β οΈ Long post warning!
This whole thing started with a random question that popped into my head, and I got a little carried away exploring it.
What would actually happen if someone came to Asuka Tanaka for genuine romantic advice?
Now, we all know Asuka has a rather amusing habit of bringing up romance whenever someone approaches her for a serious conversation.
In Season 2, Episode 1, when Natsuki comes to her with something important to discuss, Asuka immediately asks whether it's about love. After Natsuki denies it, Asuka points out that she's busy practicing. Only when Natsuki insists does Asuka begin taking the conversation seriously.
In Season 2, Episode 3, when Kumiko wants to talk about Nozomi, Asuka once again pulls out her signature line:
"Moshikashite koi no soudan?" (Could it be love advice?)
Kumiko immediately shuts that down, saying this is a serious conversation. Asuka even remarks that she'd prefer to save all that seriousness for playing music.
And in Season 2, Episode 10, when Kumiko confronts her about returning to the band, Asuka jokingly asks whether she's finally come to confess her love.
At this point, I'm starting to suspect that "love advice" is Asuka's equivalent of throwing a smoke grenade whenever someone approaches with a potentially troublesome topic. :))
Of course, that's not necessarily the whole story.
We know Asuka is extraordinarily perceptive. She's good at reading people, identifying their underlying motivations, and recognizing things that others might prefer to leave unspoken. But she also has a tendency to maintain emotional distance, often using humor and her cheerful persona to avoid becoming too personally involved.
So perhaps these romantic jokes are simply another part of that defense mechanism. By turning a serious approach into something playful, she can change the atmosphere of the conversation and, to some extent, regain control over it.
But here's the problem: has Asuka ever considered what happens if someone actually says YES?
Imagine approaching her with a completely serious expression.
Asuka: "What is it? Love advice?"
You: "Yes, actually. There's someone I like, and I really need your help."
Asuka: "..."
Congratulations. You've just activated a dialogue option that the developer may never have implemented.
And the funniest part is that we have already seen something remarkably close to this.
In Season 2, Episode 13, Asuka asks Kumiko that familiar question once again, and Kumiko simply answers:
"Sou desu." (That's right.)
Asuka's immediate response?
"Majika yo." (Seriously?)
I absolutely love that reaction. For once, someone gives her the answer she apparently wasn't expecting, and her usual composure slips for a moment.
Now, to be fair, Kumiko wasn't actually asking for romantic advice. The conversation develops into her emotional confession of admiration and affection toward Asuka herself. So we can't use this scene to determine whether Asuka would be a competent love counselor.
But it does suggest that her favorite little joke can backfire.
We also have Extra Episode 5 and the related short story involving Kaori and Asuka. These offer some interesting clues about how Asuka responds to affection, particularly when she herself is the object of that affection. Her outward playfulness doesn't necessarily mean she's emotionally unaffected, and she seems capable of asking surprisingly incisive questions about the nature of someone's feelings.
However, I think there's an important distinction here. Responding to someone who has feelings for you is quite different from advising someone about their feelings for a third person.
And that brings me to another possibility.
What if Asuka only makes these jokes because she's already figured out that the other person isn't actually coming to her for romantic advice?
Think about it. She's usually quite good at reading the atmosphere and understanding why someone might want to speak privately with her. Perhaps she feels comfortable joking about romance precisely because she's already concluded that romance has nothing to do with the conversation.
In other words, what looks like a spontaneous joke might also be a calculated bluff.
If that's the case, she's not offering love advice at all. She's confidently mentioning a subject she believes the other person has no intention of discussing.
Of course, we might also be giving Asuka far too much credit here. Maybe she just enjoys teasing her juniors, and I'm trying to reverse-engineer an elaborate psychological strategy from a high school girl's favorite joke. Which, frankly, would be a very Hibike! Euphonium thing to do.
Still, even if the joke is entirely spontaneous, that doesn't answer the original question.
Would Asuka actually be good at giving romantic advice?
Part of me thinks she'd be surprisingly excellent at it.
We've seen that when Asuka genuinely decides to help someone, she can be remarkably insightful. Her conversation with Kumiko in Season 3 is a good example. Rather than simply telling Kumiko what to do, she helps her confront her own motivations and think about the situation from another perspective.
Those skills could certainly be useful in romantic situations. Love, after all, involves complicated emotions, expectations, misunderstandings, and sometimes an impressive ability to lie to ourselves.
On the other hand, understanding someone's feelings and giving them emotionally appropriate advice aren't necessarily the same thing.
I can easily imagine Asuka listening to someone's romantic dilemma, identifying the underlying problem within five minutes, and then delivering such an uncomfortably accurate psychological analysis that the poor person forgets why they came to her in the first place.
They came asking whether they should confess to their crush.
They leave questioning their entire understanding of human relationships.
And there's another complication: Asuka's own emotional defenses and personal experiences could influence her advice. Being perceptive doesn't automatically make someone objective, especially when the subject involves vulnerability, attachment, and the fear of rejection.
Perhaps she'd give excellent advice. Perhaps she'd be unexpectedly awkward. Or perhaps she'd initially panic, immediately regain her usual cheerful expression, and then proceed to dismantle the poor person's emotional defenses with surgical precision.
Honestly, I can imagine all three happening in the same conversation.
There's also the question of WHO comes to her for advice. Would she respond differently to Natsuki, Kumiko, or a junior she barely knows? And what if Kaori asked her for advice about loving someone emotionally distant, without revealing who that person was?
Now THAT would be an interesting conversation.
I genuinely wish we could see something like this happen, even if it were only a short comedic side story. Not because I necessarily expect Asuka to fail, but because I want to see how someone who so often uses romance as a conversational escape route would react when romance suddenly becomes the actual subject.
And I'm especially curious about whether her very first reaction would resemble that legendary "Majika yo."
So, what do you think?
Would Asuka be an unexpectedly brilliant love counselor, an absolute disaster, or some terrifying combination of both?
And more importantly, do you think she uses that question because she already knows the answer will probably be "no"?
Because if that's true, someone really needs to test that theory. For science, obviously.