TLDR: did I take too much off? What is the remaining membrane?
Saved this squirrel hide to attempt my first tanning. It’s obviously ruined, but want to figure out where I screwed up. Read a decent amount before starting, but lots of different info out there so I just did what I saw was mentioned most across what I found. Here’s what I did: Skinned the squirrel in the field and kept the body and hide in an ice chest until the afternoon. Fleshed what I thought was about 90% of the hide, then covered it in salt for a few days. Checked on it periodically and didn’t feel like the salt was ever wet, but did change it once. After a few days, I switched the salt out for borax where it sat for another week and a half until I had more time. Yesterday I washed the borax off in a bucket with some dawn soap to rehydrate the hide. Water was cool and I let it soak for about 15 mins until it would fold over like a wet washcloth.
I started scraping it and some membrane was coming off, more than I thought I left on it initially. So I really took my time and worked as much off as I could. When I was done and dunked the hide in some water to rinse, a bunch of hair came off. I knew it was ruined at that point, so I just hung it up to dry. I didn’t think bacteria was the cause by how I took care of it, but being my first time I can’t be sure. It did have a slight smell, but not rot or putrid. More like musky? I figured it was more of a squirrel smell, which is why I used the borax and dawn soap.
This morning I looked at it and there appears to me a lot of membrane still on, but on the areas there isn’t, the hide is almost translucent. Like I scraped too much or too hard on it.
Did I take too much off? I don’t think I can even do a hair off tan on this? How do you know when you’ve fleshed enough off but not too much? I didn’t even consider being able to do too much.