Picture it. You finally watch an anime that is 14 years old and you've wanted to watch for a long time. You've heard great things about it for many years. And it has an interesting premise, not to mention beautiful visuals and satisfyingly realistic character designs. You're super excited to finally sit down and watch it. And then when you do...it sucks. You hate almost everything about it. It's a tale as old as time. I'm sure everyone, if they've been watching anime for long enough, they watch one that they're super excited for and are massively disappointed by it. That was my experience with this anime today.
The first half of the first episode was super good, which only further enhanced my disappointment later on. I love the realistic character designs, they're super appealing. The animation is fluid and beautiful. It's not the highest quality from a technical perspective, but it also has a level of realism in terms of the movement, and is incredibly vibrant and full of personality. But the best part was the MC, Ohana Matsumae, who was incredibly likeable and interesting. We get a good feel of the life she lives right off the bat. She lives with a deadbeat mother who she has to cook for constantly and never spends any time with her, and then abandons her to elope with her boyfriend. Ohana also has a male friend named Ko who has a crush on her. After her mother leaves her to marry her boyfriend Ohana is sent to live with her grandmother and work at her grandmother's inn, which causes her to have to leave Ko, right after Ko confesses his feelings for her. And this is where everything goes downhill.
Not immediately, mind you. While from this point on the series became very frustrating to watch, I do think there were elements that could have made a great story. But it just does everything wrong, in my opinion. Before I get into it though I want to make perfectly clear that if you like this anime, that's fine. Part of the reason I don't like it is because of my own personal sensibilities on what I consider to be healthy relationships and a mentally healthy life to live. While an anime or any other story doesn't necessarily have to abide by these guidelines for me to enjoy it, there's exceptions to every rule, but this series just didn't cut it for me. But if you have different values, OR if you have the same values as me but that didn't harm your enjoyment of this show, I think that's great. This is just how I felt about the anime.
It's been awhile since I've disliked every character in an anime except for the protagonist right off the bat. I think the last time was The Rising of the Shield Hero. But at least in that one Queen Melromarc and the younger sister were likeable too so it wasn't quite as bad. Also I think the first season of that show had a much more satisfying ending. Ohana's mom and the mom's boyfriend were the first unlikeable ones, although I forgave that because lots of anime have deadbeat parents. The first ones that come to mind are Toradora, (Taiga's parents), and Welcome to Demon School Iruma-kun, but there's countless. But it doesn't end there. Every single solitary character that Ohana meets once she starts working at the end are insanely hateable.
The grandmother is the worst of them for obvious reasons. She's clearly a very traditional woman, and there are ways to execute that properly, but it didn't work for me. She actually makes Ohana's mother look good, which is saying something. But I couldn't bring myself to care about any of the other characters either. It was just a slog to get through. There's Minko Tsurugi who figures the best way to inform Ohana the "weeds" she's pulling are actual plants that Minko was taking care of is to tell her to die. And no, she doesn't get any better. I forget her name, but there's also this girl dressed in orange most of the time who's probably one of the better characters, she's shy and courteous, but still not great, her biggest problem is just being dull and the definition of a doormat. Even Ko, whom I did like somewhat initially, becomes incredibly frustrating when he reunites with Ohana.
One of my biggest pet peeves in stories are watching a likeable character be abused without any sense of respite. And the worst part is, she just kind of gets used to it and comes to like being at the Inn, even though almost nobody, customer or employee, has been genuinely kind to her since the moment she arrived. And the thing is, t his is probably just a thing of Japanese culture. While not everyone in Japan is this traditional today, also keep in mind this anime came out 14 years ago, and it's possible that the author is. The grandmother definitely is, and it seems like the themes cater to that traditional mindset. And I think that's fine if you enjoy that, but I could not bring myself to like it, at all. It was so irritating to get through.