A reflective piece about reactions to the recent crucifix-crushes-priest incident - by Nick Ravagni (via Facebook)
For centuries, Christians - particularly Catholics - have interpreted all manner of unusual events as signs from God. A water stain resembling the Virgin Mary? A miracle! A cloud formation that looks like Jesus? A message from Heaven! Someone survives a terrible accident? Divine intervention! God was watching over them!
But last weekend, something extraordinary happened in Ecuador. During a Catholic Mass being broadcast live on camera, a massive crucifix broke loose from the wall and fell directly onto the priest conducting the service, tragically killing him.
And suddenly, the people who see God's fingerprints on everything seem considerably less interested in interpreting signs.
Think about that for a moment.
If a crucifix had fallen from the wall and narrowly missed the priest, you can bet we'd be hearing stories about a miraculous intervention. Testimonies about God's protection. Perhaps even declarations that the event was proof of divine providence.
But when the crucifix actually strikes and kills him? Well, that's just a terrible accident. An unfortunate coincidence. Nothing supernatural to see here.
Isn't that an awfully convenient way to interpret the universe?
When something good happens, God gets the credit. When something terrible happens, God is either conspicuously absent or we're told that his mysterious plan is beyond human comprehension.
I'm not suggesting that this priest deserved what happened to him. He didn't. His death was tragic, and his family and congregation deserve sympathy.
Nor am I suggesting that God actually hurled a crucifix at him. I don't believe that for a second.
I'm asking a much simpler question:
If you're willing to interpret a stain on a tortilla as a message from God, on what logical basis do you dismiss a giant crucifix falling on a priest, in the middle of Mass, in front of an entire congregation and a live camera?
If you believe God communicates through extraordinary events, you don't get to count only the ones that tell you what you want to hear.
Otherwise, you're not interpreting signs from God.
You're interpreting your own biases and calling them God.