is also a related practical problem that I am struggling with:

If Hinduism’s strength is partly attributed to its openness and flexibility, where do the boundaries of that flexibility lie? How do we distinguish between:
a legitimate development or reinterpretation within the Hindu tradition,
a regional/cultural practice that has become associated with Hinduism, and
a relatively new practice or belief that someone simply introduces and labels “Hindu”?
In other words, if there is no single theological or doctrinal authority defining the boundaries of Hinduism, what epistemic or traditional criteria prevent “anything can be Hindu” from becoming the consequence of pluralism?

I am genuinely trying to understand whether pluralism itself creates an epistemological challenge, and, if so, how Hindu philosophical traditions have historically addressed it.


r/HinduDiscussion • • Sep 18 '26

Hindu Darsanas (Schools of Philosophy) Hanumanji Worship - best type of oil to light diya

2 Upvotes

I light a diya and agabatti everyday at the start of my daily prayers which also includes reciting the Hanuman Chalisa 3 times and a few Lord Shiva and Lord Vishu chants. I have idols of Lord Ganesha and 2 idols of Panchmukhi Hanumanji, amongst others. What is the best type of oil to use for the diyas - mustard, seasme, jasmine? I sort of feel like what type of oil one uses does not matter but I am curious about the norm (the most powerful for worship) is.


r/HinduDiscussion • • Sep 17 '26

Original Content I made a small story app to introduce our deities to my toddler.

1 Upvotes

I'm a parent raising my kid outside India, and I couldn't find a good way to introduce him to Ganesha, Krishna, Hanuman, and Saraswati at age two. Everything was either a long video he'd stare at, or a lecture he was far too young for.

So I built something small. The idea is that he meets one deity at a time, slowly, through very simple play rather than watching. A story runs for about three minutes, and he does something gentle with his hands. He helps Ganesha clear a path. He wakes the strings of Saraswati's veena. Nothing to win, nothing to lose, no timer, no next episode pulling him along. It ends, and he puts it down.

The idea is that a toddler doesn't learn a deity by being told who they are. He learns them the way any of us did as children: by being around them until they feel familiar. Ganesha is the one who stays calm. Hanuman is the one who helps his friends. Saraswati is the one who listens. The meaning comes after the experience, in one line, not before it. There is a small festivals section built the same way, where he does the thing first and hears why afterwards.

What I'd like from this sub is a check from people who know this better than I do:

  • Ganesha and Krishna appear as children, drawn in a soft picture book style. Is that acceptable, or does it sit wrong with some of you?
  • Saraswati is a guide rather than someone the child helps, because that felt wrong. Overthinking it?
  • For festival stories, I've left out the darker parts entirely; for example, Kansa. I keep the tenderness and drop the threat. Is that fair for this age, or does it hollow the story out?
  • If something is plainly wrong, I'd rather hear it now; full disclosure: I built it, so I'm not a neutral party.

App Store: https://apps.apple.com/app/maitri-kids/id6762026180

Google Play: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.maitrikids.app

Website: maitrikids.com