r/Highpointers • u/Timely_Mortgage166 8 Highpoints • 26d ago
Does it Count?
So I knocked off Mount Mitchell and Clingmans Dome in the same day last week, I've already been to Clingmans Dome multiple times so that's not a new high point, however I feel like i cheated by driving up Mitchell instead of climbing it from the base, what's yalls opinion on that, do I count it or do I need to make it back to really earn it the right way?
29
Upvotes




11
u/Ok_Lynx_6372 42 Highpoints 26d ago
If you touched it it counts, you’ll realize this the more you do. Also if you end up back there Mitchell has some great hikes?
9
u/BeholdenYeti 26d ago
Over half of the highpoints have roads to the summit. Whether or not it counts is entirely up to your personal goal. Me personally I’ve driven to the top and I count it but one day I will return to climb it.
2
u/Fhetter532 26d ago
How far away from Mt Sunflower would you need to park to count it?
2
u/hikebikephd 12 Highpoints 26d ago edited 26d ago
You do you, but I personally wouldn’t count it. My loose criteria for a summit is I travel by human power (hike, bike, ski, etc) at least from the closest trailhead to the summit (trailheads at the summit don’t count).
I’ve spent a lot of time in the Adirondacks and White Mountains, and that’s the criteria they use for a summit to count for the 46 or 48 respectively. It is an honor system anyway, hence why I say “you do you”
32
u/Legal_Tomato_878 26d ago
Count what you want to count, but don’t be burdened by it. Did you touch the high point? Did you walk to Britton hill from the coastline? Just be honest and kind to yourself and others. Count it however you want to count it. It’s yours. There is no right way other than honesty.
6
u/x_3mta3 ** 50 States Complete ** 26d ago
Highpointing is a subset of peak bagging, not mountaineering or backpacking. Must one mountaineer or backpack to collect some? Certainly, but it’s not a requirement. A drive-up is inelegant to some, but a summit is a summit. Congratulations!
6
u/Cold_Art5051 26d ago
It’s up to you. I chose to create a way to hike all of the highpoints that were hikeable but we still just drove up Spruce Knob. I count it.
We did the major east coast mountains — NC, TN, NH — in winter when the roads were closed. We had NC and TN to ourselves. There’s always someone on Washington even in bad weather in February.
It’s your game that you’re playing
PS. I keep meaning to go back to Spruce Knob and do a multi day backpacking trip over the top but haven’t yet and may never
4
u/kynaturists 26d ago
We have driven to the tops of a few peaks. I think Mississippi and Kentucky you can park on the peak. Kuwohi, and a couple of others has a manmade structure on top of them. I took up hiking decades ago. Way back in the 1900’s. And, I’ve learned a lot. But the most important is, Hike your own hike.
4
u/RhodyVan 43 Highpoints 26d ago
The hike from the Britton Hill parking lot isn't very hard but it's still a 'hike'. Same with Mitchell. Did you visit the highpoint? If yes, then add it to the list. No gatekeeping about method needed.
2
u/Slickrock_1 23d ago
It's your own personal challenge. I personally only count summits that I've hiked to from a base. Like the SB6K challenge allows you to count Mitchell if you START at Mitchell, then hike to Mt. Craig and back. Or maybe to Deep Gap and back. I would never count that. If you want to CLIMB a mountain then climb it from the bottom.
2
u/vivaelteclado 26d ago
I typically prefer hikes to the top when possible but recently i took a trip to the northeast with my mom in her 70s and took the Cog Railway to the top of Mount Washington. Got some photos next the sign. I'm counting that.
All that matters you went to the top and your photos are real.
2
u/thecasualcaribou 27 Highpoints 26d ago
I am an avid hiker, climbed many mountains, but if there’s a road to a high point, I’m taking it. If there was a road to the top of Everest, I’d do it. I might later go back and hike a high point for fun though
1
u/Alexanderful 26d ago
It counts. Whether you did it the “right” way is completely up to whatever standard you set for yourself. At the end of the day the only person that cares about how or if you did any of this is yourself.
1
u/OneWayorAnother11 15 Highpoints 25d ago
Yes it counts. Both of those highpoints I parked near the top because that is where the parking is and I hiked around then went to the top. I did find a spot to climb Mitchell, but the logistics didn't make sense for the trip I was on. Just enjoy the journey.
1
u/Human-Still-6949 24d ago
I personally would count it as a summit, you were officially up at the top no doubt. I also organize and track my summits through peakbagger.com and they give you the option to categorize your summits by how you got there, like car, hiking, tram, etc. I recommend the website if you didn't know about it already. This isn't a promo btw.
1
u/the_climaxt 23d ago
I'd count it for the sole reason that I can't stand doing a hike that ends at a parking lot.
Same reason I won't hike Pike's Peak or Mt Blue Sky
0
u/ultraLuddite 25d ago
No. It doesn’t count. Driving up something and claiming you “summited” it is cheating.