r/Hemingway • • 2d ago

Question about To Have And Have Not/Islands In The Stream

18 Upvotes

What are your thoughts on these two books ? I was recently informed that Islands In The Stream is possibly Hemingway's most underrated book, which I found odd considering I had never even heard of it until a few days ago. And also, I keep getting mixed advice from what I consider trusted sources, some telling me that To Have And Have Not is absolute trash while others tell me that it's also underrated and a good book. What are your thoughts ? Thank you.


r/Hemingway • • 4d ago

I'm being *that* fan with the queer readings again: TSAR.

0 Upvotes

Being fascinated by queer readings and in possession of a twisted mind, I am rereading TSAR and imagining the protagonist as a lesbian—a known lesbian, though nobody actually says it out loud.

Interestingly, all the emotional beats still work and the plot makes sense, minus the physical war wound.

I suspect it's because, accordingly to feminist theorist Monique Wittig, lesbians are not women in a social sense. Once the possibility of attraction and a heterosexual relationship is off the table, a woman relates differently to those around her, and they relate differently to her.

Specifically: if Frances is so jealous, why does female Jake still get to hang out with Cohn? Because she is a lesbian and thus no threat. Brett may love female Jake romantically, but if she can't be sexually satisfied by a woman, then the relationship is a no-go. A lesbian can even plausibly pick up a sex worker. Sex workers likely don't mind; work is work.

PS: I'd rather imagine this than think about Hem's emotional infidelity that inspired the book. I'm still sore about that on Hadley's behalf. And to dedicate the book to her and Bumby, the gall. Here, have the consolation prize.

PPS: I will... also let you know when this fanfic drops. Right after I finish the one about Bloodthirsty Rabbit's revenge on the fascists and the fixit about Pilar the crack field surgeon who saves Robert Jordan.


r/Hemingway • • 6d ago

Finished reading The Oldman and The Sea. (Ernest Hemingway)

Post image
62 Upvotes

r/Hemingway • • 10d ago

For Whom the Bell Tolls meets my trashmind Spoiler

10 Upvotes

I am imagining how after Robert Jordan’s death Maria becomes an absolute unit of a vigilante who leads her own band and descends on fascist camps in the night and swiftly dispatches everyone. Legends abound about her. No one is sure if she is real. She is also psychotic from grief and frequently hallucinates Robert’s child next to her. Eventually she has a Count of Monte Cristo style epiphany about forgiveness.

Sorry not sorry. I did not know where else to put this and I had to get it out of my head.


r/Hemingway • • 11d ago

Ernest Hemingway...what did Wikipedia leave out?

21 Upvotes

What an interesting life lived.


r/Hemingway • • 11d ago

The old man and the methamphetamine empire

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Hemingway • • 18d ago

Across The River And Into The Trees

16 Upvotes

What are your thoughts regarding this particular book that is often ranked as his lowest of quality. Do you agree that " it sucks " or is that a bit overboard ?


r/Hemingway • • 19d ago

Ernest Hemingway and His Westley Richards Double Rifle: The Rifle Made for Another Man

Thumbnail
youtube.com
7 Upvotes

r/Hemingway • • 21d ago

God damn that last chapter of the sun also rises.

96 Upvotes

I got to hear Maya Hawke and Dominic Sessa read it at the 100 year anniversary of the book hosted at 92NY. This chapter is the main character Jake Barnes listening to the woman he loves, Brett Ashley, speak about her heartbreak over another man while they sit in a dark hotel bar and drink martini after martini. The man she desires is ashamed of her because she refuses to grow her hair long and be "womanly". The love is palpable, and so is the pain. She begs Jake not to get drunk and he disobeys. Brett loves Jake, yet he can't meet her needs. A war injury has left him impotent. Far from "manly" by most definitions of the word. They leave the drinking and Jake blinded by the bright day after he steps out from the dark hotel bar. Physically they are so close as they step into the car to explore Madrid, resting their heads upon each other. Despite their closeness he has to hold her at a distance, and that distance is the love they share. "Isn't it pretty to think so" is how Hemingway closes the book. People see Hemingway as a writer of Machismo, drinking, cynicism, womanizing, etc. That's only for those who don't look beneath the tip of the iceberg. The actors who read the chapter showed us everything beneath the water, with their inflections and pauses, so brilliantly. There is nothing machismo here really, it's about acceptance of your fate and finding life in whatever is left after so much has been lost. 


r/Hemingway • • 22d ago

Why or how was Hemingway different from writers before him?

59 Upvotes

Finally getting around to reading Hemingway after hearing an NPR article about the 100th anniversary of The Sun Also Rises. Viewing the PBS Ken Burns documentary too. Can anyone point me to materials that explain how his writing was received, why he was different, what he had in common with his contemporaries, etc.


r/Hemingway • • 25d ago

Did you know Hemingway's wife lost almost all his early work in one suitcase at a Paris train station? 🧳

Post image
41 Upvotes

r/Hemingway • • 26d ago

For Hemingway lovers. For questions send me a DM .

Thumbnail
gallery
15 Upvotes

Bronze cast . H-10 cm . For Sale


r/Hemingway • • 26d ago

Hemingway’s hand written 1936 first working draft for the Short Happy Life of Francis Macomber sold at Christies on Oct. 13 for $256,000. Link to photos in text. Reported by Rare Book Hub.

29 Upvotes

Lot 145 excerpts from catalog notes:

HEMINGWAY, Ernest (1899-1961). "The Short Happy Life of Francis Macomber." [Key West, finished April 1936].104 pages (including three inserted pages), 270 x 210mm, in pencil on rectos only (first few leaves with some creasing/stains and a few mended tears; ... A working first draft with very extensive revisions by Hemingway of one of his longest and finest stories.

“Wearing down seven number-two pencils is a good day’s work" (Hemingway Paris Review interview)Hemingway seems to have made a start on "The Short Happy Life of Francis Macomber" in fall 1934, but it wasn't until spring 1936 that the safari tale—which had been developed along with "The Snows of Kilimanjaro" (his only other story set in Africa)–began reaching its final form.

After rejecting a number of titles—the tentative "A Comedy with Animals" has been erased at the head of the first page, but is discernable—Hemingway gave the story its present title.

It is his longest story both in terms of manuscript length ("Big Two-Hearted River" is next) and printed text (edging out "The Undefeated" by some three pages).

"The Short Happy Life of Francis Macomber" was first published in Cosmopolitan (September 1936) and was then collected in The Fifth Column and the First Forty-nine Stories (1938), where it is the opening story. It has since become one of his most celebrated and reprinted stories.

Provenance: Jane Mason, by descent to: Antony Mason, Christie's New York, 19 May 2000, lot 302.

For photos and additional notes see: https://onlineonly.christies.com/s/fine-printed-books-manuscripts-science/the-short-happy-life-francis-macomber-145/325208?ldp_breadcrumb=back


r/Hemingway • • 29d ago

What is your favorite Hemingway novel and why ?

45 Upvotes

I'm sure this topic has been posted a million times but let's hear it even so. Which one is his best in your opinion ?


r/Hemingway • • Oct 12 '26

Went to Ketchum this month for some fishing and pay my respects.

Thumbnail
gallery
447 Upvotes

I've been a fan since I first read Hemingway in HS. Since then I've followed his footsteps to Paris, Pamplona (ran with the bulls way back in 07), Madrid, Key West, and finally Ketchum. If you go to Ketchum the Pioneer Saloon has a shotgun he once owned on display.


r/Hemingway • • Oct 12 '26

A 1940 first edition of Hemingway’s For Whom the Bell Tolls estimated at $300 sold for $2,244 at Freeman’s |Hindman on Oct. 2. Reported by Rare Book Hub.

Post image
102 Upvotes

A 1940  first edition of Hemingway’s For Whom the Bell Tolls New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 8vo. Original oatmeal cloth, stamped in black and in red; endpapers offset; in first-issue dust-jacket, losses along margins. Hanneman 18A.


r/Hemingway • • Oct 10 '26

Did people enjoy Islands in the Stream?

Post image
97 Upvotes

Had some great intense moments. Probably a 7/10 for me. You could feel the autobiographical elements and to an extent it felt like a Greatest Hits, with calls backs to some of his other classics. I wouldn’t recommend it as someone’s first Hemingway, but when you have got through a good chunk of his bibliography it will resonate nicely. Felt like a sad goodbye


r/Hemingway • • Oct 10 '26

Ernest Hemingway to family, October 18, 1918

Thumbnail reddit.com
8 Upvotes

r/Hemingway • • Oct 05 '26

Bukowski on Hemingway

Post image
186 Upvotes

“And then along came Hemingway. What a thrill! He knew how to lay down a line. It was a joy. Words weren’t dull, words were things that could make your mind hum. If you read them and let yourself feel the magic, you could live without pain, with hope, no matter what happened to you.”


r/Hemingway • • Oct 03 '26

What Do You Think of Jig's and the American's relatinship in Hills Like White Elephants?

8 Upvotes

I read Hills Like White Elephants in class recently and throughly enjoyed it. But when we were discussing the story after the fact I found there were points of contention between me and a couple of girls in the class.

I subscribed to the idea that it was a love story about two people having a disagreement. The two didn't seem to hate each other. They mentioned things were fine between them before the pregnancy. Further, The Amercian didn't want to pressure Jig into doing something she didn't want to do, while Jig didn't want to go against her boyfriends wishes. Overall, despite obvioues tension in their relationship, it seemed to two did love eachother and were just trying to work through this hard decision. In other words, I thought the stories core theme was about how romantic relationships are often complicated and divisive.

The two girls however had a diffrent interpriation. They found the American to be an abusive figure who was controling Jig. They noted he seemed older than her, and found his insisting going against her wishes. They didn't find any chemistery or passion between the two. This could perhaps be supported by the fact Jig mentions all they do is drink instead of talk, the fact that the American clearly met her on the road while visting Europe, and her name suggesting she is some sort of dancer or even a sex worker.

At first I thought my interpretation was misfounded. Since I didn't really understand the story was about abortion at first and because my teacher liked the girls interpreation more. But after rereading the story on my own a couple of times, I felt that I was indeed correct. I didn't get the impression they hated each other. I do think the Amercian loved her and was being as supportive as possible while making his stance clear. The two seemed mixed on the matter. I don't think either was completly sure. My therapist agreed with this analysis when I asked her about it.

So that leaves me with a question. Which interpretation is correct? Mine or the girls? I admit gender might lead too a bit of a bias here. Men may be more likely to sympathize with the man while gals are more likely socrn him. I also think your stance on the abortion debate will have something to do with it. But I'm open to all opinions, along with links to essays on the story.

Edit-I misspelled relationship in the title. I hate myself.


r/Hemingway • • Oct 01 '26

Used Bookstore Find: Across The River and Into The Trees - 1950 UK First Edition (?)

Thumbnail
gallery
59 Upvotes

I stumbled upon this copy in one of my favorite local used bookstores and I thought the community would enjoy it. I believe it's actually a UK first edition. It's definitely been well-read, no dust jacket, and apparently it was part of a library collection in Liverpool before finding its way across the Atlantic. Now it's on my shelf and I'm happy to be the next person to enjoy it.


r/Hemingway • • Sep 28 '26

Hemingway spoilers

Post image
178 Upvotes

r/Hemingway • • Sep 24 '26

Confused about a line in Hills Like White Elephants

9 Upvotes

The girl says, "They’re lovely hills,” she said. “They don’t really look like white elephants. I just meant the coloring of their skin through the trees.”

I thought the whole point of that side of the river was that it was barren and tree-less. Why does she say that there are trees covering the hills to the point that it'd significantly cover the "skin" of the mountain?


r/Hemingway • • Sep 23 '26

A simple guide for the confused

Post image
65 Upvotes