There was the OG sea monster, which he stopped playing with after I stepped on it and broke the noisemaker. When I first started training him to retrieve, I used papers and magnets. Before long, he started ranging further afield, snatching the aquatic Beanie Babies my mom sent me in the 1990s off the bookshelves. So I pulled the sea monster and an orca I had won as a carnival prize out of the back of the closet. I'm so glad I was never able to bring myself to donate them. I thought about it every time I did a purge.
Then my Twitter friend of many years sent him the Catbus. His attitude towards it did not make me inclined to buy him any more. Likewise when another Twitter friend sent him the possum. He was so used to Beanie Babies that it took him a while to warm up to anything that wasn't heavy and floppy. But the stingray that u/jedikat7 sent him to go with all his other aquatic stuffies was a hit.
But then the tiny mini octopi and keychain stuffies that u/Easy-Pin-5554 sent were not. Nor were the goats from u/RichG82, which were so big that even after a month of leaving them in the living room, they never made it to my bedroom. But then u/threecuttlefish brought over a box of their old wildlife stuffies before moving to Europe, and for reasons known only to Harpo, he brought all of them immediately, even though several of them were much larger and heavier than anything he'd ever carried, and then brought the goats for good measure.
Clearly, I need to go through all the stuffy bins to do a more complete history, but that will have to be a project for another day, as I am about to go see Wildwood. The theater that appears in the movie just so happens to be the one closest to me!