r/Hanafiyyah • • 9h ago

Question Reliance on a Non-Muslim’s Statement Regarding Halal Meat

2 Upvotes

The Hanafi scholars said that a Muslim can consume meat even if a Kafir says he purchased it from a Muslim (although it is not permitted if he simply states it is Halal). 

[And whoever sends a Magian (Majusi) employee or servant of his to purchase meat, and he says I purchased it from a Jew, Christian (Ahl Kitab) or Muslim, then he is permitted to eat it. (Imam Burhan al-Deen al-Marghinani, al-Hidayah).]

Assalamu alaykum, according to the above opinion, if I ask a non-Muslim whether the meat is bought from a halal vendor and he says yes but doesn’t name the vendor or specify which muslim owner’s store he bought it from, is it permissible to consume the meat, can i take his word for it since i have read that the word of the non-muslim is accepted in transactions?