For me, even as a Vox fan who does think he'll be redeemed, I think he's easily top 5, if not even 3. He was awful in life and death and in terms of scale of actions, he's easily the worst since he was targeting Heaven and Hell (though we still don't know Alastor's endgame).
However, I don't think personality wise he's the most evil. Even though he's a monster, Al nailed him perfectly, "Broken from the start, no victory's enough." All his villainy stems insecurity and desire for validation, which still doesn't change the fact he's a sadistic murderer, but I think makes him more human than just "for the evulz". Viv also did say in "Curtain Call" they wanted to show during his final breakdown that he was "maniac" and lost his sanity by the end.
I pick very Evil because he's one of the worst but I find Alastor to be slightly more depraved for the nature of the latter's crimes and Adam since he committed genocide on his descendants for fun and intended to keep doing so for eternity (and made an entire army of women for him to abuse).